!!! This text was extracted from an image and needs proofreading !!!
(November, December 1894; February, April, August 1895; February, March, April, May, June, July, August, September, October, November, December 1896; January, February, March, April, May, June, July, August, September, October 1897)
Publications:
- The Path, vol. IX, no. 8, November 1894, pp. 254-258
- no. 9, December 1894, pp. 286-289
- no. 11, February 1895, pp. 349-352
- vol. X, no. 1, April 1895, pp. 19-23
- no. 5, August 1895, pp. 157-160
- no. 11, February 1896, pp. 329-332
- no. 12, March 1896, pp. 361-366
- Theosophy, vol. XI, no. 1, April 1896, pp. 1-6
- no. 2, May 1896, pp. 33-34
- no. 3, June 1896, pp. 65-70
- no. 4, July 1896, pp. 97-99
- no. 5, August 1896, pp. 129-134
- no. 6, September 1896, pp. 161-168
- no. 7, October 1896, pp. 193-198
- no. 8, November 1896, pp. 225-232
- no. 9, December 1896, pp. 257-261
- no. 10, January 1897, pp. 292-298
- no. 11, February 1897, pp. 322-327
- no. 12, March 1897, pp. 353-359
- vol. XII, no. 1, April 1897, pp. 1-7
- no. 2, May 1897, pp. 33-36
- no. 3, June 1897, pp. 65-68
- no. 4, July 1897, pp. 179-181
- no. 5, August 1897, pp. 241-244
- no. 6, September 1897, pp. 300-305
- no. 7, October 1897, pp. 375-380
Read:
CTD entry in Russian: Кейтли, Джулия
DATA
Title for references: Keightley J. - On the Screen of Time
Short description: The November 1894 installment uses the image of a river readjusting its course around obstacles to r...
The June and July 1897 installments are both signed "E. T. H."; the July installment is unsigned by a printed title of its own (as with several other installments in this series, it opens the issue without a decorative title, identified here purely by its running header "The Screen of Time" and by the issue's table of contents) and is divided by asterisk dividers into four short unsigned items, on the magazine's successful enlargement and the "Notes on the Crusade" series, on lynching and capital punishment, on self-sacrifice in republican government, and on human responsibility and the "no such thing as chance" principle, closing with a note on Nikola Tesla's wireless telegraphy experiments as an illustration of mankind's undeveloped latent powers. Transcription note: the opening masthead epigraph on p. 65 (from Emerson's The Over-Soul) and the standard "society is not responsible..." disclaimer paragraph are dropped from this Text page per the series' convention, kept as a separate front-matter fragment. Signed "Julius"; the February 1895 installment is followed by an open letter from Ernest Temple Hargrove, signed "Che-Yew-Tsang", revealing and explaining his use of that pseudonym. The February 1896 installment is signed "William Q. Judge" rather than "Julius", and the March 1896 installment, announcing the magazine's change of name to Theosophy, is unsigned but by the same hand. With the April 1896 number the magazine itself became Theosophy; that installment is signed in full "William Q. Judge" (written before his death on March 21, 1896, and appearing in the first number issued after it); the May 1896 installment is signed only "T."; and the June, July, August, September, October, November, December 1896, January 1897 and February 1897 installments are all signed "E. T. H.", the July installment, however, embedding a quoted shipboard account signed "M. H. Phelps" and an account of the Liverpool meetings signed "Herbert Crooke", the September installment embedding an account of the work in Ireland signed "J. H. Fussell", and the January 1897 installment embedding an open letter to The Times of India signed by Bertram Keightley and Upendra Nath Basu on behalf also of H. S. Olcott, A. P. Sinnett, G. R. S. Mead and Annie Besant, a reply letter signed by E. T. Hargrove, Claude Falls Wright, H. T. Patterson, F. M. Pierce, Leoline Wright, W. Williams and Alice L. Cleather, and a letter from Claude Falls Wright to Mrs. Annie Besant. The December installment is dated "Red Sea, nearing Aden, 17th October, 1896."; the January 1897 installment is dated "Jeypore, Rajputana, 8th November, 1896."; the February 1897 installment is dated "Colombo, December 13th, 1896."; and the March 1897 installment is signed in full "E. T. Hargrove." (also embedding, mid-article, a passage sub-signed "E. T. H." and dated "S. S. Oceana, nearing Albany, December 23, 1896.") and is itself dated "San Francisco, February 13, 1897.", closing with special thanks to J. H. Fussell for keeping the magazine running during the Crusade. The April 1897 installment (the first in the new volume, no. 1) is divided by internal asterisk dividers into several short unsigned items and closes with the dateline "Indianapolis, Indiana, March 20th."; unlike every other installment in the series, no name or initials appear at its end in the OCR text, so no signature has been added here — the attribution to the author of this page follows the issue's table of contents, which credits it to "E. T. H." Transcription note: the phrase "removing all traces of his Wanderers" (p. 4) is almost certainly an OCR misreading of some other word (possibly "slanders"), but has been kept as printed, since the scan is unclear and no confident correction is possible without a facsimile check. The May 1897 installment is signed "E. T. H." and comments on the forthcoming third annual Convention, the doubling of the magazine's size from the June number, an appeal for reader feedback, and the changing climate of orthodox Christian opinion on hell and damnation (quoting Dr. Lyman Abbott). Technical note: the opening drop-cap "T" of "The third annual Convention..." is rendered in the OCR as "HE" with a stray "J" bleeding onto the next line; both artifacts have been silently corrected as a routine drop-cap scanning defect, consistent with practice elsewhere in this series. The word "religious" in "all the other religious of the world" (p. 36) is almost certainly a scanno for "religions" and has been corrected as such. The August 1897 installment opens the issue without any printed title or sub-heading of its own (unlike most installments, identified here purely by its running header "The Screen of Time" on p. 243 and by this project's own analysis of the issue, since no readable table of contents survives for this number) and is divided by an internal asterisk divider into three unsigned items, on the new International Brotherhood League founded by Mrs. K. A. Tingley, on an anonymous "science of vibration" interview reported in the Chicago Times-Herald, and on the virtue of moving slowly and clinging to principle during a "season of many changes." Transcription note: the closing initials are printed, as best as the scan can be read, "E. T. KI." — almost certainly a scanno for "E. T. H.", the signature used by every other installment in this series from June 1896 onward, including the installments immediately before and after it; rendered "E. T. H." here on that basis. Transcription note: the two asterisk-divider rows in this installment are printed as "****$*" and "******" respectively (stray OCR noise around the asterisks); both are rendered as the series' usual "* * * * * * *" divider. The September 1897 installment likewise opens the issue without any printed title of its own (identified by running header and by this project's analysis of the issue, no table of contents surviving in readable form) and is divided by asterisk-row dividers into several unsigned items; the first portion, ending in a signature "E. T. H." before a divider, discusses shipboard life as an epitome of the world and the rarity of visible spirituality or decision of purpose in human faces. A second, longer portion then follows the same divider, covering the International Brotherhood League's work (its meeting at the Lotus Home on 8 August, the assassination of the Spanish Premier Canovas del Castillo, the Bureau of India Relief and Famine Fund's work at Benares, and Dr. Robert A. Gunn's free treatment of alcoholism at a new East 14th Street centre) and closing with a different, separate signature, "J. H. F." (almost certainly J. H. Fussell, the magazine's business manager, several times credited elsewhere in this series' notes with keeping the magazine running during the Crusade, and with reports from Ireland and elsewhere); this is transcribed exactly as printed, with both signatures preserved distinctly, rather than silently harmonized to the usual "E. T. H." of the rest of the series, since nothing here suggests the second signature is an OCR error for the first — it is a different two-letter initial set appearing cleanly in the scan. No corresponding footnote or note in the magazine explains the dual authorship within a single department instalment; it may reflect a guest contribution appended to Keightley's own, as elsewhere in this series (cf. the embedded, separately-signed accounts credited to M. H. Phelps, Herbert Crooke and J. H. Fussell himself in earlier instalments), but is merged into this same continuing-work page per the project's standing convention for this department, on the explicit instruction accompanying this issue's preparation. The October 1897 instalment, this issue's own table of contents crediting it in full to "E. T. Hargrove" (not merely "E. T. H." as in most earlier instalments), likewise opens without any printed title of its own and mixes several items without clear internal dividers: a tribute to the late E. B. Rambo (of the School for the Revival of the Lost Mysteries of Antiquity), unsigned, with a half-tone portrait; a short paragraph on the Stockholm Convention of the T. S. in Europe (referring the reader on for fuller detail to the "Mirror of the Movement"); a comic interlude consisting of a letter of thanks to a departed member who had amused readers with absurd extracts from correspondence, followed by one specimen letter (addressed "To the Editor" and signed only "Yours forever,", with no name given) written, as printed, in broken English purporting to translate a Russian original; and finally the correspondence surrounding E. T. Hargrove's resignation as President of the Theosophical Society in America and as editor of Theosophy — his own letter of 29 August 1897 to the membership, his follow-up letter of 1 September 1897 to the Executive Committee (explaining that Vice-President E. Aug. Neresheimer's willingness allowed him to resign at once rather than in April as first planned), E. Aug. Neresheimer's reply of 9 September 1897 accepting the resignation on the Committee's behalf, and Hargrove's own closing paragraph announcing that Katherine A. Tingley and E. Aug. Neresheimer would become co-editors of Theosophy from the November issue, dated "10th September, 1897." and signed in full "E. T. Hargrove." Transcription note: the specimen "Russian" letter is printed with several evident OCR/typesetting peculiarities ("/treophical" for "Theosophical") reproduced as printed, since the letter's broken English is clearly intentional on the magazine's part and not a scanning artifact as such; only the single clear OCR letter-substitution has been corrected. Immediately followed in the scan by an unsigned quotation headed "The Soul" ("Free Translations from the Chinese"), kept as a separate fragment for the future Text page rather than as part of this instalment (see issue7_vol12_soul_quote.wikitext).
254
On the Screen of Time.
The whole phantasmagoria is only a picture thrown up against the Screen of Time by the mighty magic of Prakriti (Nature).
The various portions of the world-screen portray the Theosophical movement as proceeding with unchecked, even increased, activity. As in the course of every river, yes, even to the smallest rivulet, impediments arise, deterrents temporarily fill the bed or swerve the course, so in this movement many a change occurs.
Yet there is always readjustment, and, with that, the increased momentum observable when a pent-up force frees itself and breaks away, carrying with it the debris which it scatters and dissolves. There is a change, and yet no change. The goal is ever the same, for in the great course of evolution
Even the weariest river
Winds somewhere safe to sea.
But what the laws of motion do for the streams, the laws of mind must do for thoughtful man, for man earnestly applying himself to the study of Law with Nature and her eloquent analogies for guide. Such men readjust their course with care. Not the triumph over obstacles, not the elate sense of power evolved, of a strong, free, onward progress, is suffered to deflect their course or to swerve the calm mind from its outlook over men and things. The impediments, whether they arose from circumstance or from fellow-men, are viewed as teachers, not as foes, once they are removed, once their restraint or their opposition is removed. Karmic agencies all of them, none can impede the course unless by our own concurrence or submission. All, if we ourselves pursue unaltered the path of inaction in action to the Unknown Sea, have rather assisted by aiding in the development of latent powers of persistence, of resistance to the invasion of foreign motive, of warring elements whose accumulation would turn our course. An opponent is foe or evolver, as you take him. By the might of that newly-developed power the river takes again to its strong arms the now disintegrated opposition, no more an obstacle but an element of affluence, parts necessary to the trinity of earth and air and water: it takes them into its 255resistless sweep and all are at one again, all flow on toward the ideal Unity. In that ideal our present union consists; it is this unity of motive which makes the strength of a movement such as ours. Thus may man learn again from Nature. She teaches that great rivers rarely raise their own impediments. Such are more difficult of removal. Let us suffer without complaint—but with instant resistance—the choking of our stream by debris thrown from opposing shores, but—let us not raise our own obstacles!
How often the Friend now invisible to most eyes lamented the tendency of "the Theosophists to soil—like the cuckoo—their own nest".[1] In the first letter addressed to me by our beloved Madame Blavatsky she wrote as above, and then expressed a fear which to her was hydra-headed, the only fear that ever had power to daunt that lion heart, the fear that, like Frankenstein, she had created a monster which might rend her and mankind. So the obstacles threaten at times to turn the river into a devastating monster. Let it keep to its own bed; let it cease to war with the obstacles in the very first moment of their removal; let the common aim be resumed; and the hope of H. P. Blavatsky, her faith and not her fear, shall be justified.
London Headquarters has had a visitor of interest in an English gentleman from Tibet. Originally a botanist, he had journeyed to the "Unknown Land" and studied Buddhism with the idea, at first, that it would help him in his travels. He was soon seriously interested, and finally became a Buddhist and later on a lama, passing through the usual severe ordeals. During his present visit to London he lectured at the T.S. Headquarters, as well as before other Societies, before returning to Tibet, where he has now gone. The most satisfactory point of all that he said was, to Theosophists, his statement that the Mahatmas are known to exist and are fully believed in throughout Tibet and the Buddhist orders there, although They are not generally seen, but work through other persons (a few). He also told of some curious practices of exoteric Lamaism. When persons commit adultery they are killed and their skulls tied together; this is supposed to detain them in Kama Loka, united in the presence of their sin. A species of drum is made of the skulls, every tap upon which is supposed to give the delinquents a thump to be felt even in the place of shades. At a yearly festival called the "Butter Festival" these skulls are sometimes (in a moment of priestly mercy) burnt, which is supposed to release the astral 256bodies of the sinners from kama-lokic torment. One such human drum has been presented to Brother George Mead. I understand that he means to burn it without waiting for the Butter Festival. In fact, I suspect that Brother Mead has moments of mercy weekly, even daily: he does not wait for a stated yearly softening of the heart. Another human curio is a rosary made of round bits from the tops of human skulls, taken from the part where the soul is said to pass out at death. This will also enkindle the flames of our brother's pity. It is not clear what constitutes the "adultery" thus punished, in the view of these Tibetan lamas, as it was also said that a woman might have as many as five husbands. Another custom. Tithes are paid to the lamas as a religious observance, and these they scrupulously exact. If anyone fails to pay tithes, the delinquent is hypnotized by the lamas, when he goes about quite cheerfully but starves himself to death by their suggestion! One would like to know whether this priesthood of exoteric Buddhism is a "red" or a "yellow cap" tribe. They would appear to belong to the class of lamas mentioned by Prince Henry of Orleans in his book on Tibet, whose frontiers he successfully passed. Curios of brass and silver were also brought by the visitor and generously donated to be sold for the benefit of the T.S. Crèche. A silver prayer-wheel and rosary covered with hammered ornamentation, Tibetan texts and designs, and also set with turquoises, and a fragile chatelaine of silver hung with small toilet accessories, were the prettiest objectivities from the far and fascinating land.
The reported discovery of a new gas said to be allied to nitrogen, as announced at the Oxford meeting of the British Association, recalls the facts given in the Secret Doctrine on gases as yet unknown, which are the missing links of chemistry and alchemy. One of these, spoken of as paranitrogenic or nitrozonic, would appear to correspond to the "new" gas of modern pioneers, or rediscoverers, as we prefer to call them.
Another fulfilment of statements by the author of the Secret Doctrine is found in a paper on original research, the "Physical Researches on Nervous Matter", said to be by Richardson and published in the Asclepiad, II, No. 41. The author says that a "great mistake" has been made and concealed by "one false observation". Anatomists supposed that "the brain and its elongations in the shape of nerves were absolutely solid substances, and although at one time it was thought that in the nervous fiber there was a fluid called specifically the nervous fluid . . . 257and although the tubular character of the nerve has been exhibited by microscopists, with mistakes of observation owing to the circumstance that post-mortem changes have sometimes been taken as natural conditions, the grandest of errors has remained, that of looking upon the nervous matter as solid. The brain after death looks solid—". The author then proceeds to state, as his "first subject", the theory that the nervous matter is not solid during life, but is mobile. "It is not like a wire, as a conductor of vibration, but is rather like a column of mercury, movable by expansion and vibration of particle on particle, particles collected in centers, and in a certain sense distinct, yet all in communication by means of the connecting lines which rise from the expanses in the organs of sense and from the other surfaces." The paper concludes with various tests by oxidization, combustion in oxygen, and so forth, but I would call attention to the lines italicized by me above as finely descriptive of a condition of interior substance whose ensemble may stand as the astral or nervous body, moulded, in part, into the shape of the body which contains it, yet having, in most men and women, no specific form of its own; a carrier of "Life". H.P.B. always said that solidification of the brain after death rendered observation of the astral (or nervous) passages and "airs" impossible. Some of the most pregnant facts of practical occultism are based upon this truth. Have the microscopists tried the effect of the Tesla electric current upon the brain as soon after death as possible? Here is a hint to our scientific friends, for could the mobility of "coagulated" nervous matter be even partially restored under electric action, yet another portal to the unknown might be unlocked in part. To the pure clairvoyant power only is complete observation of the normal and fohatic action of nervous matter possible, yet even partial observation is a crutch to halting minds which, like Thomas, must touch objective fact. Nor is this an unnatural need. It is one wholly natural, for it has its root in the stubborn illusion of the physical senses. Its yoke is felt by all in one or another form, and that is one reason why, in these days when it seems to be the paltry fashion to touch upon the faults of the illustrious dead, and when even some trusted friends have been lured to post-mortem dissection of H.P.B. and to claims that those of her utterances or testimonies which disagree from their personal views were false or were the subjects of her unrecorded and unobserved repentance, I would revert to that larger method common to seekers after unity in all ages, I would by synthetic deduction from her wonderful insight, her prophetic vigor, her unfailing humanitarian service, prove the 258upward tendency of her being, and would suggest that post-mortem observers of her character, as objectively crystalised in their own minds, may have been blinded by the new and rigorous conditions. The spiritual eye sees all things by its own light shed upon them. So with the eye of the mind; so, indeed, said H.P.B., with the physical eye, which in fact emits an energy by which it sees, though modern science knows naught of this. Emerson said: "Greatness is always in a tendency, not in an action. It is for us to believe in the rule, not in the exception. The noble are thus known from the ignoble." H.P.B. tended ever towards a brighter light. She, whose spiritual beneficiaries and dependents with coldly self-righteous sighs deplore here and there a fault, a spot, (a solar spot, it may be, to eyes of faith), saw the blackest sins, crimes even, as she now sees paltry infidelities or the ingratitude of microscopic analysts—with a heart of largest pardon. Pardon, do I say? Ye gods; what homeric laughter must now be hers, who was wont to laugh as with that other Sphinx, great Nature! Ah, friends; it were easy to touch apparent lapses of character and action, yet let us rather endeavor to rival her in charity, in the largeness of her silence. Somewhat she has, perhaps, to pardon in us all. We are too prone to forget that "Self-knowledge is of loving deeds the child". And that other watchword left by her: "Inaction in a deed of mercy becomes an action in a deadly sin". In the name of her infinite pardon give the lie to those who bid us look unmoved on another's pain; "tell them their tongue is false". The Law brings pain; be it ours to heal that pain, and, like little children, to love one another. Now that Love is not emotion. It is unmoved Compassion, itself the mover of worlds. Its herald here below is to leave the awards of action or inaction to the Law, as does the living Lodge, while we work for, with, in, and through one another.
Julius.
286
On the Screen of Time.
As the student of Nature watches even his small corner of the world-wide Screen of Time, he sees with delight the things of history appear, disperse, and reappear. It was in this mood that I received, on the 12th of August last, a gift which was at once a reminiscence and a prediction.
We have eternal friends, souls of one Ray, our kindred from dawn to dawn. One such sent me two curious family relics, bought from an impoverished woman in one of the oldest towns in France: these relics were the Masonic cross and apron of her grandfather, who had received the cross prior to the French Revolution, the apron just at the close of that stormy time. They bear evidence of his having been a member of that branch of the Rosicrucian Society which was founded by Cagliostro, who suffered imprisonment in consequence of his having founded a secret society.
The detail of these objects evidences the oriental inspiration of the real, the secret—now, as then, secret—Rosicrucian fraternity. The cross, surmounted with a crown, is of green garnets and crystals, set in silver. In its center is a picture, done in black and gold enamel upon a mother-of-pearl ground, of a small cross with a rose heart; in front of the cross a pelican upon a funeral pyre plucks at her breast. Below this, eleven degrees are marked off. The woman said she had been told when a child that these marks signified the Masonic degrees taken by her grandfather, but there is a mystic significance attaching to the number eleven. On the back of the jewel is another picture, done in the same way, of a larger "rosie crosse", surmounted with the letters INRI. The apron is an oblong of white lamb's skin, sewn with small round gilt spangles, either in groups of five or singly (like sun symbols), and is trimmed with gold lace now tarnished. At the top, over skulls and crossed-bones, are the letters S. H. O. (Société Hermétique Orientale). In the center a rough double triangle is formed by square and compass; in the middle of this a flamboyant six-pointed star has the letter C or G as its seventh point. The one letter would stand for Cagliostro, the other for St. Germain. Upon a bridge in the lower foreground are the letters L.D.P., historically attributed to Cagliostro; each letter is stopped by a triangle made in dots. The bridge crosses from the 287west to the east, and Cagliostro, agent of the Universal Lodge, was the bridge or path—sometimes called "the Door" in mysticism—between the eastern and western branches of that Lodge which is ever one. The bridge has four buttresses and three arches ("four bases and three aspects"); it spans a ravine in which are strewn the mutilated remains of human beings among X crosses of black magic made by cross-bones. Above the bridge, a tree of life has seven branches, one double (an eighth sphere attached?). The path leads from a locked and barred castle, black in color and surmounted or overshadowed by nine hierarchies of flames, on the left or west, to the right, where a flamboyant sun of orange and red proclaims the East. This sun rises at the side of a grotto bearing a rude resemblance to the human back brain. At a central and upper point projects a curious green growth, like a stem or a gland; below it on one side stands the mystic soma cup, on the other side is a moon-shaped crucible. A small sword has been thrown down in front of the grotto, and the same symbol reappears, much larger, over the grotto, grasped in a hand whose huge arm is red; the handle of this sword is red and orange, the blade is green. One symbol shows that the wearer or traveller, having gone from the negative (black) to the positive world, is now an active participant grasping and using both the subjective and objective will. My learned friend, Mr. James M. Pryse, tells me that the apron has Masonic, magnetic, and Rosicrucian keys.
In the November number of the Pall Mall Magazine is an article upon the Rosicrucians. It is headed by a picture which will have a peculiar interest for some students. By what action of that force which we call "chance" has this apparently irrelevant article been injected into these up-to-date pages? At a period in last century corresponding to our present date (almost) the writer of this article states the Rosicrucians to have disappeared. Is not this one of those floating straws which show the motion of the stream beneath—apparently so glassy and inert? The real Rosicrucian Society began before the date given and continues to this day, but the stream subsides into its underground channels when the century's effort is over, and the members of the hidden force—who have not been known as such, or at all, save to a very few workers on the objective plane—work after another fashion until the last half of another century brings the moment when their chiefly-unseen but always-vigilant aid must again be given to the leaders and members of the new open movement. Some know that H. P. B. had there her most powerful helpers and supporters. Her Rosicrucian jewel (shaped like 288the pelican in the small center of mine, but of silver) will occur to many.
A friend of H. P. B. tells me that she said that at the close of the present cycle the Lodge would temporarily cease to work among men in the present direct fashion, except through the channel of the T. S., should that body then be in forceful existence. As a glacier pushes its way and leaves each year a landmark planted further in the fields of its choice, so the Lodge forces will not withdraw from any real, fixed station won for its manifestation by our effort. Hours of struggle are upon us, and it may cheer us to go over certain known things. It is always helpful to pass the countersign. And H. P. B. said further that we should be in bad case next century if we failed now.
As in universal action force flows from hierarchy to hierarchy, from world to world, from cell-unit to cell-unit by established channels only, so the guardians of the Secret Wisdom, followers of Nature's laws, have everywhere their posts. Not alone in the East. It is not only Eastern Occultism, but Eastern and Western, two objective poles of one spiritual hierarchy, with a great teacher, twin-brothers in work and duty, in each division, with spiritual chiefs "above", and followers and helpers of all degrees in succession. "The Lodge is everywhere." Such Teachers take bodies of Eastern or Western heredity for their temporary habitations; the force generated through these bodies or physical bases for projection upon the physical plane must be magnetically and psychically homogeneous to the ray or sphere of the work. After the dawn of the Christian era, the Western mind, slowly involving the World-Manas, was more readily to be reached by the symbols adopted from antiquity by the early Christians, for these symbols were crystallized in their etheric environment and were those which had most life there at that time. Hence the rosie cross which had a sweet and secret heart, and was the same abode of the same spirit as the lotus-petalled heart of the East.
The visible agents of the last century worked under both directors, as I gather, but each one had someone superior to whom he immediately looked, and one brother inferior in knowledge who was his immediate assistant. Any member of the Lodge in any degree may have a number of "twin-souls" in all degrees, but one link of a chain must be objectively and relatively nearer to two others than to all. St. Germain, Cagliostro, Mesmer: one Adept and two Chelas. H. P. B. and her original trimurti completed by H. S. Olcott and William Q. Judge. Then, as now, there were other ardent workers, but as we look down the lines 289of the centuries here and there the mystic triad of pioneers reappears.
The human mind has a tendency to exalt what is distant. Prophets are naught in their own country, and cities are least known to their inhabitants. The young in occultism are sometimes drawn eastward by this trait, which has its root in the attraction of contraries. The tendency is toward forgetfulness of this linked succession, and that our soul chose for its next step the environment where we now are. Prophets may have a mission to other lands, but the dweller in cities may find rich rewards close to his hand. The Eastern race had earlier fruitage, and the coronal flowers of her achievement are those perfect souls who are as the pole-star to heaven-aspiring minds. Such men are not confined to bodies of that nation in which they first attained, but take such houses in such lands as the great work of human service may demand. To-day the West is the hope of the future race as of the present. To-day the elder brothers of men look to that West for objective aid as for racial evolutionary development. Individual men may still pass on to perfection everywhere, but the evolutionary forces tend westward now and must thence react back upon the East.
H. P. B., true to her mission of breaking up old moulds of mind, fixed modes of thought, attacked all forms from which the spirit had fled. The nascent Manas of the new race must not be smothered in the musty cradle of old forms. The husks of all creeds were in turn by her assailed. Readers of the early numbers of the Theosophist will find her dealing with the materialized dogmatic forms of the East just as she dealt with those of the West. She encountered the hostility of eminent Brahmins and prominent Christians then as now. This must inevitably occur when the spiritual pride of a race or the "modern spirit" of a nation is touched by a mordant such as hers. Intellectuality of times outruns spiritual (universal) intuition. The saddest shadows which hurry across our Screen are those of some Western occultists who went eastward, of some Eastern Chelas who came westward—to fail.
It ought to be more generally understood that H. P. B. not only disclaimed infallibility, but also deliberately put herself on record as having both made mistakes and "done wrong" as we would say. Her large nature was reckless of self. And yet some clues were left which we may follow. She wrote to Mr. Judge: "When I am dead and gone you will know that I never, never deceived any one, but that I was often forced to let others deceive themselves". It is told that she said to another and a less experienced 290friend: "Would you believe that I had done wrong if you were to see it in my own writing?" We can imagine the friend's loving answer. Ah! may it go well with both the living and the "dead" friend's memory in the hour of test.
But those two cries of hers show her heart craving for a faith and trust that should outlast her bodily life, outlive her generous self judgment; something of heart-knowledge; had she not won it fairly? Soul-recognition, had she not revived our memory of soul? She longed for that intuitive understanding which scorns material proof or disproof of subjective realities. The touchstone of soul is soul.
It is not yet too late, if, as I believe, she lives, consciously lives and works on. Whelps of the old Lion of the Punjaub, which of you will cry to her: Had'st thou writ thy fault up large upon the halls of the universe, thou had'st not so deceived me—never.
"It is possible to have a splendid loyalty and yet be wise."
Julius.
349
On the Screen of Time.
One who looks carefully at the shadow-pictures thrown upon our universal screen must observe strange figures and new combinations pointing to changes in the future. Sometimes even a Christian minister is slightly inspired, as in the case of the Rev. Parker at the Temple in London last month. Prophesying of next century, he said there will be no creeds and no need for preachers—as there is none even now. H. P. B. once made a somewhat similar forecast, though not so fixed in date. Such a change would be good.
350But the American Section of the Screen is the one to look at for advance indications. Here came about—insensibly, yet most powerfully—the great Religious Parliament, which started as a mere annex to a Fair but soon grew to an enormous affair in itself. It has left traces far deeper than the commercial Fair, its shadows still move over the surface. It aroused people in distant lands, and many Orientals came here through it. They attracted more attention than any other priests, they still in part remain. One of them on the way over stopped at London to lecture, beginning by abuse of the Theosophical Society, went to Chicago and discovered that Theosophy had been drawing people's minds eastward for twenty years. The Sanyasi, the Brahmo Samajist, the Buddhist, the Brahmin, spoke at the Parliament and created more stir than all others. The meeting closed.
But while some of the Orientals departed, others remained and still go about America lecturing in public halls and private dwellings and obtaining pupils. Some get their classes for Yoga. All succeed in invading the parlors of Boston, New York, Chicago, of any town. Dull England, the Conqueror, would not thus harbor them, but they find constant welcome in lively America. And they continually write home their impressions, their successes, their hopes. All this is significant.
Although not so heralded, it is part of the great Theosophical movement. It points to the subtle current running West, joining the East. The East lies almost dead, almost paralyzed by Western materialism. The West is waking to the greatness and value of the ancient Aryan philosophy; it has the energy to appreciate and use it under new conditions; when made a part of Western thought, it will react back to the East, when an awakening will take place—it will not take place till then. This is the great secret of the Screen. There is no division of races in it. He who says that those who insist on Western destiny and point to the current flowing West are trying to make discord between the East and West, is blind when not malicious. 'Tis true the Mahatmas are of no country, and just because of that they are wise, and run with the great cyclic currents so as to turn into the obstructed and befouled canals of the Orient the newly-purified water of the ancient wells. To obtain the purification they must have a free land and a free or partly-free people to work with; they can also wait while doubting or vain people dispute the question.
As the Theosophical Society represents outwardly the whole Theosophical Movement, so the Screen shows its most powerful 351influence in America. In India a comparatively small section of the people know of it. The masses know nothing about it. They require almost centuries to change and raise them from their superstitious state. One of the Masters—K. H.—himself a Hindu, wrote years ago that he could not stand the magnetism of his own country and had to flee after a short visit. The Rajahs care nothing for it, and mostly live in luxury, bound to the English Bank. In Europe Theosophy has some headway, but not a great deal. Almost every proposition has to be laboriously proved; psychic events are wholly doubted; those who have psychic experiences are obliged to excuse themselves; the land is still conventional. But in America the whole land rings with Theosophy. Its terms are known everywhere. Psychic facts are accepted, apologies are not needed. Ridicule arises here and there from editors, but the people think. The Masters have been freely spoken of and the perfectibility of man expounded. The whole land is asking for news of Theosophy. If for the present it be but an Athenian desire, that is an advantage, for it gains Theosophy a hearing. Verily the Screen shows the farther West to be the hope of Theosophy for both hemispheres, and those who shall sow the seeds of dissension by failing to see the real reasons and by calling any exposition of the cyclic Western wave an attempt to divide the Masters from the rest of the world, are heaping up for themselves a very heavy Karma.
Julius.
351 Dear Julius:—Che-Yew-Tsang? There is little of interest to relate. You will remember that Lord Brougham sent news of his death to London in order to read his obituary notices before his actual decease. He wished for frank criticism. My first motive in writing under a nom-de-plume was similar to that which prompted his action: I had an article burning in mind and heart, but I wished that the subject should be worthily treated. I might write and use my own name, but I feared that my friend Mr. Mead, the editor of Lucifer, might insert it, even if indifferently written, for friendship's sake. That I did not want. So I thought I would have it taken or rejected on its own merits, and would hide the person behind the idea. Was it chance that made me take a Chinese name and write as a Chinaman? Probably not.
Once that I began to write I found an additional motive for doing so from behind a veil, as it were. Regardless of criticism or praise, I wrote what I felt and what I wanted to say. The entire anonymity (for I told no one living of my purpose) made it 352possible to write from an impersonal standpoint. Much is gained in that.
The first article was a success, and so many favorable things were said about it in my presence that I almost wished it had never been written! At its first most flattering reception, modesty forbade my claiming it as my own (Lost since then? Perhaps.); and besides, already I had ideas for further work, and good-bye to all impersonality if now the Chinaman's identity were revealed. From the Universal these ideas had come; why color them with a soon-to-be-forgotten name? But to one person I did reveal his identity, and because I knew that this person had seen the real author of those articles. This person, with my permission, told Mrs. Besant under a promise of secrecy who the Chinaman was: that was on October 6th, 1893. Mrs. Besant's pleasure and approval helped to satisfy me that it would be best to preserve the anonymity.
Some time later I informed Mr. Judge, who had previously written that he was sure Che-Yew-Tsang was no Oriental. He had been asked by several who the author was, and had replied that he did not know, nor did he care,—for if this writer spoke the truth, it should be accepted for what it was worth, and if what he said were judged false, what had names or persons to do with it?
And the writer's words were largely taken as true: people wrote to the Unknown, but only one correspondent was ever answered, for I feared they might tell me that which they would not have revealed to me personally. So I was silent, and only wrote to one to say that I spoke with no authority whatever. Do I deserve credit for those articles? I do not; for when I have said that "from the Universal" those thoughts had come to me, it is but a partial statement of the case. I have heard it said that there is useful teaching in those articles; others have said that they were written with unusual force. Did they not recognize that force and that teaching; did they not see the source of both? They might have felt so plain a thing. Let me put on labels, then: the force was that of William Q. Judge; the teaching I had got from his writings and from one who had been taught by him—Jasper Niemand. To him and to his "creation" is the credit due: but they do not want that credit. If those articles were helpful I am glad. But I would have it known that where the author stood when they were written, in loyalty, in trust, and in love, there this day as in all days stands—
Che-Yew-Tsang.
London, January 6th, 1895.
19
On the Screen of Time.
Has the screen got any sense of humor? Some elemental, protoplasmic sort of smile must surely pass across its face as time brings men and things and dreams to play their pranks before it. A student of some experience once said in jest that "to have a sense of humor is the first qualification for Chelaship". There is truth in that, though care is needed lest the humor should grow bitter. But come with me for a little while and smile! Leave the noise and dust behind, and rest in the cool and the shade of smiling contemplation. There is no need to take life as a tragedy: has it not been said that "if we only knew our business all this would be but a contest of smiles"? He who cannot see the humorous side of events is well-nigh lost, and this the present shows. So look forth with me upon the scene of strife and laugh as the gods must laugh to see the mortals playing at being immortals. See how they grow into the parts they play and think they hold the destiny of worlds in their little hands! This 20one cries to the four points of space that, unless another resign from office, the future not only of the Society but of races yet unborn will be imperilled. And the cry is taken up and quickly echoed, for faithful echo ever answers "Yes" when that is needed. Do you not remember that combat fierce and terrible between Don Quixote and the wine-skins, and Sancho's part in the story? So that "Sancho, awake, was as wise as Don Quixote asleep: his head being quite turned by his master's promises". History is never original, as I will presently remind you on another count. But returning to our comedy, gaze out on the warfare of papers, protests, and promises; dust, documents, and dummies—all in wild confusion, each final and conclusive. Thunders of indignation, volcanoes of approval; tragedy and desperation. And laugh! The mortals are lacking in dignity, but they mean well. They really do believe that if success does not crown their individual efforts, the sun will give up its work in despair. Let us look on and wait: there is never such haste that action must be frantic. The wheel of months and years grinds on and on unceasingly. The face of things changes in that grinding. Exaggerated tragedy becomes burlesque, and the wise man waits for the reaction which follows all strained emotionalism. Many would have been saved from grievous blunders if they had stopped to gaze at themselves on the Screen of Time. They might have caught its protoplasmic smile!
But some are being wounded in the fray, and to one of such this letter was lately written by a friend: I give it, as it takes up a different standpoint to the one I have been considering:
Hearing that you are not well in health and have as well another grief to bear, I make bold to write to you and say that I am sorry. It is not consolation that I have to offer, for I think that is too often a mere mockery of sorrow. Yet I would tell you that you are not quite alone. A friend who is dealing blows to right and left, and would fain make of herself an enemy, has not spared you in that respect. But I think we have only to remember what we have already learned for ourselves—that it is all from delusion—and then we shall not mind and shall be prepared to wait until great Time brings its magic changes. We can wait: 'those also serve who only stand and wait'. And that too has to be learned no doubt like other things—through pain. But let us not forget that it is we who make our own pain. I have found that grief and sorrow only spring from wrong thinking. Not wrong in the sense of wicked, but in the sense of something out of harmony with the scheme of Nature; something unscientific and therefore 21contrary to the highest ethics. If we confined our thoughts as well as acts to our own clear duty, leaving results and the morrow to the Law, what room would there be for sorrow? So let us lean back and smile at the show and seeming of things, knowing that even if we are tied by hands and feet for a spell of days or years the heart of the world will throb on quite well without us. Therefore do not let us get mentally involved in this or any other matter, but stand aside—spectators, though doing with power all that comes to us to do and ready to do nothing if that be needed. Then, Brother, let us be glad at whatever comes and at all that is said and whispered, for though to-day may seem dark these things work out in the end for good. The more violent the storm the sooner shall we see the face of the sun which shines behind the clouds that only hide it for a very little while. You are quite happy and serene, ready for all and indifferent to each, at rest in the silent place of your own abode. But, like all of us, you are not known to every man, for the soul alone knows the soul. That is why there is little need to hide in Kali Yuga! You may tell them all, and they are not one jot the wiser. These people who imagine that they know the heart, the mind, and the soul of either you or me are not wise at all. They do not understand. They do not believe in their teaching, but merely hold it in their heads. So let it turn there, and perchance in the course of ages a flower will bloom in the heart of each, and then we will rejoice. If man could be strong in himself as a part of the whole, the noise of the world would not so much as reach his ears. My love to you.
It has been said that history cannot be original. We have instances of this to-day on every side. What battles were fought by H. P. B. with the Brahmans of modern India, and how she faced the opposition of their inherited conservatism! She had to deal with priests, for, as everyone should know by now, the Brahmans were the priestly caste of India. They were horrified with her unfamiliar methods, for they had grown hard-cased in a form and they overlooked the spirit in the letter. In all her writings, especially in the Secret Doctrine and the Voice of the Silence, she had much to say about the "Tirthikas, the unbelievers"—the Brahman ascetics, as she carefully explained. But, needless to say, she was not so foolish as to think that all Brahmans were of this kind. Was not Damodar a Brahman? Though he had to lay down his caste before achieving the aim and hope of his life. There are of course many good and noble-minded men amongst the members of that caste, as amongst those of other 22castes. One may study the characteristics of a nation with profit and without the slightest harshness, and if you conclude that the dominant peculiarity of some European nation is frivolity, you do not mean that each and every native is frivolous. It would be ridiculous. It would be still more ridiculous for every native of that country to take the criticism as a personal insult to himself. He would be self-condemned at once. Most educated Englishmen would tell you that the English as a nation are conservative to a fault, but are there not flaming Radicals in England? Yet one may say that, however subtly hidden, the characteristic of a race will be found in the units of which that race consists. I have known a socialist in Scotland whose deepest feelings were outraged when a small boy whistled on the Sabbath! So one may study a race impersonally, and expect to see it repeating its previous records. One may study an association in the same way, or a caste. Following that method it would be easy to foretell the action of a number of men in a given crisis, when action was necessarily hurried, if one knew the character of the race to which they belonged. In an early number of The Theosophist (vol. I, pp. 51, 52) a description is given of a famous Yogi known as Brahmachari Bawa, or Vishnu Pant Gokhle, a Brahman. Before reaching "illumination" he tells his interviewer that he had often consulted Brahmans and sought teaching from them, but he was always answered thus: "If you will worship us and learn our mantras and incantations from us, we will disclose to you the truth about the 'self-existent'. And so", he continued, "in order to try them, I learned their mantras and did all they bade me do, and then demanded that the true knowledge should be divulged to me. Their answers proved their selfish wickedness, foolishness, and often entire ignorance of the subject. Having thus discovered that most of them were only hunting after fame and selfish ends, and yet dared to brand those who questioned them as to their learning 'faithless infidels', a great aversion arose in my heart for them." No doubt many Hindus could thoroughly endorse from their own experience the words of the Brahmachari Bawa. They could hardly have found amongst their fellow Brahmins the light which they sought, or they would not have so run after H.P.B. All this is interesting as a study in Karma. National heredity is a powerful factor in human action, and actions ever tend to repeat themselves. True it is of most men, and especially of those with priestly blood in their veins, that "What men prize most is a privilege, even if it be that of chief mourner at a funeral". And the essence of a privilege lies in its excluding others from sharing in it; the 23holding of something as apart from the rest. A form of preservation which surely turns to self-destruction soon or late. By this you may know men: the soul which is of light opens its door to all who care to enter; sets no time limit on its acceptance; is indifferent to either praise or blame; and waits in patience on the Law, and waiting works. But not for self or against any man: for Humanity and Brotherhood.
Julius.
157
On the Screen of Time.
In a recent contribution to an English magazine, a writer on Theosophy makes Pain the very centre of manifested nature. The universe, it is there said, was produced through the self-sacrifice of the Logos, and self-sacrifice is made synonymous with pain. From that first agony all things have since subsisted on physical and mental torture; all growth has been the result of pain. Pain is to be welcomed as an honored guest. Remains the truth at first repellent, it is said, then austere but attractive, finally peace-giving and inspiring, that each step upward is only won by pain. Pleasure, happiness are not named. A picture is drawn of blood and tears and broken hearts that must make the ordinary reader marvel at this strange philosophy. Such a view stands out in vivid contrast to the old legend which made the universe the result of a great shout of laughter from the gods. They could contain their joy no longer, and in one long peal of merriment the worlds were born. Opposites indeed! Neither view is correct when taken apart, and it is unfortunate that this writer on Theosophy should have insisted upon one of nature's poles to the entire exclusion of the other. The duality which exists throughout this period of manifestation, or Manvantara, is fully explained in the Bhagavad Gita. Heat and cold, light and darkness, pleasure and pain, are opposites. One opposite cannot exist apart from the other. Growth does not take place by means of pain alone, any more than through pleasure alone, but is the result of oscillations between the two extremes. Above these two extremes there is a third state which may be called Contentment. In that state both pleasure and pain are accepted equally. Preference is not given to one mode of force any more than to the other. All these phenomena of consciousness can be interpreted in terms of vibration, and just as a bad smell can be transformed into a sweet odour by changing the vibration of the "odoriferous ether," so intense agony can reach a point when it becomes indistinguishable from delight. So with enjoyment: it can become so intense that it looses its character and is called painful. A good instance of this was given the other day by the great Italian tenor Tamagno, who confided the fact to an interviewer that some music gave him such delight that he suffered agonies from it!
So it is impossible to consider pain as central or as something superior to pleasure. The philosopher, according to the Gita, 158regards both with an "equal mind." The worship of one at the expense of the other is unhealthy, besides being unphilosophical.
Once a vision was seen. The seer is known to the writer by letter only, though well known. He was in Paris. Passing up from the Luxembourg Gardens, along narrow streets that seem to be a centre of equal attraction for priests, restaurants and funerals—though hiding perhaps beneath this safe disguise an inner life of different and loftier order—he came out upon the Quai directly opposite the site of the Tuileries. Leaning over the parapet, gazing at the muddy waters of the Seine, his thoughts were in no way enticed by the miles of second-hand bookstalls that extend along the south side of the river. Their volumes in every language and on every subject (a battered Key among the rest!), rare and curious, cheap and very nasty, no more occupied his mind than the tragedy of the fallen Empire which had played its last stake within two hundred yards of where he stood. Paris, once the temple of Pleasure and still the rendezvous of pleasure-seekers, was all in holiday attire. Laughter was in the air—but what are surroundings to a man whose mind is occupied with thoughts that are worth the thinking? Nothing. Truly it is the mind which makes the surroundings, and Archimedes was neither the first nor the last thinker who has remained faithful to a thought during the sacking of his city.
My friend soon found realistically the truth of this oft-repeated adage. He had been pondering over the history of a life, a friend's life; studying it, not unkindly, but in relation to universal principles and with fraternal sympathy. He came down along the record of events until he reached the present. Looking out across the river, gazing without sight at what had once been the palace of a tinsel Cæsar, there suddenly appeared to him a gray figure, stooping, meditative. Then it waxed clearer and he saw that the head of the figure was bent over some object held in the hand. It seemed that the whole being—the mind, heart and soul of this silent spectre were rivetted on this one object. My friend looked more closely to discover what this was: only a worm, a poor, struggling worm transfixed on a pin, writhing in agony. A feeling of disgust at the cruelty of it came over him and he turned to reproach the torturer, who had not seen him, who had eyes for nothing but the sufferings of the captive worm, regarding it with interested pity and yet with satisfaction. "Why not take it off—?" my friend began, but as he turned to speak he started back in momentary horror. The figure was that of the person whose life-history he had been pondering, and the worm, as he 159now saw, bore a similar likeness—the picture of a mind gloating over its own self-inflicted sufferings.
Then all vanished. A company of French infantry passed by him with strident bugling that could be heard for miles. It sounded miles away. The picture still fascinated him. The pity of it! For it was true: this had been the symbol of that life. The Worship of Pain; a sublimated form of selfishness that longed for a martyr's crown, but which would welcome the martyrdom for its own sake, even without the crown. A selfishness that in its grosser form would be but hypocrisy and conceit. A passion for pain which made it seem that to inflict it on others was to confer a benefit rather than a wrong. How could they grow without pain? See how I have grown through pain! A disease, my brothers, a disease of the mind. "Think not that breaking bone, that rending flesh and muscle, unites thee to thy 'silent Self'." And remember that "these vices of the ordinary man pass through a subtle transformation, and reappear with changed aspect in the heart of the disciple." The St. Dominic of yesterday may well continue to try to purify the souls of others and his own, by the pain he thinks it right to inflict, though now perhaps he uses some mental torture. The St. Simeon Stylites of one life may pass from racking his body for "the greater glory of God," to racking his mind; and with the same motive. He may now cry as then, though in different form:
O my sons, my sons—mortify
Your flesh, like me, with scourges and with thorns;
Smite, shrink not, spare not...
O Jesus, if thou wilt not save my soul,
Who may be saved? Who is it may be saved?
Who may be made a saint, if I fail here?
Show me the man hath suffer'd more than I.
But that is not Theosophy: nor is it Occultism. It is far removed from either. Once more we see that growth does not depend upon the amount of pain or pleasure that is endured, but upon our attitude of mind towards all that may meet us on life's journey. "It is not what is done, but the spirit in which the least thing is done that is counted." Extremes are always dangerous. To follow "the Middle Path" requires a broad mind that can recognize the duality running throughout the whole of nature and that can adapt itself to either mode of force with lightning-like acceptance, meeting the pleasure and the pain, 160the failure and the success, with unmoved centre. It is not an easy path to travel, but those who try to follow it and who continue trying shall succeed.
Julius.
329
The Screen of Time.
Forever hiding futurity, the Screen of Time hangs before us, impenetrable. Nor can it be lifted. Its other side may have pictures and words upon it which we would like to read. There is such a desire in the human heart to know what the coming days may hold, that if there be pictures on the hidden side of the Screen we long to see them. But fortunately for us in our present weak condition we may not look behind. Standing in front, all we are privileged to perceive are the reflections from human life thrown upon this side known as the present, while the pictures that have been there in the past turn themselves into background and distance, sometimes bright, but oftener gloomy and grey.
A very pernicious doctrine is again making an appearance. It is weak, truly, but now is the time to deal with and destroy it if possible. It is the theory that the best way to overcome a tendency—of any sort—of the physical nature, is to give way to it. This is the dreadful doctrine of Satiation: that the only way to 330deal with lust and other things of the lower plane is to satisfy all cravings. By argument this may be shown to be an evil doctrine; but fact overcomes all argument, and it is easy to discern the truth to be that satiation of a craving does not remove its cause. If we eat, and dissipate hunger, the need for food will soon be felt again. And so with all cravings and tendencies which are classified as bad or low, or those which we wish to get rid of. They must be opposed. To satisfy and give way to them will produce but a temporary dulness. The real cause of them all is in the inner man, on the plane of desire whether mental or physical. So long as no effort is made to remove them they remain there. The Voice of the Silence is against the doctrine of satiation most clearly, and so are the voices of all the sages. We must all wish that this pernicious idea may never obtain a hold in Theosophical ranks.
The desire to see the fulfilment of lugubrious and awful prophecies is a singular one for good men to hold. Yet many Theosophists have this most strange peculiarity. They have read and heard of certain prophecies said to have been made by H.P.B. about calamitous and disastrous times to come in Europe; of a new reign of terror; of sinking continents and destroyed nations. They add to these the improbable, vague and sometimes hoaxing prophecies by astrologers and old women. Then they begin to wish all these most terrifying things would come to pass so that their prophets may be justified. Every time a slight jar occurs in Europe they feel the terreur is at hand. But it does not arrive. Surely we ought to be satisfied with an ominous prophecy, if we believe in it, and be content to let its fulfilment be delayed for an extremely long period. We do not need prophecies, in any case, because out of our present deeds future events are made. Those among us who wish, as I said, for the realization of forebodings are the croakers of the movement. Even among the singular people called Theosophists they are singular, but their peculiarity is both unhealthy and useless.
In 1888 I had a morning conversation with H.P.B. at the Lansdowne Road house in London, upon the spread or weight of the Theosophical movement. I said that it was sometimes appalling to remember the millions of people in America alone, in comparison with the few Theosophists and Theosophical branches: what hope was there of our making a change in national character in any land? Her reply was that, while it might seem discourag-331ing looked at in that way, it was really not so. "Look," she said, "at our beginnings in 1875, when no one knew of Theosophy, and only jokes greeted our amazing efforts for publicity. But now we have come into the papers and magazines. We have made a distinct impression on the mind and literature of the time. This is much to have done."
There is abundant proof of this on every hand. Our name is now well understood. Writers may allude in their sketches to Theosophists and Theosophy without fear of castigation by the editor. There are two recent conspicuous instances. The N.Y. Herald, in December last, had an article in which this occurs:
"No man on the globe knows how to keep a hotel as the American does. He is a perfect Mahatma at the business."
Here is this great word abused, it is true; but that does not damage it. It has reached in less than twenty years the familiar treatment which it took in India centuries to come to. There they often use it as a term of reproach, on the principle that to call a man that high and great thing which he cannot be is to abuse him.
Again, in the Cosmopolitan for December last—a magazine widely read—there is a story by Zangwill called "Choice of Parents," on the abolition of compulsory reincarnation. The sketch deals entirely with the ante-natal world and reincarnation on the earth. Not long before the author had something in the English Pall Mall Magazine wherein Theosophy, Theosophists and reincarnation were mentioned. I do not know who will have the hardihood to deny the great share the Theosophical movement has had in bringing about this change.
At the present time one of the most urgent needs is for a simplification of Theosophical teachings. Theosophy is simple enough; it is the fault of its exponents if it is made complicated, abstruse or vague. Yet enquiring people are always complaining that it is too difficult a subject for them, and that their education has not been deep enough to enable them to understand it. This is greatly the fault of the members who have put it in such a manner that the people sadly turn away. At public meetings or when trying to interest an enquirer it is absolutely useless to use Sanskrit, Greek or other foreign words. Nine times out of ten the habit of doing so is due to laziness or conceit. Sometimes it is due to having merely learned certain terms without knowing and assimilating the ideas underneath. The ideas of Theosophy should be mastered, and once that is done it will be easy to express 332those in the simplest possible terms. And discussions about the Absolute, the Hierarchies, and so forth, are worse than useless. Such ideas as Karma, Reincarnation, the Perfectibility of Man, the Dual Nature, are the subjects to put forward. These can be expounded—if you have grasped the ideas and made them part of your thought—from a thousand different points of view. At all meetings the strongest effort should be made to simplify by using the words of our own language in expressing that which we believe.
William Q. Judge.
361
The Screen of Time.
There will be a change in the title of this magazine when issued next month. It will appear as THEOSOPHY instead of as THE PATH. This change is thought advisable for many reasons, one of which is the indistinctiveness of the present name. "Theosophy," as a word, has become familiar throughout the civilized world, and a certain definite though not always correct meaning has been attached to it. One of our chief objects will be to spread a proper understanding of its significance, as well as to remove false impressions concerning it. One of the chief results of the change will be an increased familiarity on the part of the public with the word; and it is a word that has a power in it, sufficient in itself to change the tenor of a man's life, as experience has shown in more than one instance.
Among other important results that should follow from the change, one of which I have already touched on, a very considerable increase in the circulation will be effected, it is hoped. Each reader will doubtless help to bring this about by reading THEOSOPHY on the street cars, in the trains, and in other public places where many eyes will be caught by the well-known name on the 362cover of a magazine. Once seen it will not be forgotten. So as this is a Theosophical venture I invite the cooperation of Theosophists the world over in making it a success. Nothing can be accomplished without you; everything with you: and the last and apparently least of you is not always the most helpless.
A contributor sends me the following communication, which I fully adopt:
"In Lucifer's 'Watch-Tower' (December, 1895) the editor undertakes to explain finally the question of Mars and the Earth-chain of Globes. Considerable assurance is shown in the expression of the views thus put forward, only surpassed, perhaps, by the assurance shown when the same writer expressed diametrically opposite views about two years ago in an article on 'Mars and the Earth' (The Path, vol. viii, p. 270; Lucifer, vol. xiii, p. 206). That article was written by its author in New York for publication in both journals.
"The editor of Lucifer, now saying, 'The facts [recently revised] are these,' proceeds to state that Mars and Mercury are globes of the Earth-chain. In the article on 'Mars and the Earth,' already referred to, the same writer stated that Mars and Mercury were not globes of the Earth-chain, correctly pointing out that to hold that they were would violate the fundamental principles of H.P.B.'s teaching, and concluding with the words, 'And so, once more, we find the Masters' doctrines self-consistent.'
"It would be useless to revive all the points in a discussion which was amply ventilated nearly two years ago. In an article entitled 'Mars and Mercury,' by William Q. Judge, which appeared in the Path (vol. viii, pp. 97-100) the matter was well summed up as follows: 'The two Masters who had to do with Esoteric Buddhism and the Secret Doctrine have distinctly said: first, that none of the other globes of the earth-chain are visible from its surface; second, that various planets are visible in the sky to us because they are in their own turn fourth-plane planets, representing to our sight their own septenary chains; third, that the six companion globes of the earth are united with it in one mass, but differ from it as to class of substance; fourth, that Mr. Sinnett misunderstood them when he thought they meant to say that Mars and Mercury were two of the six fellow-globes of the earth, and this correction they make most positively in the Secret Doctrine; lastly, they have said that the entire philosophy is one of correspondences, and must be so viewed in every part. If we admit that Mars and Mercury are two visible planets of the 363sevenfold chain belonging to the earth, then the consistency of the philosophy is destroyed, for as it is with planets, so it is with man. Every planet, considered for the moment as an individual, is to be analyzed in the same way as a single human being, subject to the same laws in the same way. Hence, if two of the principles of the earth are visible, that is, Mars and Mercury, then why is it that two of man's seven principles are not visible, in addition to his body? In his sevenfold constitution his body represents the earth in her septenary chain, but he cannot see objectively any other of his principles. The philosophy must be consistent throughout.'
"If the editor of Lucifer carries these recently revised facts, as given in the last December issue, to their logical conclusion, we may expect in future issues of that magazine a record of some entertaining experiments in clairvoyance with the object of 'finding Smith's physical body,' with the possible result that it will be discovered as Jones, a wanderer on another continent, blissfully ignorant that Smith is his Kama or lower mind, as the case may be. Smith's Buddhic or other principle will perhaps be found objectivized as a Hindu yogi—but what would happen if the yogi were to die before Smith? And how about Smith's four invisible principles (Globes A, B, F, and G), supposed to be careering through space in bewildering independence of law, rhyme, reason or analogy?
"On the whole, the teaching of the Secret Doctrine is likely to remain the standard, at least of common-sense, and I for one prefer to think that neither the principles of the Earth-chain nor the principles of man are physically separate from each other in different parts of space, but that all are in 'coadunition,' as the Master wrote."
Students will do well to refer to the former discussion on this subject, sufficiently complete to render further comment needless. The following articles should be read in this connection: Path, "The Earth-Chain of Globes," vol. vii, pp. 351 and 377, continued in vol. viii, p. 11; "Mars and Mercury," vol. viii, p. 97; "How to Square the Teachings," vol. viii, p. 172 (this follows an article by A. P. Sinnett on "Esoteric Teaching"); "Mars and the Earth," vol. viii, p. 270. Lucifer: vol. xiii, pp. 55-58, giving short criticisms by W. Kingsland, "C.J." and "G.R.S.M." of Mr. Sinnett's article; vol. xiii, p. 206, "Mars and the Earth," by Annie Besant. Students should also refer to "A Word on the Secret Doctrine," giving quotations from a letter of Master K.H.'s to Col. Olcott, 364which appeared in the Path, vol. viii, p. 202, with a preliminary note signed jointly by Annie Besant and William Q. Judge.
The recent remarkable discovery by Professor W. C. Röntgen of the fact that a photograph can be obtained of an object surrounded by an opaque covering is of immense value to Theosophy and Theosophists. If a living human hand, for instance, be interposed between a Crooke's or Lenard's tube (through which is passed a discharge from a large induction coil) and a photographic plate, a shadow photograph can be obtained which shows all the outlines and joints of the bones most distinctly. It is even stated as a result of later developments of this discovery that a dense body can in the same way be made transparent to the human eye.
These researches show that opaque matter so-called is not impenetrable to light-rays. It is an old Theosophical statement that matter is permeable, and to human sight, and is no obstacle to the astral senses. In these discoveries by Prof. Röntgen and others it is even shown as permeable to gross physical light. H.P.B.'s statement should not be forgotten that before many years important discoveries would be made by science tending to vindicate the teachings of occultism.
And once more science has the "spiritualist" on the hip; for the latter never heard from his spooks about these "cathode rays" that make a hard iron box transparent. Why is it that the spirits in Summerland never give out these things, but prophesy all sorts of matters and events that don't fall true?
Mr. Edward Maitland has recently issued a memoir of Dr. Anna Kingsford, in which there is an interesting account of her continuous attack on vivisection and vivisectionists. So bitter was her feeling against all those who practised this form of "scientific research," as it is called, that she claimed to have turned the force of her will against two of them with a view to their destruction—with success, she afterwards said. Certain it is that the two vivisectionists died. Elated by her achievement, she wrote to Mme. Blavatsky proposing a joint psychic onslaught on these miserable sinners wherever they could be found, in the hope of killing them off en masse. To this proposal H.P.B. is recorded as having replied in the following clear and noteworthy words:
"I feel sure and know that Master approves your opposing the principle of vivisection, but not the practical way you do it, injuring yourself and doing injury to others, without much benefiting the poor animals. Of course it is Karma in the case of 365Paul Bert. But so it is in the case of every murdered man. Nevertheless the weapon of Karma, unless he acts unconsciously, is a murderer in the sight of that same Karma that used him. Let us work against the principle, then; not against personalities. For it is a weed that requires more than seven, or seven times seven, of us to extirpate it."
H.P.B.'s words are of great importance. Mania to act as Chief Executioner of all disapproved and disapprovable things was not confined to Anna Kingsford. Members of the Theosophical Society have been known to burn with a passionate longing to act as agents for Karma, forgetting that the sword of the Executioner is a two-edged sword; forgetting also that they do not know Karma, and are held responsible by Karma for the mischief they will inevitably work. The absurdity of such an attitude of mind does not deprive it of a certain pathetic aspect. See these people, impure themselves, thinking they can either forcibly purify the world or can legitimately punish others for their impurity! The pathetic aspect comes in when they are so deluded as to call the proceeding "self-sacrifice." It would be real self-sacrifice for such people to sit still and attend to their immediate duty.
The Indian Section of the Theosophical Society proposes to take away the first object of the Theosophical Society, to-wit, the attempt to form a nucleus of a Universal Brotherhood, and insert in its place some high-sounding phrases, derived from the Brahmans who now control that Section, about spirituality and identity. These phrases will allow Universal Brotherhood to sink slowly out of sight. A Committee of Revision, appointed by the "European Section T.S." in July, 1895, has reported in favor of these words: "To promote the recognition of the spiritual Brotherhood of Humanity." A majority voted in favor of this alteration, but there are minority reports. But as the reigning magnates and high-cockalorums of 19 Avenue Road favor the change, it will probably be made by the Convention of the "European Section T.S.," to be held next July. The Theosophical Society in America, with the similar Societies in Europe and Australasia, will thus be left as the only part of the movement upholding Universal Brotherhood.
1
The Screen of Time.
This magazine enters upon the eleventh year of its existence with the present number. Its new name will in no way alter its purpose or character, but, as stated in the last "Screen of Time," Theosophy will more explicitly proclaim these to the general public than the old title—The Path. Already the good results of the change have become evident, for soon after the announcement of the alteration had been made new subscribers came forward and will doubtless continue to do so. But the efforts to increase the circulation of this magazine are made with the sole aim of spreading a true understanding of the Theosophical philosophy among the people, and only in so far as Theosophy can be of use in that giant undertaking will it fulfil its mission. It is to be hoped that readers will keep the same aim in view, and will make the watchword for the present year that given elsewhere in these pages by Dr. Buck — Organize and Work; for work, unfaltering work, is the first expression of brotherhood, and organized work is the second as well as the last expression of the same ideal. Masters, knowing how to work with nature, are the most perfectly organized body in the world; 2for nature as a whole and in all her departments is the faultless type of organization, and, as one of the Masters wrote, they "but follow and servilely copy nature in her works." Let this year, then, be one of Work and Organization.
There are several hindrances to the doing of good work by individuals, with resulting loss to the movement. These are all surmountable, for hindrances that are insurmountable are nature's own limitations that can be used as means instead of being left as barriers. One of these surmountable and unnecessary hindrances is the prevalent habit of reading trashy and sensational literature, both in newspaper and other form. This stupifies and degrades the mind, wastes time and energy, and makes the brain a storehouse of mere brute force rather than what it should be — a generator of cosmic power. Many people seem to "read from the pricking of some cerebral itch," with a motive similar to that which ends in the ruin of a dipsomaniac: a desire to deaden the personal consciousness. Sensation temporarily succeeds in drowning the voice of conscience and the pressure that comes from the soul that so many men and women unintelligently feel. So they seek acute sensation in a thousand different ways, while others strive to attain the same end by killing both sensation and consciousness with the help of drugs or alcohol. Reading of a certain sort is simply the alcohol habit removed to another plane, and just as some unfortunates live to drink instead of drinking that they may live, so other unfortunates live to read instead of reading that they may learn how to live. Gautama Buddha went so far as to forbid his disciples to read novels — or what stood for novels in those days—holding that to do so was most injurious. People are responsible for the use they make of their brains, for the brain can be used for the noblest purposes and can evolve the most refined quality of energy, and to occupy it continually with matters not only trivial but often antagonistic to Theosophical principles is to be untrue to a grave trust. This does not mean that the news of the day should be ignored, for those who live in the world should keep themselves acquainted with the world's doings: but a fair test is that nothing not worth remembering is worth reading. To read for the sake of reading, and so filling the sphere of the mind with a mass of half-dead images, is a hindrance to service and a barrier to individual development.
When two or three or more Theosophists meet together socially, what should they talk about in the absence of uninterested 3strangers? It may be said that they should talk like any other people, but this ought not to be the case. The usual worldly custom is to bring up for conversation unimportant matters, often in regard to persons, not infrequently to their detriment, or in regard to transient events, and to discuss these without relating them to permanent and basic principles. Many people talk for the sake of talking, as others read for the sake of reading, regardless of results. But those who know that a "single word may ruin a whole city or put the spirit of a lion into a dead fox" will be more careful of their words. Apart from that aspect of the question, it should be evident that for people who profess to be interested in Theosophy to meet together without discussing it is to fritter away their time and opportunity. To babble out words does not help on the evolution of humanity or inspire any other idea but the natural one that such conversation borders on the idiotic. Nor is there any reason why conversation should not be at once interesting and instructive. It can easily be led into such channels by anyone present. No one has a right to excuse himself on the ground that "the others" would talk gossip, or about clothes or games or similar things; for a few words and, more important still, a proper attitude of mind will at once lead the conversation into the proper channel. And here again any extreme should be avoided. There is a right time and a wrong time for the discussion of games, clothes, food, and so forth, and there is a decided limit to the usefulness of such discussion. Other topics should be dealt with when fellow students are so fortunate as to meet together. They at least should never part without conversing on some ennobling and uplifting subject that will help them in their work and study. To make that a rule would not only insure much positive good; it would insure against much positive harm.
The French press has recently been thoroughly aroused by the tragic fate of young Max Lebaudy, the multi-millionaire. Inheriting a huge fortune from his father while quite young, he soon became notorious on account of his eccentric extravagance and folly. On reaching the age of twenty he was obliged to serve his time in the army like any other of his countrymen, rich or poor. As he had already succeeded in gaining an unenviable notoriety he was constantly watched by newspaper reporters, especially by those of the radical and socialist press, for fear he would not be treated like the son of some poorer man. But he was not strong, and though his health soon gave way his superior 4officers did not dare allow him relaxations that would have been granted to other conscripts, for fear of the outcry that would have been raised by the radicals. So Lebaudy had soon to be sent to a hospital, well-nigh dead. The press, disbelieving in his illness, at once proclaimed this an outrage, hinting that he had bought up the officers and doctors and was shirking active service by means of his wealth. Afraid of newspaper disapprobation the doctors sent him from hospital to hospital, trying to pass on the responsibility to others, till at last Lebaudy died. Then came the usual reaction in the public mind and he was soon glorified as a martyr by the opposing section of the press. As pointed out by Francisque Sarcey in the March Cosmopolitan, the whole story well illustrates the abject fear of public opinion in which so many people stand. They will abandon any duty and almost commit a crime to avoid condemnation or harsh criticism by a majority of their fellow men. They act and talk with one predominating idea in their minds—what other people will say. As a failing this is more marked in some parts of the world than in others, it being particularly active in the more conservative countries where class distinctions are a matter of much greater moment than they are in America. But even in America this failing is not unknown, though there is less excuse for it here. Such pandering to the opinions of other people is despicable, and should be eradicated from the mind where questions of right and wrong are concerned. It is one thing to conform to custom in matters of form, so long as the form is not harmful, and this should be done as an acceptance of the environment in which one is born. Freedom does not consist in violating either national or social laws, written or unwritten; but in boldly living up to one's standard of what is right, in the strict performance of duty in spite of any condemnation from others, and in unswerving obedience to principle rather than to precept. Such freedom absolves men from mental allegiance to the daily press. The question "What will they say?" then ceases to be of any importance, since in no case should it be a factor in the determination of what should be done.
Max Lebaudy's case further offers a good example of Karmic action in one of its aspects. His great wealth was derived in the first place from the French people. Its possession placed him in a prominent public position, so that he no longer belonged to himself; he belonged to France. He was played upon, as it were, by the Karma of France. His follies, his deeds, and 5especially his misdeeds, appeared on a proportionately large scale. His prominence, due solely to his wealth, caused his destruction; and though people envied him for this wealth they would not have accepted it if they could have foreseen to what it would lead. In the same way a person of international reputation shares to a certain extent in the Karma of the nations that look upon him as a celebrity and whose thoughts are turned towards him. He has to suffer for it, while the poor man and the man of apparent insignificance are affected in correspondingly less degree by national and international Karma.
Another lesson that can be drawn from Lebaudy's history is the one-sidedness of the brotherhood proposed by people of all nationalities who make a great parade of "Liberty, Equality and Fraternity," but whose brotherhood is one of hate rather than of love. With them it is too often a question of forcibly depriving the rich man of his possessions for the supposed benefit of the poor man, and of inspiring the poor man with hatred for everyone who is better off than himself. A great many political movements whose party cry is brotherhood actually produce the reverse effect, and, instead of working for a universal brotherhood, they work for a carefully selected brotherhood exclusive of most.
It is fortunate for the Christian Church that every now and then a popular preacher comes forward to vindicate truth at the expense of orthodoxy. It would be difficult to find a successor in this respect to Henry Ward Beecher, whose oratory was famous throughout the English-speaking world, and whose fearlessness of thought made him at once a terror to all straight-laced believers in verbal inspiration and a religious saviour to those who wished to cling to a church, but who had been imbued with the then novel theory of evolution. A not unworthy successor seems, however, to have appeared in the person of Dr. Lyman Abbott, the pastor of the large and influential church in Brooklyn to which Beecher used to draw such an immense congregation. He preached a sermon a short time ago on "The Theology of Evolution" that was widely reported in the press. In it he ridiculed the idea of a manufactured universe, strongly supported evolution, and attempted to prove that a man might still "hold the Christian faith" while believing in the gradual development of humanity and the rest of nature. Telling his congregation that it was not uncommon in past centuries to discuss at what season of the year God created the world, he is reported as having quoted one mediaeval 6writer who argued that it must have occurred in the autumn because apples were ripe then—at which there was naturally "a laugh all over the house," as the reports state. If this liberal preacher continues to think as well as to talk, he may yet discover that reincarnation is the outcome of a belief in evolution, and that this doctrine is as much a part of Christianity, in the true sense of that word, as it is of Buddhism and Hinduism.
William Q. Judge.
33
The Screen of Time.
A new cycle has begun. The "turning inwards"—and homewards, of William Q. Judge was the signal for the dawn of a new day, long since promised by H. P. B. and by Masters. Far and wide throughout the Society an immense output of energy has already been felt. For months before the death of that body the greater part of W. Q. Judge's force had been used in the weary task of preventing its untimely dissolution. Only when the right time had come, and all things had been made ready, did he leave it forever, and almost immediately the liberation of his energies was felt like a vast throb of unrestrainable enthusiasm that aroused the hearts of men who had for long been sleeping. His will, one-pointed and unbendable, instead of being slackened by the dissolution of his body, seemed to increase in power and influence, and the "Rajah"—as the real W. Q. J. was so often called—after taking one rapid survey of the whole Theosophical situation, appeared to throw his force North, South, East and West, taking up the work where he had momentarily dropped it, drawing closer the ties of comradeship here, strengthening the faint-hearted there, affecting those he called "the faithful" though separated by many thousands of miles, and in all ways insuring victory where the world expected and in some cases hoped for disaster.
34A new cycle has begun. And though man will always mourn for those he calls the dead, and though it is but fitting that we should pause for a little while in loving memory of the friend whom so many of us loved more deeply than anything else on earth, let us not forget when all has been said and written that the only lasting memorial we can build to him will be one forged by our own thoughts and deeds on the model that his life and his teaching made so plain.
This new cycle was foreseen by H. P. B. and by the "Rajah" as one of regeneration and accomplishment. Since it began the responsibility of each unit in our ranks has increased tenfold, and upon the extent to which that personal responsibility is realized depends how far the whole world will be affected by the Theosophical movement in this and the next century.
Success is assured, but unless a victory is seized and used, it may cost more than many defeats. The greatest victory is only another opportunity. In the course of ages man may once come face to face with his chance, and grasping the sword of destiny may use it for his salvation or his everlasting shame. Here is the chance, here is the two-edged sword. The hour is ripe and the need is great. Where are God's Warriors? They have answered the call before; they have seen the Light and know it, have flashed back instantaneous recognition. Will they linger now when the Light shines forth again? They cannot.
Each to his place then, and whether it be high or low the honor and reward will be equal. Putting aside all jealousy, all suspicion, fear and doubt, let there be one far-reaching forward movement, made with perfect trust, with certainty of aim, with overwhelming force. Then will death be swallowed up in victory and the loss of a beloved friend be made the means of universal gain.
T.
65
The Screen of Time.
If any justification be needed of William Q. Judge's life and work, it is to be found in the last annual Convention of the Theosophical Society in America. Both in its absolute unanimity and in its attendance it far surpassed any Convention of Theosophists previously held, and what was felt on the inside by all present was of even greater consequence than the stupendous success of the outer proceeding. What was felt was the force that can only be generated by greater powers with the help of loyal and unselfish hearts to give that force a basis on earth. Such a body of men and women could never have been got together if it had not been for the sacrifice of W. Q. Judge, who lived and died a martyr in the cause of brotherhood.
This fact was evidently realized by the members present, and undoubtedly influenced them in all their deliberations. In this way the Convention was made the foundation stone of the great memorial to be built in his honor in the future—a memorial of deeds. For those who stood by him during his life are not likely to be ungrateful now.
The Convention was widely reported in the press, on the whole fairly and accurately, though the account given in the New York Tribune was 66considerably the best. The length of these press reports and their friendly tone, formed one of the most significant "signs of the times."
The newspapers are not hostile to Theosophy, with perhaps one or two exceptions; and such enmity counts for little. The large majority of leading papers are favorably disposed towards the Society, and when misrepresentations are made, as was recently done in the case of Brother Claude Falls Wright's wedding, it is really the public who are to blame more than the editors or reporters. The public demands sensationalism, and in order to keep in touch with the public the newspapers are obliged to supply it. No one can dispute their success in this direction, and hence the absurdities that appeared regarding a "veiled Mahatma," when in fact there was no veil and no "Mahatma,"—visibly present at least. But reporters cannot be expected to discriminate between "Mahatmas" and "Adepts," nor would the tout ensemble have been complete—from the standpoint of sensationalism—without a veil. So the public demand was satisfied and the absurdities appeared.
These things should be a matter of no consequence to Theosophists. No possible object would be gained by public contradictions. It would antagonize the press, and by the time the contradiction appeared the original cause of complaint would have been forgotten by almost every reader. Such matters do not linger in the public mind as they linger in the minds of Theosophists. It is wiser to laugh with the public than to assume an attitude of defence. People of sense do not believe all that they read in newspapers, however much they may pretend to when what they read promises to be a likely weapon against some theosophical acquaintance. And people who have no sense should cause us anxiety on quite other grounds, if at all. So instead of mourning over attacks, misrepresentations, or "chaff" in newspapers, members would do well to go on with their work and let all the rest go. If let go, such things are carried into the great melting pot of life and may ultimately be turned into useful channels under the guidance of some master-mind. And work for Theosophy would put a stop in time even to the public demand for sensationalism. So on all grounds it would be foolish to waste time over contradictions, indignation or regret.
An important communication will be found in the "Mirror of the Movement" concerning a great Crusade that will shortly be made throughout Europe. It will be seen to be a magnificent conception; that from this land of promise and of freedom, young in its present civilization but older than almost any other if pre-historic epochs be taken into account—there should be carried a vast theosophical impetus to other parts of the world.
W. Q. Judge, in a letter dated August 5th, 1895, wrote: "What I 67want to work at is a Napoleonic propaganda at which I hoped to, but cannot assist...... We have to fill the air with Theosophy and the T. S. in A. . . . We have to pour in force at those points." And force will be poured in at the points he named, and elsewhere as well. Vibration is the key to much. It is the key to the thought of the world. At this time when new forces are out and a new cycle begins, it is by "vibrations" on all the planes that all real work will be done. It is not by chance that the X rays have been recently discussed by thousands of educated people in every civilized country. Ideas on the subject have in this way become familiar, however crude the general conception of vibration may be, and as the work of the next century becomes more clearly outlined it will be seen that the science of vibration will play an important part in the XXth century's development.
Meanwhile it would be safe to infer that anyone who had mastered the occult side of this science would have a power over nature and over that important part of nature—the thoughts of humanity—difficult to realize but easily credible. With or without such knowledge it is certain that a body of earnest students, united in purpose and harmoniously working together, carry with them a peculiar force and influence. This band of Crusaders at least know what they want and are agreed as to the means of reaching their common goal. If for no other reason, so rare is unity, this fact alone should impress all those they meet with the power and influence of Theosophy.
Events move rapidly at the present time. Since writing the above, and since inserting in the Forum "A Warning," concerning attacks to be made upon certain prominent Theosophists, one of those attacks has appeared in a New York newspaper whose reporter had been instructed, as he informed one of our number, "to tear Theosophy to pieces." This attack was directed against Mrs. Katherine A. Tingley, a member of the Theosophical Society in America, a personal friend of Mr. Judge's, and Outer Head of the "E. S. T.," to which position she was appointed by Mr. Judge in papers left by him. Certain statements made regarding this lady in the newspaper article in question were wholly erroneous, and in connection therewith an interview that appeared in the New York Tribune of May 18th should be carefully read; for it was considered best to ignore all personal criticisms, and what was told in the Tribune interview, while leaving unanswered various points of too much absurdity to be seriously treated, at the same time gives students of Theosophy a full explanation of all the insinuations made against our fellow Theosophist, Mrs. Tingley, in the hostile article in question.
It was not originally intended to reveal the name of the Outer Head of the E. S. T.—or "Inner Circle" as the press delights to call it—for 68one year after the date of Mr. Judge's death. The work of the Crusade however, necessitated a change of plan, for Mrs. Tingley would have in any case been obliged to take an active part in that campaign, and to preserve secrecy would have been well-nigh impossible. For that reason, on Sunday, May 17th, at the conclusion of Brother Claude Falls Wright's lecture in Chickering Hall, E. T. Hargrove briefly addressed the audience.
Many of the remarks he then made have already been outlined above. He said in addition that he must apologize to those in the audience who were not members of the Theosophical Society in America for referring to a matter which concerned members of that body only. But he wished to take advantage of the opportunity, when a large number of members were gathered together, of referring to one or two matters of importance that required attention. Looking at that day's New York papers, he said, one could not fail to be struck by the sensational and often foolish news purporting to be about Theosophy and Theosophists. He had seen one report to the effect that a small boy, about six years old, was a great Mahatma; the reason for this being that the boy was said to be controlled by George Washington, Webster and one or two others of equal note! This boy was stated to have been accepted as a Mahatma by Theosophists in all parts of America. He, for one, had never before heard of this small boy; nor did he want to hear of him again; nor would most Theosophists be at all inclined to believe that this precocious infant could be controlled by any such entities. But this was a fair sample of the nonsense published concerning Theosophy.
Mr. Hargrove then went on to say that in another paper certain statements were made in regard to one of our members, many of which statements were entirely false. It was far from being his intention to controvert such erroneous statements as those referred to, for in any case Theosophists did not deal with personalities, but with universal principles. And, he said, it should further be made clear that Theosophists, as such, did not care in the least for the opinion of the public concerning any or all of our prominent members. Theosophists asked the public to pay attention to their philosophy, a knowledge of which they were busily spreading throughout the world: that was all.
Most of those present, said Mr. Hargrove, would no doubt be familiar with the facts of which the newspapers made a good deal not long since, that Mr. W. Q. Judge left an occult heir and successor to the Outer Headship of the "E. S. T." or Inner Circle, and that the original arrangement was to keep the name of this person a secret for one year from the date of his death, not in order to create mystery, but with a view to shielding this person from the inevitable slander and persecution to which she would be subjected, as Mme. Blavatsky and W. Q. Judge had 69been when occupying the same position. That year's silence would now be broken on account of the Crusade (and Mr. Hargrove then briefly outlined this great plan of work). Mr. C. F. Wright and himself had prepared a statement for the press on the previous Thursday evening, containing the real facts about the Outer Head, with one or two details in regard to her previous work—all of which was well known to Mr. Judge. These details Mr. Judge himself had given them at various times before his death. This statement was given to one paper, but its publication had been deferred when it was learned that another New York paper intended to publish a long article on the subject on Sunday the 17th.
Regarding Mrs. Tingley personally, Mr. Hargrove said that those who sustained her knew what they were about; they knew her past and her present, and both present and past were equally honorable and free from reproach—worthy indeed of the deepest respect. With such a great work on hand as the Crusade, was it likely that he or any of them were going to waste their time in trying to convince the public of the excellence of another person's character, or of that person's occult attainments? He was absolutely indifferent as to what any one living thought about the present Outer Head. He knew, and it was his business to say what he knew; but beyond that he had no interest at stake. At the same time he, like every other member, must wish to save her pain and needless persecution. Mme. Blavatsky and Mr. Judge had had many loyal supporters in America, who had never failed in their loyalty nor in their appreciation of what these their friends and helpers had done for them. As it had been in the past so would it be in the future, and he was perfectly aware that their present helper would receive the same and even greater support, unwavering and certain, than had been extended to those who had preceded her as Outer Head of the Inner School.
One other item of "news," for which more than one New York paper made itself responsible, deserves emphatic protest and condemnation. A "prominent Theosophist" was represented as having given certain information regarding what was headed "The Reincarnation of Mr. Judge." The suggestion made in this interview was disgustingly coarse, besides being absurd; it was as novel in its vulgarity as in its direct application, which, needless to say, was absolutely foreign to any ideas entertained on the subject by Theosophists actually prominent. The fact is that the inspirer of this interview is inimical to the T. S. in A. and was one of Mr. Judge's personal enemies. He masqueraded as a "Prominent Theosophist," with the connivance of the reporter, in the hope of discrediting the Society of which he is not a member. Such tactics can only recoil on the offender.
70The American press has shown good taste and kindly feeling in one important respect: in all the comments that were made upon Mr. Judge's life and work after his death, there was sometimes disagreement with his philosophy and criticism of his aims, but never personal abuse or a revival of the slanders so industriously circulated against him during the last years of his life. It is possible that the press had some respect for the memory of a man who had worked unselfishly for years, who had never ceased to work in spite of sickness and persecution; it is possible that the press had some respect for his wife, for his family, still mourning their great loss—even respect for the thousands of loyal hearts throughout three continents who had looked upon this man as their friend and teacher. In any case there was no slander, no viciousness. It remained for two or three people, whom I will not name, who had once clasped hands with him as friend, who had looked on him as leader,—it remained for them to cry "fraud" at him across the valley of death and so brand themselves with ineradicable shame. This was done in newspaper interviews, which in this case must be accepted, since they but reiterated what had previously been stated in more than one personal conversation. But the persons do not concern us in the least. They are their own executioners. It is the act that calls for notice as showing that the press of America has its own code of ethics which is at least vastly superior to a code that allows of persecution, not only into the grave, but beyond it.
E. T. H.
97 The Crusade is already at work in Europe, or will be by the time these pages are read in America. The greatest enterprise of the XIXth century, theosophically speaking, has thus been commenced. It will not be abandoned for one moment until every part of the plan has been made perfect. It is the supreme and necessary effort of the century, and at its completion the life-work of H. P. Blavatsky and William Q. Judge will be consummated. From its inception the theosophical movement has been a holy war, and this Crusade goes forth to conquer the world by the power of Light and Truth. It will be the last campaign of a twenty-five years' struggle—a struggle for brotherhood and for the liberation that the light of truth always brings.
Such an undertaking as the Crusade is certain to meet with opposition. Enemies of the Society have already tried to interfere with it and will doubtless try to do so again. They cannot succeed. These enemies are of all sorts, from ordinary blackmailers to people of wealth who hate Theosophy as an owl hates the sun. The first attempt to interfere with this great work was easily frustrated. One or more of the Crusaders were to have been arrested on the strength of any false charge, it being thought that they would gladly pay blackmail in order to avoid arrest and so keep their European engagements. The injudicious 98communicativeness of one of those responsible for the plan supplied the detailed information that was needed, and the prompt statement in the New York papers that in the event of such arrests being made, warrants on counter-charges of perjury and false arrest would be applied for, was quite sufficient to paralyze the proposed inimical action. The Theosophical Society will have enemies as long as it is powerful. Its strength may be gauged by the number of these enemies and the bitterness of their opposition.
After all that has been said and written by H. P. Blavatsky, W. Q. Judge and others, concerning the dangers of psychic practices, it should not be necessary to again warn students against such things. Throughout America at the present time hundreds of "Occult Brotherhoods" are springing up in which teaching is given for monetary consideration. "Initiations" are charged for at rates ranging from five to one hundred dollars. In the first place any one paying such sums for such teaching is foolish, seeing that they may obtain the same information in many books which may be purchased for twenty-five cents. They are consequently making a bad business bargain. In the second place by following the advice of such teachers of sham occultism they run a serious risk of physical, mental and moral destruction.
The teaching given in this way varies in character as much as in price. Twaddle about "our Most Ancient Elder Brother, Prince Rameses" and a strange jumble of Theosophy and Spiritualism—in which Theosophy gets much the worst of it—can nearly always be met with. Other pseudo-occultists teach a modified form of Hatha Yoga, advising concentration on the tip of the nose, on a picture hanging on the wall, or on a watch. This leads to self-hypnotism and in no case to more than physical and lower astral results, all of which are bad. It turns the force of the mind on to lower instead of higher planes. Advice is also given as to breathing: that one nostril should be closed; both closed; the other closed—as if the kingdom of heaven could be entered by self-suffocation! These practices render a man mediumistic and a mere sponge to all lower astral influences; they will in time give him heart-disease and probably make him insane.
One of the worst forms these teachings assume is in dealings with other men and women, for explicit directions are given in several of these organizations for hypnotizing people at a distance. A business man is advised to call up the "astral body" of his customer and to think to it in a certain way, as a result of which larger orders are guaranteed. On entering a room in which business is to be conducted the student is to think along lines that will lead to his own success and to the confusion of the person with whom he is dealing. All of this is Black Magic and 99every Theosophist should wage a merciless war against it. Such practices only end in one way: in the destruction of any one who attempts to pursue them. The black and poisonous force that is liberated by efforts of this sort, reacts with fatal violence, and moral, mental and physical ruin must inevitably result in the course of a few years. It is not necessary to touch upon some of the still more loathsome practices recommended in a few of these organizations. They bear their own condemnation on their face.
A rumor has reached America that a prominent lady member of the Society whose headquarters are at Adyar, intends to take advantage of the Crusade to make a tour round this country and if possible convert the American Theosophists to a belief in Mr. Judge's alleged "fraudulent methods." This tour is to be conducted by a professional lecturing agent. The entire manœuvre shows a lamentable lack of appreciation of the American national character, and still more of the character of those who supported Mr. Judge during his life-time. The last Convention of the T. S. A. should have been a lesson to Mr. Judge's enemies. It should at least have shown the utter futility of attempting to destroy a faith that was well founded and which is not to be shaken by any wind, from any quarter. The presence or absence of the Crusaders will not make the slightest difference in this respect. Those who stood the test before are still standing on their own feet; they then upheld principles, not persons, and do so still. And though W. Q. Judge is no longer with us and cannot answer his enemies, his friends are better able to defend him, than at any time in the past, seeing that they are now in possession of all of that evidence which he held back because he preferred silence to self-defense and preferred to suffer rather than give suffering to others.
This rumor, which appears to be based upon fact, can well be let go and left to time to deal with as time alone knows how. There is work to do.
E. T. H.
129 The Crusade may safely be pronounced an immense success. From the day the Crusaders left New York up to the present time, the force of its work has steadily increased, and if we may take the English verdict as impartial, it is certain that the record in Ireland and the other European countries will be even more encouraging. "A new day has dawned": so have many writers and speakers lately proclaimed, and facts prove the truth of the claim.
The reports that follow give details of the work up to the date of writing. It should be first remarked, however, that no one who stood on the deck of the U. S. M. S. "Paris," on the morning of June 13th, and there witnessed the solid square of Theosophists who cheered their out-going comrades with whole-hearted enthusiasm, could ever doubt the success of the great work then commenced. The force and heartiness of that farewell showed indisputably that the Crusade was the expression and embodiment of a widespread movement on the part of American Theosophists, who had heard a call for help from other nations and who responded by sending the best help that lay within their reach.
The following account of the activities on board the "Paris" is furnished by an old member of the Aryan T. S. of New York, who travelled with the Crusaders as far as London.
The Crusaders sailed for Europe, as every one knows, on Saturday, the 13th of June. I had taken passage on the same ship, and it will no doubt be interesting to readers of 130Theosophy if I give a sketch of what took place on the voyage. The gathering of friends of the party at the dock was very large and the "send-off" extremely enthusiastic. Just as the steamer was about to start, the well-wishers of the Crusade came together in a compact square on the platform at the end of the dock, and as the ship backed out there was loud cheering and great waving of handkerchiefs, to which of course the Crusaders responded.
The first day on board was fine and the water smooth, but the second, Sunday, was, alas, far different, and most of the Crusaders kept to their rooms. The next day was much better, the sea fairly smooth and the weather delightful, and it has continued the same up to the present writing, near the end of the voyage.
On Tuesday evening the Crusaders began their public work. The passengers were invited to a meeting in the main saloon, and most of them came. Mr. H. T. Patterson presided and opened with a statement of the purpose of the Crusaders and the route which they intended to take. Mrs. Keightley followed, showing the unreality of the apparently real and the reality of the ideal. Mr. Hargrove then gave a brief but very clear statement of the theosophical philosophy, its history in the world, and its breadth and liberalizing power. Mrs. Wright spoke of the position assigned by Theosophy to woman, and her influence on the thought and life of mankind. She was followed by Mr. Wright, who spoke on the theosophical conception of human brotherhood. Questions were then invited and quite a spirited discussion arose between some gentlemen of the audience and Messrs. Hargrove, Wright and Patterson. The evening closed with a hearty vote of thanks to the Crusaders for having held the meeting.
Theosophists will not be surprised to learn that their representatives made a strong presentation of their respective subjects at this meeting and that the impression made was most favorable. I regarded it as a highly satisfactory initiation of the work of the Crusade.
On Wednesday a meeting was held on deck for second-class passengers, which was well attended and aroused considerable interest. The climax was reached however in the steerage, where a most impressive meeting was held on the evening of June 18th. The only place for the meeting was a wide, badly lighted passage way, turning at an angle, where stood the speakers. There were about ninety steerage passengers on board, and these with many stewards and a number of stokers, crowded together in the passage way and listened to the speakers with an eagerness which was pathetic. Mr. F. M. Pierce opened the meeting with a few general remarks, and he was followed by myself, Mrs. Keightley, Mr. Patterson, Mrs. Tingley and Mrs. Wright, in the order given. Mrs. Tingley's remarks were particularly impressive. She spoke without notes, and was evidently deeply moved by her wide experience among the poor. She told them that her best lessons had been learned among them and that she had found in them generosity and kindness of heart not often to be met with among the higher classes. She said that she longed to bring Theosophy to the poor because it would be a consolation to them and because it would kindle the light of the soul in their hearts. Her address was both touching and beautiful, and aroused great enthusiasm.
After the addresses questions were freely asked and answered by Messrs. Hargrove and Wright, and an animated discussion ensued. This meeting was a great success in every way. Many were profoundly interested and earnestly invited some of the Crusaders to visit the steerage again. With this meeting ended the public theosophic activities of the voyage, although during the whole period much was done in conversations with both cabin and steerage passengers.
On Thursday evening, Commander Herbert Booth gave, in the main saloon, an interesting account of the organization and work of the Salvation Army. Mr. Hargrove moved a vote of thanks for the Commander's address, which was duly seconded and carried amid applause.
131 The usual first cabin musical entertainment took place on Friday evening, and, at the request of the Captain, was organized and presided over by Mr. Patterson.
My impressions of the voyage may be summed up as follows: The Crusaders are acting absolutely as a unit, with the utmost harmony, of which it is possible to conceive. They are continuing in the same spirit of unity and solidarity which was the dominating characteristic of the April Convention, and are moving with a concentration and power which is certain to achieve great results. They are all of them constantly at work, even on board this ship, and the only criticism I have to make of them—which is in the nature of a personal grievance—is that they work too much. I have naturally been very desirous of seeing as much of them as possible, and the gratifying of this desire has frequently been interfered with on account of the pressure of their work.
I am writing on shipboard, Saturday afternoon, June 20th. We expect to land tomorrow morning.
The Crusaders landed on Sunday morning, June 21st, and were welcomed at Southampton by Dr. Archibald Keightley, who travelled with them to London, where the party were met by a number of members and old friends, including H. T. Edge, Mr. and Mrs. T. Green, E. Adams, Gordon Rowe and others. All proceeded to 62 Queen Anne Street, where an E. S. T. meeting was held at about 1 p. m.
After the meeting the Crusaders at once drove to St. Pancras Station, en route for Liverpool, where they arrived the same evening, putting up at the Mitre Hotel. They were met there by Robert Sandham, Herbert Crooke, J. K. Gardner, John Hill and others of the loyal and devoted band of Theosophists in Liverpool and Southport. A general E. S. T. meeting was held on Monday afternoon, which was attended by the Crusaders and by the local members. A cordial welcome was extended to Mr. T. A. Duncan, who had travelled all the way from Oxford in order to be present at the various meetings. Mr. Duncan took a very active part in the work in the early days of the Society in Liverpool.
The following extracts, describing the Crusaders' proceedings, are taken from an account written by Mr. Herbert Crooke:
The first public meeting in England which was organized in connection with the Crusade was of a character that at once stamps the undertaking as one of a noble and philanthropic purpose. In a hall situated in the very heart of the slums of the city (Liverpool), over three hundred of the very poorest of the poor were gathered on Monday evening to partake of a free supper which was happily called a "Brotherhood Supper." Here were the corner-man, the orange-girl, the match-seller, and the poor out-of-work men and women, lads and lasses and even a sprinkling of dirty though bonny babies who did not fail to make their presence known on occasions.
Everyone of these had been personally invited to the supper by one and another of the little band of Theosophists who weekly gather together at their Lodge rooms in the city. It was a marvel on this unique occasion to observe the faces of the people as they trooped into Albert Hall, where the supper was held, and the look of pleasure and the wonderful suppression of natural excitement with which they took their seats orderly and contentedly before the ample repast that had been provided.
There was no grabbing, no struggling for place nor any of those elements of disorder that one might expect to be naturally manifest. And one can only conclude that this was 132the effect of the worthy effort to treat these "outcasts of society" as brothers and sisters, and to welcome them as one's best friend is welcomed to one's home. We can recommend such a course of procedure to every similar effort that may be made by every charitable organization in our country.
The after-meeting was devoted to brief speeches and music in place of the Lantern entertainment which was rendered impossible by the breakdown of some mechanism. These speeches were listened to with deep attention, every speaker being received with applause. Mrs. Tingley in particular appeared to evoke the enthusiasm of her audience.
On Tuesday a well-attended Branch meeting was held in the afternoon, at which the Crusaders made brief addresses, and in the evening a large mass meeting, at the Picton Lecture Hall, where over one thousand people assembled. The platform was tastefully decorated with flowers and palms and the banners and flags carried by the Crusaders. Dr. Archibald Keightley of London, President of the Theosophical Society in England, occupied the chair and Dr. Herbert Coryn, also of London, cordially welcomed the Crusaders to these shores, remarking upon the objects of the Theosophical Society and the one qualification for membership, a belief in universal Brotherhood. Mr. Henry T. Patterson followed with a statement of the objects of the Crusade and the route they proposed to take on their journey round the world, carrying their message of peace and goodwill among men. Mrs. Wright, in a clear voice and telling manner, discoursed upon the quality of true love and besought her audience to exercise charity, as being the highest expression of the soul of which it is possible to conceive. Mr. Ernest T. Hargrove discussed the question of Compensation; as to why men suffer, and for what, and how, they might cease from suffering and enter upon a birthright of joy and happiness.
At this point in the proceedings two interesting incidents occurred; one being the reading of a letter from the children of the Lotus Circle in New York, with greeting to the children of all the nations of the world, and a reply presented to Mrs. Tingley by a boy and a girl of the Lotus Circle in Liverpool; the other, the presentation to the Crusaders of the Union Jack by Mr. Herbert Crooke on behalf of the Theosophists of England, with the remark that as the flag had often been carried into war in the past against the nations, it might now be carried to commingle with the flags of other nations in this work of promoting brotherhood amongst the peoples without distinctions of race.
Mrs. Tingley rising later to accept these offerings, dwelt upon the spirit of sacrifice that had prompted the noble men and women who had come with her from their homes and friends and business, regardless of expense or loss to health and comfort, to give the needed answer and help to the cry of poor suffering humanity which she said, with suitable gesture and powerful dramatic effect, went up as "O God! My God, is there no help for us!"
Mr. Claude Falls Wright then spoke on Re-incarnation and Mrs. A. L. Cleather followed with the appropriate theme, "The Perfectibility of Man," which was the grand ideal of the Theosophical movement; Dr. Keightley briefly referred to the founding of a school in America for the revival of the ancient mysteries of Egypt and Greece. A farewell address from the Liverpool and Southport Theosophists to the Crusaders concluded the meeting. Mr. Frank Weston of Liverpool, Mr. W. Ashton of Southport, and Mrs. Cleather and Mr. Basil Crump of London contributed musical selections which greatly added to the success of the meeting.
On Wednesday, at 1.30 p. m., the Crusaders left Liverpool for Bradford, Yorkshire. They were heartily cheered by the Liverpool members who had gathered in full force at the station to see them off. At Bradford they were met by Mr. T. H. Pattinson, an old friend of Mme. H. P. Blavatsky's. After a hasty tea they proceeded to Mr. Pattinson's 133house, where they met Mrs. Pattinson, Miss Brittan, and Messrs. Williams and Dunckley, and carried on a long and informal conversation with these old and loyal friends of H. P. B.'s. Next morning, Thursday, a public meeting was hurriedly arranged for the evening, and the Crusaders spent the day rushing round Bradford looking after the printing of handbills, newspaper advertisements, music and the various other things necessary for a Crusade meeting.
The short notice did not permit of a very large concourse of people, but a highly appreciative and sympathetic audience assembled that evening in the Mechanics Institute, and at the conclusion of the meeting a Branch of the T. S. in Europe was formed which should have a most prosperous career in Bradford where there is great need for the organized propaganda that such a Branch can carry on.
Early on Friday, June 26th, the Crusaders left for London, where they arrived at 3.30 p. m. They were greeted by a number of friends who escorted them to the Norfolk Mansions Hotel in Wigmore Street. Saturday was wholly taken up with American mail; Sunday was devoted to E. S. T. meetings; Monday was a day of calls and visits; and Tuesday, the 30th, was given up to a "Brotherhood Supper."
This was held at 8 p. m., in the large Hall of the Bow and Bromley Institute, and was one of the most successful meetings which has yet been held. Mr. R. Machell, who is rightly called the theosophical artist, kindly lent some of his magnificent pictures for the occasion, and these decorated the walls of the hall and greatly delighted the people and also acted as an inspiration to the speakers. Mrs. Cleather and Mr. Basil Crump furnished excellent music, but the same cannot be said of the Crusaders, who tried to sing "The Star-Spangled Banner" for the entertainment of the London poor.
There were four hundred present, and they all enjoyed thoroughly their supper of roast beef, bread and butter, and tea and coffee. After the supper brief speeches were made by all the Crusaders on the broad lines of Brotherhood, compensation, and the real nature of man, and were much appreciated as was evidenced by the appropriate and hearty applause that greeted every point of special significance that was made. A display of magic lantern views of America, ancient and modern, by Messrs. Wright and Patterson, followed the speeches, and in conclusion, after giving "three cheers for America," the entire audience, at Mrs. Tingley's request, filed on to the platform and shook hands with those who had addressed them. "A veritable triumph," as an English member remarked.
One hundred of the men and women invited had spent the previous night in a "Shelter," which they may not do on two consecutive nights, 134so that without the "Brotherhood Supper" they would have passed the night on the streets, supperless.
On the evening of Wednesday, July 1st, Lady Malcolm of Poltalloch, one of the most devoted members in England, gave a reception to the Crusaders at 23 Great Cumberland Place, to which she invited several old friends of H. P. B.'s, such as the Baroness de Pallandt, the Countess d'Adhemar, Mrs. Hunt, and Mr. Stewart Ross, well-known as "Saladin," the editor of the Agnostic Journal.
On Friday Lady Malcolm gave a dinner to the Crusaders and various representatives of the press, preliminary to the great public meeting that was held in Queen's Hall, Regent Street, at 8 p. m. This meeting was attended by over eight hundred people, in spite of heavy rain and the hundreds of entertainments being given in all parts of London—for it is now the height of the London season. This meeting was an immense success. The music, in which Mrs. Cleather and Mr. Basil Crump again took a leading part, was excellent, and the various speakers were equal to the occasion and delivered splendid addresses.
The meeting opened with the prelude to Parsifal played by a quartette consisting of violin, cello, piano, and organ. H. T. Patterson was first introduced by the Chairman, Dr. Keightley, and spoke on the "Theosophical Crusade;" then in order came Mrs. C. F. Wright on "Charity," E. T. Hargrove on "Toleration," an address by Mrs. Tingley, E. T. Hargrove in the place of F. M. Pierce, who was unable to speak, on "The School for the Revival of the Lost Mysteries of Antiquity," Mrs. Keightley on "The Need for Theosophy in Europe," and C. F. Wright on "Reincarnation."
At this point was read the address of the children of the Lotus Circles of America to those in foreign lands, which was replied to by Mrs. W. Lindsay on behalf of the children of London. The standard of the city of London was then presented by Mr. Wm. Lindsay.
The meeting closed with a fine farewell address by Dr. H. A. W. Coryn. Rounds of applause greeted the various speakers, and the whole of the proceedings were conducted with peculiar energy and spontaneity. Such a meeting cannot fail to be of immense service to the work throughout England.
On Saturday, July 4th, a public meeting is to be held at Woolwich, at which the Crusaders will speak. It is expected that a large number of the workmen attached to Woolwich Arsenal will be present.
The following cities in England and Scotland are to be visited before the Crusaders reach Dublin, where the Convention of the Theosophical Society in Europe is to be held on August 2d and 3d: Bristol, Birmingham, Southport, Middlesborough, South Shields, Edinburgh and Glasgow.
London, 4 July, 1896.
E. T. H.
161 It would be difficult to adequately describe the ever-increasing success of the American Crusade of Theosophists around the world. Every town visited seems to add something to the total force of the movement. Naturally enough there has been some opposition to overcome or to ignore, as the occasion required; but this has been easily done.
A word or two as to this opposition: it has all come from certain people who formerly persecuted Mr. W. Q. Judge and who belong to the same type as those who attacked Mme. H. P. Blavatsky at an earlier date. These people claim to be Theosophists, but their actions certainly belie the claim. Their leader, whose work in the world has always been destructive, attempted to destroy the result of Mr. Judge's labors in America, but failed ignominiously. That attempt was due in the first place to the influence of modern Hindu thought, but was also inspired by more personal motives, to which further reference is not now necessary. But the attack upon Mr. Judge was really an attack upon Theosophy and upon its basic teaching of Brotherhood.
It was consequently not a matter for great surprise when the Crusaders were greeted shortly after their arrival in London by a hostile letter, signed by the leader of Mr. Judge's persecutors, together with others who 162took minor parts in the campaign against him. This letter was sent to all the London newspapers, and was inserted by one or two. It repudiated the Crusade, discountenanced its work and stated that its members did not belong to the organization (whose headquarters are at Adyar) represented by those who signed the letter. The Crusaders endorsed this letter—especially the last clause—at the numerous public meetings held throughout England.
Following this came another illustration of "brotherhood" as exemplified by the same people. The English division of the Theosophical Society in Europe held its annual meeting in May last and those who took part in it directed that a letter of greeting and fraternal good-will be sent to the annual Convention of the European Section of the Adyar Society, which was held in July. This was done, and as soon as the letter was read, the Chairman of the Convention and President of the Adyar Society, ruled all discussion of or reply to the letter "out of order." Friendly overtures were thus made and rejected, and in addition a direct act of hostility was indulged in.
The climax was reached in an article which appeared in a London quarterly review. It contained a vicious attack—too evidently inspired by jealousy and defeated ambition—upon Mrs. K. A. Tingley, the leader of the Crusade, and Outer Head of the E. S. T. This attack was not signed, but behind the shield of an admirer the same destroying hand was visible, and naturally the attack contained various false statements. It was also humorous in one important respect. Its main point lay in the supposition that Mrs. Tingley had claimed to be the reincarnation of H. P. B., which is not true. On the contrary, Mrs. Tingley has frequently stated that in her opinion H. P. B. has not reincarnated. Why publish such a vicious fabrication?
Much is made by the writer of a supposed solemn declaration by Madame Blavatsky "to all her disciples" that "in her next reincarnation she would inhabit the body of an Eastern man." Mrs. Vera Johnston, H. P. B.'s niece, Claude Falls Wright, James M. Pryse and other close friends of the "old lady's," have a different version of this story. They say that H. P. B. was asked by one of her disciples where she would reincarnate, and promptly replied: "Reincarnate? Why, of course, in the body of some nice young imbecile Hindu!" And she would frequently repeat the joke, asserting that she would be reborn as a Hindu—with only one lobe to his brain, and if he should have two he would be imbecile all the same. This joke is now paraded as a most serious argument against a claim which has never been made!
Other false statements appear in the same article, or series of articles, but they are transparently absurd and do not require refutation. In passing, however, it may be as well to state that for anyone to call Mrs. 163Tingley "a medium" is to show either a complete ignorance of occultism, or a complete ignorance of Mrs. Tingley. In either case there is less than no title to pass judgment.
Now for a few definite and positive statements. The success of the last Convention held in New York and the success of the Crusade has been very largely due to Mrs. Tingley's energy, good judgment and self-sacrifice. Every one of H. P. B.'s immediate pupils who have so far met Mrs. Tingley unhesitatingly state that the similarity between H. P. B.'s and Mrs. Tingley's methods is extraordinary and that the results now obtained if anything surpass those formerly achieved by their old teacher, perhaps owing to the wider opportunity offered at the present time. They recognize the same force, the same inspiration, the same wonderful effects. Such old students as Mrs. Alice Cleather, Drs. Archibald Keightley and Herbert A. W. Coryn, James M. Pryse, Claude Falls Wright and others come under this category, all of whom, owing to continuous personal contact with Mrs. Tingley, have had ample opportunity to form a just estimate in these respects. They should certainly have a better right to pass judgment than those who have never seen her and who blindly endeavor to destroy her by circulating falsehoods gleaned from stray newspaper gossip. Many others might be named, such as Mr. C. Johnston and Mrs. V. Johnston—the latter the niece of H. P. B.'s already referred to—who bear witness to the same effect. But better than any such comparison is the actual living testimony daily afforded by work that endures. To that, hundreds of Theosophists in America, England, Scotland and Ireland can already bear witness.
And now to the further record of the Crusaders' doings. They travelled from London to Bristol on July 8th, holding an E. S. T. meeting there that afternoon, and a public meeting the same evening, with Mr. H. P. Leonard in the chair, which was attended by over two hundred people. At the conclusion of this meeting, at which Mrs. K. A. Tingley, Mrs. Wright, Claude Falls Wright, H. T. Patterson, F. M. Pierce and E. T. Hargrove spoke as usual, the chairman announced that the Crusaders would be glad to meet and talk with members of the audience who might desire further explanations of Theosophy than those afforded by the replies to questions put publicly. The various speakers then left the platform and mingled with those in the body of the hall who remained after the formal adjournment. This practice has since been continued, as it gives an opportunity to all to come into personal contact with the Crusaders, and does much to remove the stiffness that too often pervades such gatherings.
The branch in Bristol has always had a hard struggle to hold its own, but the untiring devotion of its members during many years is certain to 164bring its reward, and the very friendly reception of the speakers at the public meeting showed that there are at least one hundred thinking men and women in that city who take a sympathetic interest in Theosophy. Sufficient praise could not be given the local members for the way in which they had worked up the Crusade meeting.
On July 10th, in the afternoon, a large E. S. T. meeting was held at Southport, a city on the west coast of England, not far from Liverpool. A public meeting the same evening, with Mr. J. K. Gardner in the chair, attracted an audience of about two hundred, and from the questions asked it was clear that many present had been deeply impressed by the message of the Crusade. One listener, not then a member of the Society, was instrumental in forming a new branch in Chesterfield within ten days after this meeting. The Southport papers gave long and appreciative reports of the proceedings, and one published a two-column interview with Mrs. Tingley and other members of the party.
From Southport the Crusaders journeyed to Middlesborough in Yorkshire. On this and other railway journeys in England and Ireland they posted a printed notice on the windows of the cars they occupied "Crusade of American Theosophists Around the World." Other travellers would curiously gather round and would gaze with astonishment at one or another Crusader busily employed with a typewriter. Much inquiry followed as to what Theosophy might be, and one country yokel was heard to remark that "them American Theosophists don't waste no time no how, that's sure."
A correspondent writes of the work in Middlesborough as follows:
The visit of the Crusaders revolutionized the work in this town. The local branch had made little progress for some time past, and members were beginning to despair of seeing it become an active power in their neighborhood. But despair fled, and hope—nay, certainty took its place when it was seen how much could be done in so short a time by a few people who simply went right ahead and worked without a thought of possible failure or of anything but the immediate work in hand.
On Sunday, July 12th, at 3 in the afternoon, an E. S. T. meeting was held at which two new members were admitted. At midnight on the same day, another E. S. T. meeting was held at which six more were admitted. This midnight gathering immediately followed a public meeting which was very well attended, the speeches made by Mrs. Tingley, Messrs. Hargrove, Wright and the other Crusaders being warmly applauded, and every word uttered being listened to with the closest attention. Questions were freely asked and answered at the conclusion of the speeches.
Apparently not content with their midnight meeting, and the admission of eight new members into the Esoteric School, since their ar165rival, another E. S. T. meeting was held on the morning of the 13th, and two more members were taken in. The Crusaders then left for South Shields, leaving behind them many close friends in the place of strangers, leaving activity in place of heavy stillness, and hope in place of despair. The good they did cannot be put into words. But we will try to show our gratitude by properly using the force they left us and by making the work in Middlesborough a permanent success.
The Crusaders held a public meeting in South Shields on the evening of their arrival, over two hundred being present. The hall was decorated as usual with the numerous flags presented to them, conspicuous among the rest being the purple banner given by the Boston T. S. with its device, "Truth, Light, Liberation for Discouraged Humanity." The proceedings opened and concluded with music. At this meeting the questions were particularly good. A local clergyman, however, who was inclined to be pugnacious, could not quite rise to the ideal of "many Christs" presented to him in reply to a question on the subject, and when the audience loudly applauded the reply, he hastily stamped out of the hall in token of his disapprobation.
At eleven o'clock that night an E. S. T. meeting was held at which fifteen members were admitted. This was a satisfactory increase, for till then there had been but one member of the school in South Shields.
On July 14th the Crusaders travelled south to Halifax, in Yorkshire, where a public meeting was held in the evening, with from two to three hundred present. A branch of the Theosophical Society in Europe (England) was formed immediately after the meeting and the next morning an E. S. T. Lodge was also formed.
Scotland was entered on the 15th. Proceedings began with a public meeting in Glasgow, attended by about one hundred and fifty people. The holiday season had taken "every one"—except the right people—out of town. The next day, July 16th, saw the founding of the T. S. in Europe (Scotland) eighteen members joining, several of them old students who for various reasons had not previously identified themselves with the Theosophical Society.
The Crusaders immediately proceeded to Edinburgh, and at the kind invitation of a lady member of the Edinburgh Lodge of the Adyar Society, addressed several people that evening at her house. No public work had heretofore been done in this city, the capital of Scotland. The "Scottish Lodge" of the Adyar Society is secret and its exact aims and purposes are not known to the uninitiated. Neither this lodge nor the Edinburgh Lodge of the same Society carry on any public propaganda; nor did the members of these bodies encourage the formation of a branch of the T. S. in Europe. After a parlor talk, however, in the hotel on the evening of the 17th, which was crowded, a branch was 166formed on the 18th, and in future there will be a nucleus of people in Edinburgh ready to support the principles of Theosophy before the public.
The Crusaders are not good sight-seers. They seem to feel no attraction for picture galleries and do not spend their evenings at theatres. But they deliberately witnessed a magnificent panorama at half-past four on the morning of the 19th. At midnight they started for King Arthur's Seat, and from that promontory,—overlooking the Castle and city of Edinburgh, overlooking hills and valleys far and near, and the Firth of Forth with its wonderful cantilever bridge, and the ocean, and a vast expanse of purple, silver and orange sky—they saw the old sun rise from behind a mountain of darkness and pour benedictions upon the earth. And they thought it worth the steep climb and the sleepless night and went on their way rejoicing.
Their way led them back to Glasgow, where they were due for another public meeting on the evening of the 19th. It was a great success; over a hundred present and the deepest interest shown. One member of the audience, of quasi-clerical persuasion, demanded five minutes in which to "exterminate the vermin" (the Crusaders), but his request was naturally not granted.
Before leaving Glasgow on the 20th an E. S. T. meeting was held at which ten members were admitted. Reaching Edinburgh again, the Crusaders were met by Mr. Herbert Crooke of Southport, who helped them to work up a large public meeting on the evening of the 21st, attended by some eight hundred people. This meeting certainly aroused immense interest. There was a disorderly element in the audience, consisting of a few university students with both theological and rowdy tendencies. But they did not begin their noise until question time came, and even then they in no way succeeded in disturbing the meeting. By way of protesting against such behavior one member of the audience rose and proposed a vote of thanks to the Crusaders, and throughout the entire proceedings the applause was hearty and continuous. This was the farewell meeting in England and Scotland and it fittingly summarized the work in those countries: intense irritation on the part of a few at the success met with, and approval shown by the large majority.
The Crusade departed for Ireland on the 22d, arriving in Dublin on the morning of the 23d. Preparations for the work there occupied the next two days, and in addition to this over one hundred and fifty letters were written by the Crusaders to fellow-workers in America. An out-door meeting was held at Bray, a sea-side resort near Dublin, on the afternoon of the 26th.
A wagonette was hired and from it the Crusaders addressed over three hundred people who soon collected at the sight of the Stars and 167Stripes floating gayly from the box-seat of the conveyance. Brother George Russell, better known as "Æ," of Irish Theosophist fame, gave a fine address on the glories of ancient Ireland and their revival in the near future.
A special mission visited Limerick on the 29th, consisting of Mrs. C. F. Wright and Brothers Wright, Patterson and Pierce. They held a public meeting there, several hundred being present. Much good-humored opposition was met with, and at one stage of the proceedings the chairman, Mr. Gibson, a local Theosophist, had to add to his functions the part of "chucker-out," forcibly ejecting a particularly noisy commentator. The meeting was, nevertheless, a huge success from every account received.
On the afternoon of July 31st a drawing-room talk was given at 3 Upper Ely Place by Brothers Hargrove and Patterson. On the evening of the same day Brothers Neresheimer and Fussell, Drs. Walton and Wood and Mrs. Wood arrived from America and were greeted with whole-hearted delight by both the Crusaders and the Dublin members. The story of the work in Ireland can well be told by Brother Fussell.
On Saturday, August 1st, the day after our arrival in Dublin, a Brotherhood supper was given to about four hundred men and women from the poorest parts of the city. Several newsboys and young girls who had been found begging on the streets were also present and were feasted on an unlimited supply of cake and tea. The short addresses made by the Crusaders and others after supper were listened to with great interest and attention, those by Mrs. Tingley and Mrs. Wright receiving especial applause.
The Convention of the T. S. in Europe was held on August 2d and 3d. An account of this will be found in the Mirror of the Movement. On the afternoon of Monday, August 3d, an E. S. T. meeting was held, at which thirteen new members were admitted, and on the evening of the same day a reception was given at 3 Upper Ely Place, the rooms being crowded. Tuesday, August 4th, was occupied mainly by personal talks and discussion of plans of work. In the evening an informal meeting was held to discuss Lotus Circle work. A large meeting of the Dublin Lodge was held on Wednesday, many visitors being present. The Rev. W. Williams read a paper on the Kabbala and addresses were given on general Theosophical topics by some of the delegates and Crusaders. August 5th was also occupied largely by personal talks in regard to the work and in getting off arrears of correspondence.
Brothers Pierce and Herbert Crooke left Dublin for Killarney to arrange the camp so that the rest of the party might find it ready for them on their arrival the following day. Those remaining behind were kept busy with correspondence and personal interviews and at midnight a farewell meeting was held at Maple's Hotel, where the Crusaders were staying. At 3.30 on Thursday, August 6th, the Crusaders, accompanied by the American delegates and others, arrived at Killarney, where a stone was to be found to form part of the foundation stone of the School R. L. M. A. and where other work was to be done. Brothers Dick, Dunlop, Johnston, Mrs. Johnston, Mrs. Dick and others joined the camp later.
The stone was found on the next day and on the 8th a cairn was built on the spot from which it was taken. On Sunday, the 9th, an E. S. T. meeting was held at the camp at 11 A. M. and in the afternoon several talks were given by different members to groups of 168people who came to visit the camp. Several sketches of the camp and of the neighborhood were made by our two artist friends, Brothers Machell and Russell.
On the 10th the camp was broken up and the party left for London, arriving there on the 11th. Preparations were made for the tour of the Crusaders on the Continent, and a farewell E. S. T. meeting was held on the evening of the 12th.
It is impossible to adequately describe the work of the Crusaders and the tremendous impetus which is being given to the Theosophical movement in every place they visit. Everywhere the members receive new life and energy, and everywhere is being spread a unifying influence, bringing us nearer to a realization of true brotherhood. And yet it is evident that great as are even now the results of the Crusaders' work the full harvest is still to come and will not be fully seen till our comrades shall have completed their great task in carrying the message of Theosophy around the world.
On August 13th, at 11 a. m., the Crusaders left for Paris, Drs. Walton and Wood and Mrs. Wood travelling with them. They were seen off at Holborn Viaduct Station by the contingent from America, Brothers E. A. Neresheimer, J. H. Fussell and Fred Neresheimer, and by many of the London members, Drs. Keightley and Coryn, Sydney Coryn, Basil Crump, Roger Hall, Thomas Green and others, who have done so much to make their work in London the success it has been.
An easy journey brought them to Paris, after a fair crossing of the much dreaded English channel. They were met there by an old Boston member, a friend of H. P. B.'s, whom all were very glad to see—Madame Peterson.
There is to be a public meeting here and an E. S. T. meeting, and between whiles an attempt to get equal with an enormous accumulation of correspondence. Then farewell to France and flying visits to Brussels, Amsterdam and other European cities before reaching that ancient land of wisdom, Egypt.
Paris, August 14, 1896.
E. T. H.
193 It is one of the common-places of Occultism that the true science of life lies hidden in every-day events. If these be understood, universal nature becomes easy to interpret. But common-places are apt to be ignored, because of their self-evident truth and apparent lack of complexity. So in Theosophy, when students begin their study of "occult" matters, and seek to open up "communication with Masters," they almost invariably look for striking and phenomenal results, and in their anxiety to obtain these, lose sight of simple nature's countless voices. "The Master-Soul is One," and the true Master is that Supreme Self, made manifest in a fitting vehicle, yet single and common to all that lives. For that reason it has been truly said that all men are our teachers, since all men veil that divine presence, and in rare moments may so far forget themselves as to permit this "dark divinity" to shine forth and illumine the lives of others. But before we can recognize the divine without us, we must see it within ourselves: the divine is only known to the divine. Unless the eyes be opened, the brightest objects remain unseen, and unless the eyes of the mind be awake, the purpose and message of the world that surrounds us must remain unrecognized. Particularly must this be the case with those smaller circumstances which only the accustomed eye observes, in the same way that the eye of the dyer knows shades and tones that cannot be sensed without long prac194tice. So the smaller circumstances too often pass by, treated with a contempt they do not deserve, while the subterranean or celestial but unmistakably phenomenal voice remains an immaterial expectation.
But even supposing such small circumstances be recognized, be properly interpreted, how difficult to relate them to others so as to convey their real significance! It is their constant occurrence, their sequence, their very simplicity, that makes them at once so full of meaning and so intangible. In nearly every instance they must remain, as in their origin, "occult."
Such a train of thought is the natural outcome of mentally reviewing the work of "The Crusade of American Theosophists around the World," up to the present time. The evident success of the Crusade has been striking enough, but for one who has taken part in its work the most remarkable thing about it has been the marvellously wise leadership of Mrs. K. A. Tingley, and the extraordinary luck that has never deserted the party in any undertaking so far entered into. The world, which is foolish for the most part, would attribute this good luck to chance; but to the Theosophist, who does not believe in chance, the wonderful luck experienced so continuously makes it appear as though the heart of Nature had been touched by some spiritual force, impelling her to fight for the success of the enterprise.
Innumerable small occurrences, leading to results of great importance, have well exemplified this, and in many instances it has been the immediate recognition of their real significance by Mrs. Tingley which led to their proper utilization. Luck (in the true sense of the word) is not easily overcome; nor is wisdom, at any time or under any circumstances: but when wisdom and luck are united you have a practically unconquerable combination.
Now for a record of the recent activities of the Crusade. The result of the work in Paris was the formation of the French division of the Theosophical Society in Europe on August 21st, at 8.30 p. m., in a large parlor at the Hotel St. Petersbourg. Public meetings at the same hotel, on the evenings of the 16th, 18th and 19th, and a larger gathering at the Hotel Continental on the evening of the 20th, led up to this farewell meeting on the 21st. Mons. Charles See was elected President of the newly formed Society, and with the invaluable assistance of Mme. Petersen, who did so much to help the work of the Crusade in Paris, the movement in France should soon become as active as it already is in Holland and Germany. A meeting of the Esoteric School on the morning of the 22d immediately preceded the departure of the Crusaders for Amsterdam. They traveled by way of Brussels, patiently endured an examination of 195their baggage at both the Belgian and Dutch frontiers, and reached "The Venice of the North" with its bewildering ramification of canals late that night. There they stopped at the Hotel Pays Bas, where the table linen and in fact every spoon, fork, chair and carpet in the place were marked with the familiar initials "H. P. B."!
Early the next morning (Sunday, the 23d August, a day of considerable activity) there was a great assemblage of old as well as new friends at the Headquarters. Madame Hermance de Neufville, an old friend of Madame Blavatsky's, Mlle. Immerzeel, Mme. van Pellecorn, Brothers Van der Zeyde, Jasink, Goud, Haupt, and many others who stood so loyally by W. Q. Judge in 1895, were all present, and at half-past ten a meeting of the T. S. in Holland was formally opened. An address of welcome was made by the chairman, Brother Van der Zeyde, and then the Crusaders spoke in English, their speeches being translated into Dutch, phrase by phrase. In the afternoon there was an E. S. T. meeting, twelve new members being admitted, and in the evening a public meeting was held at Frascati's, attended by some seven hundred people who listened with the closest attention to the speeches of the Crusaders, much applause being given to each speaker. Brother C. F. Wright gave a particularly admirable address, which delighted the audience and which seemed to lose little in the hands of the translator. When the time came for the usual questions, however, some disturbance was created by two or three Anarchists and Socialists, young boys of 17 and 18, who demanded permission to address the audience from the platform and air their views on capital and labor. As no reference had been made to such subjects by the speakers, permission was refused and the boys howled imprecations until a policeman appeared, when they hastily withdrew. This disturbance in no way interfered with the meeting, one of the most successful yet held. If anything it helped to evoke the sympathy of the majority present, many of whom at the close of the meeting expressed their deep regret that such interruptions should have occurred "in Holland." They explained that it was almost impossible to hold a meeting in a public hall in Amsterdam without similar attempts being made to procure a ready-made audience for the propaganda of revolutionary ideas. There is a very strong revolutionary party in both Holland and Belgium, which is wrongly called Socialistic, being for the most part anarchical in its tendency and methods. A great field for Theosophy!
At sunrise next morning the Crusaders and between twenty and thirty of the Dutch members started in seven carriages to find a stone to be placed with others from other countries in the foundations of the School for the Revival of the Lost Mysteries of Antiquity. In a flat country like Holland it is not easy to find stones of any description, but after an hour's drive one was discovered at 6 o'clock in the morning and was 196carried back in triumph to the Headquarters at Amsterdam. That afternoon, the 24th, the Crusaders were "at home" at their hotel and in the evening were present at a meeting at the Headquarters at which they spoke on branch work. Next day there were further meetings in the afternoon and evening—in the afternoon of an informal character—and on the 26th, at 8.33 a.m., the party left for Berlin. Almost the entire Amsterdam Branch, with several members from Arnheim, The Hague and Zaandam were present at the station to bid the Crusaders farewell, and it was with real regret on both sides that the farewells were said.
Another frontier and on this occasion some hesitation on the part of a custom house officer over the numerous flags discovered in a suspicious looking hand-bag. These were the national flags that have been presented to the Crusade by the local members in each country so far visited. Could these people be the agents of some foreign government? But the Catholicism of English, Scotch, Irish, French, and Swedish flags, as well as the Stars and Stripes, appeared to puzzle the officer, until a glimpse of E. T. Hargrove's typewriter—which was mistaken for a musical instrument—apparently cleared his mind on the subject. The Crusade was a variety show and therefore innocuous!
So on to Berlin, which was reached at about 11 p.m. A national charter for the T. S. in Europe (Germany) had been issued immediately after the Dublin Convention, so there was no Society to be formed in Germany but a good field already prepared for the sowing of the seed. In connection with the work there the name of Brother Richard Prater of New York must be mentioned, for the existence of the Society in Germany to-day is very largely due to his unwavering perseverance. For years he has been mailing pamphlets, writing letters and in every other way doing his best to prepare the ground and keep up whatever interest might have already been aroused. Dr. Franz Hartmann's continuous work in Germany is too well known to need recognition, with his Lotusblüthen, his immense personal correspondence and the numerous books he has written. Brother Paul Raatz, the President of the Berlin Branch of the T. S. in Germany, did splendid service in Berlin; but R. Prater did what no resident could accomplish, for he worked from a distance and his work certainly produced a telling effect.
A meeting of the Berlin Branch on the evening of the 27th August, opened the work of the Crusade in Germany, at which speeches were made in English by the Crusaders and translated into German by various local members. A larger meeting was held next evening, convened by means of personal invitations, at which some two hundred students of Theosophy were present. On the 29th a public meeting was held in the large hall of the Vereinshaus with about 400 present. The hall was full to overflowing and a number of people were obliged to stand throughout 197the proceedings. Dr. Franz Hartmann occupied the chair and after a few preliminary remarks by him the Crusaders spoke on various Theosophical subjects, each speech being warmly received. The larger part of the audience lingered for nearly an hour after the meeting had been formally closed, asking questions about Theosophy and the Society, and showing that their interest had been thoroughly aroused by what they had seen and heard.
At midday on the 30th, the first annual meeting of the T. S. in Germany was called to order by the President of the T. S. in Europe. Brother Theodor Reuss—who will certainly become better known to Theosophists before long both as a fine speaker and an invaluable worker—was elected chairman of the meeting. Dr. Hartmann was then elected President, and Herr Reuss Vice-President of the T. S. in Europe (Germany) amid loud applause. The utmost enthusiasm and unanimity characterized the proceedings, which were brought to a conclusion by the inevitable Convention photograph.[2] That afternoon an E. S. T. meeting was held at the Residenz Hotel, at which eleven new members were admitted. Brother H. T. Patterson had meanwhile left for Hamburg, where he held an E. S. T. meeting, returning to Berlin in time to join the rest of the Crusaders who started at 7.40 a. m., on the 31st of August for Heidelberg. A brief exploration of Heidelberg Castle, with its Alchemist's Tower and magnificent terrace, and then off for Geneva, which was reached at 1 a. m. on September 2d. There the Crusaders found two members who had not until then known of each other's existence—Brothers H. L. Purucker and Karl Brünnich. They had both been working quietly, and without attempting public propaganda. Together, they should accomplish much which it would not be possible for an isolated member to undertake. A parlor-talk at the Hotel Metropole on the evening of the 3d; then next morning off to Interlaken, and a good night's sleep by way of a change. Some of the party made an independent Crusade to Grindelwald on the 6th, in order to get a breath of mountain air, but returned the same evening for a meeting at the Hotel Victoria at Interlaken, where they spoke all the better for their change. This meeting was unique in its way. The large Ladies Drawing Room crowded to overflowing, with many standing; a mixed audience of Americans and English, holiday seekers one and all, professional and business men with their wives and daughters. Splendid propagandists whether they agreed with you or not, seeing that for two months in every year their only need is a subject for conversation at table d'hôte; and what could serve them better than Theosophy? The questions were below the average from the standpoint of intelligence, which was to be expected under the circumstances; but the interest was 198intense and a week in the hotel would have turned it into a Theosophical headquarters. One or two questioners endeavored to amuse the audience at the expense of the Crusaders, but were rather severely punished in a polite way.
On the road again (Sept. 7th), and this time for Hallein in Austria, the home of Dr. Hartmann. Over the famous Brünig Pass, with its glorious view of Lake Brienz, the Jungfrau, Wetterhorn, Faulhorn and other Alpine peaks; through Lucerne with its quaint bridges and fashionable hotels, to Zurich, where a night is spent in needed rest. Then another early start and a quick passage across Lake Constance, dazzlingly beautiful with its girdle of mist-covered purple hills and snow-capped mountains. But the opportunity for writing letters is not to be missed, so most of the Crusaders devote themselves to that practical occupation until called upon to expose their worldly possessions for the edification of a custom house-officer at Lindau, the German frontier town. So on to Munich, with its second finest library in the world, and to Salzburg where was the home of Paracelsus and where his tomb may be seen to-day. Next morning, the 9th, Dr. Hartmann makes a welcome appearance at the Salzburg station and conveys the party to Hallein. He is full of information concerning the locality, pointing out the far-famed Salt Mountain, with its caverns and its lakes hidden deep beneath the earth's surface; then the weird looking mountain where according to the legends the soul of Kaiser Barbarossa is still imprisoned. But the Crusaders did not leave America on a pleasure trip, so on the following evening, after a day of incessant writing, a meeting was held at the Hotel Stern, at which an illuminated address from the members of the Crusade was presented to Dr. Hartmann. As some of those present, including a Turkish gentleman, were not members of the Society, brief speeches were made concerning Theosophy and the movement in general. Dr. Kellner, an old member, also spoke, welcoming the Crusaders to Austria in a few well-chosen words.
Now for Vienna, where it is certain that a Theosophical Society will be formed; then to Italy, Malta, Greece and Egypt.
Hallein, Austria, 11th September, 1896.
E. T. H.
225 It is very difficult for those actually taking part in the Crusade of American Theosophists around the world to adequately describe its progress. The very appearance of exaggeration has to be avoided, and this may well lead to an under—rather than to an over—estimate of the success of the work. It is notorious that a participant can never write the history of an event. He colors all that he sees with his personal idiosyncracies and preferences. He is not sufficiently removed from the "sphere of activity" to see things in correct perspective. The best he can do is to faithfully narrate occurrences, leaving it to others to compare results with previous achievements and to offer a synthetic view of the undertaking.
The duty of the historian is to help the man of to-day to understand himself and his fellow men. This he can do by revivifying the thoughts and actions of men in by-gone ages, showing that history is but the orderly unfolding of thought in action—of thought which was not peculiar to Nero, Constantine or Alexander, but which is very common, very near, and which enters as much into the buying and selling of a cabbage as it entered into the partition of Poland many years ago. But to see the universal application in the particular instance when the instance is still vibrating within us, is a difficulty hard to overcome. Nevertheless, until overcome, we are only talkers of philosophy, not livers of it. We must 226learn to see the great in the small and the small in the great, and must know that both great and small are the expression of universal forces and are governed by universal laws.
This impersonal view of history and of life cannot be obtained, however, without an understanding of the personal element which plays so prominent a part in every political as well as domestic incident. To properly study the war of American Independence would be impossible unless the character of Washington, for instance, were constantly kept in mind. Both the inductive and deductive methods must be followed in order to insure satisfactory results. So, in the case of the Theosophical Crusade, no matter how impersonal we may wish to be in recording its activities, it would be unwise to overlook the characteristics of those taking part in it. What may be said will not be an elaborate analysis, for the difficulty previously referred to of justly estimating immediate surroundings makes brevity not only a virtue but an overwhelming necessity. And in any case we may know that future historians will be delighted to provide unlimited destructive criticism!
Mrs. Katherine A. Tingley is the leader and originator of the Crusade. She has been well called the leader of the Theosophical movement throughout the world. At the last Convention of the Theosophical Society in Europe, she was elected Corresponding Secretary, the significance of which lies in the fact that the only previous holder of the office was Mme. H. P. Blavatsky, the Founder of the Society. Mrs. Tingley is also the Head of the Esoteric School.
I think it is Emerson who says that one of the most delightful attributes of the "heroic class is the good-humor and hilarity they exhibit," and the leader of the Crusade has an inexhaustible fund of good-humor. Neither illness nor what is often acute pain resulting from illness can in any way daunt her perennial cheerfulness. Another of her characteristics is her persistency. Having chosen her path she will abide by it; having entered upon some undertaking she will never relinquish it until success has been achieved. She is an indefatigable worker, with boundless energy, and becomes absolutely absorbed in whatever she has in hand. She is wonderfully free from prejudice, and as long as a thing is wise and right is careless of precedent or custom. Fearless of public opinion, without going to the foolish extreme of disregarding it; deeply compassionate as only those can be who have suffered largely and generously; humble and peculiarly child-like in disposition, she also has a large fund of common-sense, a very keen understanding of human nature and a profound knowledge of the world. Another characteristic is of great importance,—a capacity rather than a characteristic. In the past men have become famous on account of their ability to sense and take advantage of an opportunity. Such men have not always known when 227to abstain from action and have consequently brought about their own destruction in the end. It is a question of sensing the tide of great forces in nature, whether expansive or contractive. Events and what we call opportunities are but the outer expression of these forces. Mrs. Tingley has that sense to a remarkable degree, unusually developed, for she recognizes occasions when inaction is as important as decisive action is necessary at other times. This in itself stamps the great leader. She is furthermore a very fine speaker, appealing to the hearts of her hearers, throwing great force into all that she says. No wonder that she is both beloved and respected by all who know her! What the movement owes to her self-sacrifice it would be impossible to express.
In this brief sketch, based upon continuous personal experience, no reference has been made to the higher psychic and spiritual gifts which Mrs. Tingley possesses, for testimony in regard to such matters more often does harm than good.
Continuing, with the ladies of the party first in order, there is Mrs. Alice L. Cleather, an old and faithful member of the Theosophical Society, one of Mme. H. P. Blavatsky's personal pupils and a very warm friend of Mr. W. Q. Judge. She joined the Crusade on September 20th, at Rome. An Englishwoman by birth and education, wife of a colonel in the English army, she is nevertheless a good American in her sympathies. Two visits paid to America, one in '95 and the other in '96, endeared her to so many members there that they will well understand how useful are her services as a member of the party. Mrs. Cleather is a good lecturer, speaking with deliberation and with considerable force. She is tireless in assisting younger students, for which she is admirably fitted as a result of many years careful study of the philosophy.
Mrs. Claude Falls Wright, who did so much for Theosophy in Chicago and Boston, is another important factor in the work of the Crusade, a great favorite with all who meet her. She has the rare gift of adapting herself to circumstances, an invaluable quality in work of this sort. Her unselfishness, her evenness of temperament, and her intense devotion to the cause, have often been severely tried, but have never been found wanting. As a speaker she enlists the sympathies of her audience by a certain freshness of style and by her evident indifference to its opinion of herself, personally; a characteristic which this blase world does not look for in the younger generation! She is also logical in her thought—altogether a convincing speaker. At receptions and interviews she has been of great assistance to Mrs. Tingley, who has the highest possible regard for her. If it had not been for her numerous letters to Branches in America, members there could not possibly have been kept as well informed as they have been of the progress of the Crusade.
Claude Falls Wright is so well known throughout the length and 228breadth of the Theosophical Society that little need be said concerning him. He is the President of the Aryan Theosophical Society of New York. Like Mrs. Cleather he was a pupil of Mme. H. P. Blavatsky's, acting as her Secretary as he later on acted as Mr. Judge's. He has had a most varied experience of the work in the movement, both in the office and in the lecture-field, of which he has taken the fullest advantage. And he loves the work; nothing better, throwing into it all his life and energy. He has of course been of the greatest service on the Crusade in working up public meetings, as well as when speaking at these meetings. For as a speaker he is not only fluent; he shows a wide range of thought and much originality. He is versatile and on his travels will doubtless gather much information which should ultimately be of no little use to the movement. Certainly the Crusade would have lost very much if Claude Falls Wright had been by any chance omitted from the party. No one could have filled his place.
H. T. Patterson, President of the Brooklyn Branch of the Theosophical Society in America, is also well-known as an old student and an incessant worker for Theosophy. As the head of a large business in New York it naturally fell to his lot to look after many matters of detail in connection with Crusade activities. He has performed the incredible task of shepherding the trunks and hand-baggage of the party across Europe without loss or damage (the check-system is not in vogue there). He has had stand-up fights with English, French, Belgian, Dutch, German, Austrian, Swiss, Italian, Greek and even Egyptian porters, and has preserved the amiability for which he is justly celebrated. Seriously, his well-known affability and kindliness have been of real service, particularly when he has occupied the chair at public meetings, which he has almost invariably done. As a speaker he excels in his illustrations. He has written more letters since leaving America in June last than he has ever written in his life before.
F. M. Pierce is also a prominent business man in New York. He is acting as the representative of the School for the Revival of the Lost Mysteries of Antiquity in connection with the Crusade. He has done an immense work in that way; a work, however, which cannot be chronicled, for it has been done through personal contact with individuals, only the results of which have been evident. But the School already owes him more than could well be believed unless his work had to some extent been witnessed. He has also acted as the cicerone of the party—no light task. He has looked after railway and steamboat routes, hotels, and the countless other necessary things which make traveling comfortable or the reverse. No one with experience of European traveling would have believed that such a party could have traveled either so cheaply or so comfortably as it has done. Not one hitch, and not one 229cent wasted. This should show what type of man he is: a tall and very strongly built man, patient, intuitive, with sound "horse-sense," absolutely devoted to Theosophy, self-sacrificing as few can be. His best work is done with individual enquirers, to whom he gives Theosophy in "solid chunks," as one of them remarked, ramming these home with pointed logic and his own over-mastering conviction.
In addition to the above there is the writer, making seven in all; as united a body as it would be possible to get together, each having his own place and duties and yet all of them interacting perfectly.
Much territory has been covered since my last report was written and a great many people have been helped by the message of the Crusade. The Crusaders left Hallein for Vienna on the 11th, arriving there the same day. They received a most cordial welcome from the three or four members of the Society in that city, and on the following evening held an informal meeting at their hotel to consider the formation of a Theosophical Society in Austria. About twelve were present, not including the Crusaders. On the 13th a public meeting was held in a large parlor in the hotel, some fifty attending. It was a decided success, as it ought to have been, considering the labor of organizing it. For the doctrine of "the liberty of the subject" is not looked upon with favor by the Austrian police, and in order to hold a public meeting an infinite amount of red-tape has to be twisted and untwisted. Affidavits have to be sworn that no reference will be made to religion, nor to brotherhood (!); a police officer must be in attendance and must be paid for his services, and if he hears any remark which in his opinion is disrespectful to Emperor or government, woe betide the offender. As delay is of the very essence of red-tape, it is not surprising that as a rule it takes three days for an application for permission to hold a public meeting to reach the officer who controls such matters, and an indefinite time for the permission to be finally granted. So there were some doubts as to whether it would be possible to rush a meeting through with only twelve hours' notice. Thanks to Mr. Wright's persuasive pertinacity and to his plea that we were Americans and were built that way, permission was granted, the meeting was held, and an officer in full uniform graced the proceedings throughout—a congenial spirit, as it happened, a very polite and amiable man.
Next day a Theosophical Society in Austria was formed, with seventeen earnest and devoted members, many of them old students of Theosophy. Herr Last was unanimously elected President; Herr Lang, Vice-President, and Herr Max Taubert, Secretary. The latter had given invaluable assistance as interpreter and as guide through the intricacies of Viennese custom. On the 14th, ten members were taken into the Esoteric 230School. An early departure was made on the following morning for Udine, a small town in Italy, just beyond the Austrian frontier, not far from Trieste. The journey to Venice had to be broken in any case, and promise had been made by Mrs. Tingley to her friend the Countess di Brazza that if possible the members of the party would visit her at her old Friulian castle, an hour's drive from the city of Udine. Two restful days were thus passed, Mrs. Tingley and Mrs. Wright staying at the castle, the men of the party sleeping at an hotel, the opportunity being taken to catch up to some extent with the pile of accumulated mail. Then to Venice, once so mighty, now so terribly dilapidated; a relic of the past, a skeleton city; glorying in its monuments, in its Piazza and Church of St. Mark, magnificent with mosaic, in its Palace of the Doges and Ponte dei Sospiri or Bridge of Sighs, in its much-vaunted "oldest aristocracy in Europe"—soulless, nearly lifeless, nothing but a husk.
So on to Rome, reached on the evening of the 20th, after a twelve hours' stifling journey: Rome, once the capital of the world, the home of the Caesars, still the centre of much power, wielded by the Roman Church. It is a wonderful city, a lasting exemplification of the old warning, Sic transit gloria mundi. There is the Palace of the Caesars and the Colosseum to remind one of the splendor and yet the folly of Imperial Rome; the Catacombs, a relic of early Christian days as the guide-books say, and St. Peter's and the Vatican, resplendent with marbles that once decorated heathen temples, as witnesses to the size and imposing majesty of the modern church. Then there is the Castle of St. Angelo, once the tomb of Hadrian, next a fortress, a Palace of the Popes and a prison, where Cagliostro was incarcerated and before him, Bruno.
But there was a meeting to be held there and only a spare hour or two for sight-seeing, at which, as has been remarked before, the Crusaders do not excel. So in this city of all cities, speeches were delivered on Brotherhood, Toleration, the universality of truth, on the dignity and innate divinity of man, on Reincarnation. The audience in the large parlor of the hotel was a mixed one; people present from Russia, South Africa, England, as well as Italy. Other and equally important work was done, and then at midnight on the 22d a start was made for Naples. This was a halting place on the way to Athens, where trunks had been forwarded by sea from London. Naples is celebrated (a) for being the dirtiest city in Italy, (b) for being near to Mt. Vesuvius, (c) for being the modern imitation of the ancient city of Pompeii which was so fortunately destroyed during the eruption of Vesuvius in A. D. 79. It is also celebrated for its mosquitos, which "do not bite, but chew," as an American tourist once remarked. These mosquitos did serious damage to three members of the party, who carried away with them a lasting souvenir of their visit.
231No public meeting was held in Naples, but circulars and leaflets were industriously circulated throughout the town. Early on the morning of the 25th the Crusaders left for Athens, going by train to Brindisi and from there traveling by the Austrian-Lloyd line to Patras, the Liverpool of modern Greece.
Patras was reached on the morning of the 27th, and Athens, by way of Corinth, the same evening. There were no members there to meet us, and not one in the party could speak modern Greek! Judged superficially the outlook for Theosophy did not look hopeful. Only those who have experienced it can quite appreciate the peculiar sensation of being surrounded by unintelligible talking, and many vows were registered by the Crusaders to learn not only French and German, but all the spoken languages. Not an easy task truly, but the fact remains that one of the most formidable barriers to Brotherhood, is the barrier of unknown languages.
Nothing daunted by either real or apparent difficulties, steps were promptly taken to overcome them. The American Consul was called upon, a cultivated and delightful man, who, curiously enough, had been made an honorary member of the Chicago Branch years ago and who was familiar with the tenets of Theosophy. He introduced the party to the American Vice-Consul, Mr. Nicoleides, a Greek of the best type, a friend of the King's, of marvellously quick intelligence, who knew everyone worth knowing in Athens, and who spoke English excellently. He not only quickly understood what was wanted and hastened to do his utmost for us; he as quickly grasped the general principles of Theosophy and ultimately became a member of the T. S. in Greece.
But before forming the Society there was another matter needing attention. There were several hundred Armenian refugees in the neighborhood of Athens, in the most miserable plight. They had been generously supplied with tents by the Greek government and received a pittance of food from the local Relief Committee, but during the cold nights were in terrible need of warm coverings. Many of them had fled from Constantinople with nothing but the clothes they were wearing at the time. It was at first proposed to give them a "Brotherhood Supper," but their more pressing need of blankets being only too evident after a visit to their camp, Mrs. Tingley decided to purchase a number out of a private fund partly raised by the Crusaders themselves, and to distribute these in place of the supper. An Armenian gentleman, a naturalized American citizen, who had devoted his life to the protection and relief of his unfortunate fellow-countrymen—Mr. Verjohn—assisted in this, translating the few words of hope and encouragement which the Crusaders addressed to them into their own language. It was an extraordinary sight, one never to be forgotten, to see these exiled and homeless 232people so eagerly listening to all that was said, so piteously grateful for the help they received. They will not hastily forget Theosophy.
But modern Athens still had to be converted to the doctrines it had once known so well! Only a few miles from the city stands the site and many of the ruins, recently excavated, of the ancient Temple of Eleusis, where the Eleusinian mysteries in honor of Demeter were held until the end of the fourth century of our era, then to disappear, alas! from the gaze of men. It was of those mysteries that Cicero, who had been initiated, wrote that they taught men "not only to live happily, but to die with a fairer hope." Right in the heart of Athens itself stands the world-famed Acropolis, with its Temple of Minerva and its Parthenon which once held Phidias' statue of Athene Parthenos. Not far from there lies the site of Plato's School; the prison of Socrates, in perfect preservation, and countless other reminders of what the Athens of the past had done for the western world—sufficiently inspiring, as every Theosophist will understand. And the results were in keeping with the inspiration. The largest hall in the city, the "Hall of Parnassos," was taken for the public meeting on the evening of the 30th. It was packed with a deeply attentive audience, who appreciated every point made and seemed to intuitively grasp the full application of every idea put forward. There was not a vacant seat, hundreds were standing, and according to the police report over five hundred people were turned away at the doors after the hall had been filled to overflowing. A wonderful meeting, followed next evening by the formation of a Theosophical Society in Greece with 106 members. Mr. Cavarfy was elected President amidst much enthusiasm. He had very kindly acted as interpreter and his perfect knowledge of English together with his previous reading of theosophical literature enabled him to render in classic Greek ideas that are too easily distorted by bad translation. Under his able leadership the Society in Greece is sure to prosper. Applications for membership were already coming in from the provinces when the Crusade left the city on October 4th, and in a few years it is quite possible that Athens will again become a great centre of Theosophical thought.
A smooth passage across the Mediterranean from Piraeus to Alexandria, brought the Crusaders to the mouth of the Nile on the morning of the 6th. That afternoon they reached Cairo. The next report will tell of the work in Egypt.
Cairo, October 7th, 1896.
E. T. H.
257
The Screen of Time.
To arrive at Alexandria from some European port is to undergo a siege against which the fiercest resistance has to be offered if the unfortunate passenger would land in safety. As a first experience of the East it is not a pleasing one, though vastly entertaining in retrospect.
As soon as a vessel is sighted some hundred or more boats put off from the shore, each manned by several Arabs, whose business it is to yell with fiendish expectation until they have boarded their prize. This they do in one wild rush, each striving to be the first up the "companion," all scrambling over each other in headlong confusion, fighting, kicking, tearing their way on to the deck. Then only is the turmoil momentarily stayed, as they severally grab any piece of luggage they can lay hands on, and fling themselves once more into their boats, from which place of comparative safety they triumphantly wave their capture at its rightful owner. They believe in the saying that wherever the treasure is there will the heart be also !
The Crusaders made a stubborn resistance, in which Mr. F. M. Pierce, as cicerone, naturally took a leading part. They finally succeeded in discovering Messrs. Cook's Arab representative, whose big stick protected them from further onslaughts, and who in due course conducted them safely to the train for Cairo.
* * * * * *
258Such an experience naturally led to a certain amount of moralizing, and to a comparison of the manners and customs of different races. Generally speaking the inhabitants of southern countries are more demonstrative than the staider folk of the north. It would be difficult to exaggerate the influence of the climate and physical characteristics of a country upon its inhabitants.
The Nile, for instance, has been the backbone of Egypt in all ages. Without it the country must have remained a barren desert, its people nomadic savages. For the Nile has always been the highway of commerce and the fertilizer of the entire country. The control of its course and the utilization of its water made a knowledge of river-engineering and land-surveying absolutely necessary, and the approach and departure of its inundations must have greatly stimulated the study of astronomy in all its branches, for only by means of "heaven's eternal calendar" could they be foretold.
Year after year the overflow of the river would obliterate all landmarks, so that the land had to be constantly measured anew, careful registers of property had to be kept, and judicial courts had to be maintained to settle disputes as to title. In an hundred other ways the Nile called forth all the genius latent in the Egyptian people, leading them along a line of development that sharply distinguished them from contemporary races.
The more superficial peculiarities of races in most cases can generally be traced to their origin in a similar way. The rugged strength of the ancient Spartans was largely due to the nature of their country—barren, rocky, difficult to cultivate, hard to live in. The originality of the American people must be largely attributable to the many new conditions which the early settlers met with and boldly overcame. The same originality was no doubt latent in their forefathers; but necessity alone could evoke it.
Mr. Judge repeatedly urged upon students of Theosophy the advisability of studying the peculiarities of the race to which they belonged, for every individual is bound to mirror to a greater or less degree the weaknesses as well as the virtues of his own nation ; and such inherited tendencies are the most misleading and the most difficult to recognize. But in order to study such peculiarities their cause should be determined, otherwise they can never be overcome. Much common-sense is naturally needed in this as in every other study, for without it hard and fast conclusions may be arrived at (especially in regard to other people) which can only hinder instead of helping the student to understand himself and the human mind and heart generally.
There are so many exceptions, so many influences to be reckoned 259with that come into the life during boyhood and manhood, besides the basic character, brought over from the past, which may be sufficiently strong to set at naught every other inheritance, that to form a hasty judgment would be worse than forming none.
Other nations have to be studied as well as one's own, with the same object in view, and if this be properly done a larger tolerance and more sympathetic appreciation of all "foreigners" should result. If Theosophists are to be leaders in the cause of universal brotherhood they should be the first to rid themselves of race prejudices, and after that should do their best to exert the same influence upon others.
So long as men look for evil they will find it; if they were to recognize the fact that good must exist and were to seek for it, it would quickly be discovered. Europe to-day stands in constant danger of a fratricidal war because of the absurd and unwarrantable suspicions entertained by each nation against all the rest—with one or two exceptions where the opposite extreme has been reached. These suspicions and fears are fostered by a narrow study of history, and the past is used as an incentive for revenge instead of as a permanent argument in favor of peace and good-will.
Arbitration may or may not be practical, but it is certain that if the doctrines of Rebirth and Compensation were widely accepted, the nations of the world would not be so ready to rush into war as they now are. An immense toleration would take the place of bigotry and jealousy and the idea of unselfish statesmanship, which appears at the present time like a contradiction in terms might become, at least, an ideal to be striven for.
All of which is a somewhat long commentary on the methods of Alexandrian porters, but a natural one nevertheless, for flurried tourists have frequently supposed themselves to be the victims of barefaced robbery, when in fact these men are uncommonly honest and only act as they do because competition among themselves is keen and because it is a tradition among them that most Europeans will follow their baggage to the gateway of the nether-world—possibly beyond it.
For Egypt, Alexandria is a comparatively modern town, having been founded by Alexander the Great, b. c. 332. It was the home of many great thinkers, such as Euclid, Aristarchus, Timon, Conon, Strabo, Ptolemaeus, Archimedes, Ammonius Saccas, Plotinus, Porphyrius, and Jamblichus. In 415 a.d. Hypatia, "the last of the pagans," was murdered by an Alexandrian mob, and the city then passed into the hands of the Persians, Arabs and Turks successively, entirely losing its position as a great centre of philosophy and science. To-day it is a commercial town with but few relics of its ancient glory.
260The Crusaders did not stop in Alexandria, merely passing through on their way to Cairo, where they arrived on October 6th.
The early history of Cairo is not known, and the more recent history seems to have presented an almost continuous succession of revolutions, rapine and bloodshed under the rulership of various grand-viziers. The Babylonians are said to have founded the modern city in 525 b.c. It would take a month's constant sight-seeing to explore Cairo. There are bazaars without number, numerous mosques, including the famous Gamia Sultan Hasan and the smaller Gamia Amr ibn el-As.
In the latter there is a column of grey marble on which the names of Allah, Mohammed, and Sultan Suleiman in Arabic characters appear in veins of a lighter color—by "a freak of nature" as the guide-books carefully explain. This mosque witnessed a very remarkable scene in 1808. At the usual period of the rise of the Nile the water began to fall. Dismayed by this strange phenomenon, the whole of the Mohammedan priesthood, the Christian clergy of every sect, and the Jewish rabbis, with one accord, assembled in the mosque of Amr to pray for the rise of the water, and so effectual were their prayers that the river ere long rose to its wonted fertilizing height. It is not recorded which sect claimed the miracle!
Then there are the Tombs of the Khalifs and the Mamelukes, various museums and so forth. But the Crusaders had no time to spare and devoted their few days' stay to forming a Theosophical Society in Egypt, paying a flying visit to the Pyramids and Museum of Gizeh the day before their departure. No public meeting was held, but numerous personal interviews led to the formation of a Society with a gentleman as its President who volunteered to occupy the position and who was certainly well qualified to do so. A Sufi and born Theosophist, he also occupies a high official position in Egypt near to the Khedive. Other work was done, but without public display, and in fact everything that had been looked forward to was accomplished in far less time than had been thought possible.
So, much has been written about the Pyramids that little remains to be said. They are disappointing at first sight. The Pyramid of Kheops—Khufu Khut or the "glorious throne of Khufu," as the Arabs call it—although still 451 feet in height appears much smaller. It requires time to appreciate its magnitude. With its original covering of marble it rose 482 feet above the level of the desert and must have appeared far grander in every respect than at present. It is significant that the thousands of tourists who annually visit this gigantic relic of antiquity have done nothing to diminish the mysterious solemnity of the interior, with its King's Chamber, Queen's Chamber and subterranean crypt. The silence is indescribable, but it is not a dead silence, for the whole colossal structure palpitates with life and power.
261The Sphinx, hewn out of the natural rock, is not less wonderful. Neither its origin nor its purpose has ever been made public. The Temple of the Sphinx or of Chephren, as it is sometimes called, is also of profound interest. Built of enormous blocks of granite, lined with slabs of alabaster, in many cases twelve feet long and six feet wide, it stands as an imperishable memorial of Egypt's material prosperity and spiritual greatness, for it has lost none of its influence as a temple, in the true sense of that word. Altogether an extraordinary place, never to be forgotten. Of Egypt's ancient religion, which some day must surely be revived, this is no place to speak. Its symbolism contains some of the greatest truths of nature, only thinly veiled, and is of course a mine of wealth for every student of Theosophy.
* * * * * *
But there were other fields waiting for the work of the Crusaders and on October 11th they left Cairo for Port Said, arriving there the same evening after an intensely hot journey. A night in a hotel of very questionable cleanliness and then next morning on board the Italian Navigation Company's S. S. "Singapore," bound for Bombay. Since then they have passed through the Suez Canal and have nearly reached Aden, at the southernmost point of the Red Sea. The heat has been stifling and the cabins have been deserted for the cooler decks, where all the passengers have passed their nights as well as days. But India lies ahead, where there is much of importance to be accomplished, and meanwhile a great deal of writing has to be finished. So the heat is overshadowed by the work.
Red Sea, nearing Aden, 17th October, 1896.
E. T. H.
292
The Screen of Time.
The Crusade has now reached India, and is consequently working among new surroundings and conditions, very different from those met with in Europe. New methods have to be adopted and lectures given that would sound strange in the ears of Europeans. The truth of the matter is that except under the personal guidance of Madame H. P. Blavatsky many years ago, the Theosophical movement in India has been an entire failure. Recently it has become a mere Hindu sect, one of thousands, and even at that is stagnant, with "dormant" branches scattered here and there which the members themselves confess to be inactive and practically useless. Excepting in Bombay and perhaps in two other Indian cities—which have yet to be inspected—it would appear from the reports of the natives who are members of the Adyar organization that no work is being done and absolutely no progress is being made. It should be understood that the organization whose Headquarters are at Adyar has no connection with the Theosophical Societies in America and Europe, and is indeed decidedly opposed to them, as the sequel will show. Mr. W. Q. Judge always did his best for the movement in India but could accomplish but little through the organization which existed in that country.
So the question naturally is, what can be done for this vast population of Mohammedans, Hindus, Parsis, Jains and Christians? With the exception of Madame H. P. Blavatsky, every prominent worker, whether American or European, who has so far become identified with the work in India, has fallen under local influences, has joined some sect, and instead of trying to free the people from their moth-eaten traditions has positively encouraged them to hug their shackles of ancient customs, forms and methods. This has strengthened the hand of orthodoxy in the country and has had the effect of hindering instead of helping forward the progress of the people. The one thing they need more than anything else—inspiration to work practically for humanity as a whole—they have not been given; nor have the two warring creeds of India, Hinduism and Mohammedanism, been brought together in the least degree.
The mental and spiritual stagnation of India is simply indescribable. Original thought or investigation is practically unheard of and is looked upon as a sign of moral depravity. A pundit can quote from a few of his sacred books—those which he considers orthodox—from morning till night, and if he be somewhat above the average intellectual standard of his district, he may attempt to write a five-thousandth commentary on one of his predecessor's commentaries on one of the Upanishads or Puranas. Commentaries,—that is the first and the last step of literary
293and spiritual achievement in the Hindu community! It is nearly as true of orthodox Mohammedan enterprise, though there are more exceptions to the rule, as there certainly are among the Parsis. But in any case how few are the exceptions, and how often they consist of unintelligent swallowers of Büchner, Spencer or Bain! The notion that the modern Hindu of necessity knows more about Theosophy than his western brethren is absolutely ridiculous. His mind is over-weighted with traditions, and if the Light of the ages were to pour its radiance upon him, he would refuse to benefit by it until that Light took upon itself some color prescribed in the Shrastras.
To anyone who loves India, such a condition of things must of necessity be sad in the extreme. It is made worse by the inordinate pride of many of the Brahmans who consider that civilization and wisdom begins and ends with themselves. Their attitude is well illustrated by a remark made to the writer by a Brahmin pundit in regard to Mr. W. Q. Judge. The pundit spoke of Mr. Judge in terms of respect, who, he said, had learned all that he knew from India. He could not conceive of Western occultism, nor believe that it might be possible to gain wisdom without a thorough knowledge of Sanskrit! And in thus referring to the narrow-mindedness of the majority of the Brahmans, I have purposely refrained from touching upon the continuance by many of them of certain rites and ceremonies that can only be called degrading. It is far from my intention to attack even the most bigotted among them, and the only object in calling attention to their failings is to show the difficulties to be overcome and the great need of helping this country, which once was great but is now fallen as low as a nation can fall, and yet live.
The word Theosophy has temporarily fallen into disrepute in India on account of the misguided course that has been followed by certain prominent members of the Adyar organization. One of the first things, therefore, that has to be done is to remove the false impressions current concerning its nature and teachings. That is the chief work of the present Crusade in India. By doing this and by practically demonstrating the feeling of sympathy that the Theosophists in America feel for the cause of India, the foundation will be laid for carrying on a magnificent work in the future.
The Crusaders reached Aden on board the Italian Navigation Company's S.S. "Singapore," on October 18th, leaving next day for Bombay. Aden is uninteresting from every point of view, and is unpleasantly notorious as being one of the hottest places in the world. On the 20th a public meeting was held in the first saloon and several passengers appeared to be sincerely interested in the subjects dealt with. The rest of the voyage was uneventful, letter-writing occupying all the
294spare time. Bombay was reached on Sunday the 25th at midday, and Watson's Hotel was regarded as a paradise after the long sea trip from Port Said. Much preliminary work was done of a private nature, and on the evening of the 29th the Crusaders' first public meeting in India was held in the Town Hall. Mrs. Tingley gave an address of immense importance which was afterwards printed and circulated. It appears in full in the present issue of Theosophy. It was exceedingly well received on its delivery. The proceedings were fairly well reported in the Bombay papers, except in so far that one of them, in giving the number present, underestimated the audience in the proportion of one to three. The majority of those present were Parsis. On the following evening a further meeting was held in the Durbar Room of the Town Hall and the deepest possible interest was shown in all that was said relating to the work in America as conducted by Mr. Judge and as now carried on. Next day a Theosophical Society in India was formed, on the lines originally laid down by Madame Blavatsky; at which there was naturally great rejoicing among the Crusaders, who heartily wished that their friends in America and Europe could know of it. The future of India was already beginning to look brighter.
The third and last meeting in Bombay was held on the evening of the 2d November in the Durbar Room. It was well attended and many kind offers of help were made by those present, which should bear good fruit when the time comes, as it will come, to take advantage of them. Profuse apologies were made by many members of the Adyar organization who had attended the meetings, for the untheosophical letter which had appeared in the local press on the first arrival of the Crusade in Bombay. They all considered the phrase "masquerading Theosophists" as inexcusable. The letter deserves to appear in these columns for without it the condition of things in India would remain unintelligible. It was sent to nearly all of the Anglo-Indian papers:
Masquerading Theosophists.
To the Editor of The Times of India.
Sir:—We shall be much obliged if you will kindly publish in your valuable paper the accompanying repudiation of certain persons who are at present masquerading in India under the name of the Theosophical Society.—Yours, etc., Bertram Keightley, Upendra Nath Basu, Joint General Secretaries.
The Theosophical Society which was founded in New York in the year 1875 by Madame Blavatsky and Colonel H. S. Olcott, and has since spread over most parts of the world, has no connection with the Society formed last year at Boston, U. S. A., by the late Mr. W. Q. Judge and his followers, and disclaims all responsibility for the "Crusade" now being carried on in this country by some members of the latter.—H. S. Olcott, President-Founder; A. P. Sinnett, Vice-President; Bertram Keightley, General Secretary, Indian Section; Upendra Nath Basu, Joint General Secretary; G. R. S. Mead, General Secretary, European Section; Annie Besant.
295The following reply was sent to The Times of India and to the Bombay Gazette:
To the Editor of The Times of India.
Sir.—A communication signed by Mrs. Annie Besant and others concerning the American Theosophists having been inserted in your issue of to-day, we ask you kindly to find place for the following in reply thereto:—The statements made in this communication cannot be regarded in any other light than as an attempt to frustrate our work in India and among its people; and as we cannot allow interference with this we are unfortunately and unwillingly compelled to answer it; but whatever we may say we trust will be considered as a necessary explanation and in no way as an attack on any person or persons whatsoever. It is against the motive of the Theosophical movement to make derogatory statements about anyone, a law among most members being "never to listen without protest to any evil thing said of a brother"; and to this law the Society has ever held as an ideal. But we are surprised and pained that anyone who has once held this ideal should so far forget himself (or herself) as to publicly denounce as "masqueraders" those who have never done him harm, simply because they belong to an organization other than his own. And the case is made much worse when these people are foreigners, who have left their homes and families for a labor of love. From the hour that we left our American shores we have not ceased working, day and night, to accomplish the purpose to which we have devoted our lives, the amelioration of mankind by the spread of the ideals of toleration and unselfishness throughout the world. Yet on our arrival in England we were assailed with an attack similar to the communication in your issue of to-day. But the people of that country, knowing the general circumstances, flocked to hear us in consequence, and as a result not only thousands attended our lectures, but the Theosophical Society in England was more than doubled in its membership and branches. In India, however, there has hitherto been no explanation of the real cause of the so-called "split" in the Theosophical Society; but we are now called upon to plainly state the facts.
The working organization of the Theosophical Society, for several years prior to 1895, was found to be unwieldy, and too centralized for healthy growth. The Society had grown too large for a constitution effective enough in earlier days. In America particularly was this felt. In that country, where the members number more than three quarters of the whole Society, there was open objection—though no ill-feeling—to their owning allegiance to a small office in a little village outside Madras. The Americans desired to govern themselves, and that each country should individually manage its own affairs. But their generosity forbade their taking active steps to secure this; they knew that if the money they annually sent to India were withdrawn, the foreign headquarters would suffer, and they preferred for the time to bear with inconvenience rather than act in any way that might damage the movement abroad. But when in 1894 Mrs. Besant, influenced by a Bengali Brahmin, openly began a groundless and puerile attack upon one of our noblest and purest workers, William Q. Judge, a man respected throughout the length and breadth of America—our land of freedom—we decided that we could no longer allow official interference from abroad by persons who could not understand our ideals, and in 1895 we reorganized ourselves as the "Theosophical Society in America," and, what is more, announced to the world a well-known truth, that the real Headquarters of the Society had always been in New York, where the Society was founded in 1895, though nominally removed to India during Madame Blavatsky's stay in this country.
To call us masquerading Theosophists is therefore childish,—we who constitute more than three-fourths of the whole Society, and, if the truth be told, that part which for years paid the greater share of the funds used for the up-keep of the Indian Headquarters.
The entire attack has been made upon us, simply because we in America refused to believe a brother, William Q. Judge, guilty of a purely occult offense unless so proved,
296and would not join Mrs. Besant in some wild and unbalanced notions she entertained concerning Mr. Judge's method of communicating with his teachers. And, surely, we in America ought to know more of our countryman, his work, and his worth than those who have scarcely met him or perhaps have only known his name. We feel sure that when these facts are understood we shall have no difficulty in bringing fair-minded residents of India to a proper appreciation of our position.
And here it is our duty to refute also a statement made by Mrs. Besant in a public lecture delivered in Bombay some weeks ago, just seen by us. In the report of her lecture it is stated that she attacked our leader, Mrs. Katherine A. Tingley, for having stated that she was a re-incarnation of Madame Blavatsky! As Madame Blavatsky died in 1891, and as Mrs. Tingley is a woman in the prime of life, the pettiness of Mrs. Besant's remark is apparent. It is only necessary to quote the following letter which has been despatched to Mrs. Besant:—
Esplanade Hotel, Bombay, October 26, 1896.
Mrs. Annie Besant,
- Benares.
Dear Madam: I have been requested by Mrs. Katherine A. Tingley to call your attention to the fact that in the Times of India of the 2d October you are reported to have referred to her in the following terms:
"An American lady, Mrs. Tingley, has been claiming to be the re-incarnation of Madame Blavatsky."
Such a public reference as this cannot be allowed to pass without the equally public refutation it deserves.
The case is greatly aggravated by the fact that owing to your close intimacy with Mr. Alexander Fullerton of New York, Mrs. Tingley is convinced that you must already have known she has never claimed to be a re-incarnation of Mme. H. P. Blavatsky—a claim that in her opinion would be ridiculous in the extreme—but has in fact frequently expressed her conviction that the soul of that great worker has not re-incarnated, either in the West or in the East.
Mrs. Tingley informed Mr. Fullerton of this, as she has informed everyone, whenever the opportunity has occurred.
As Mrs. Tingley is well aware that you cannot produce a single document of any sort to sustain your assertion, she expects that after her emphatic protest and denial you will cease to give currency to this slander.—Yours, etc.,
- Claude Falls Wright,
- Secretary to Mrs. K. A. Tingley.
Mrs. Tingley herself refuses to take any public notice of these attacks so persistently made against her, being far too busy with correspondence and interviews. Moreover, she feels that Mrs. Besant is momentarily blinded, and therefore she does not desire to say anything which may hurt her. But we feel it right to say that, though not a re-incarnation of Mme. Blavatsky, which, of course, is folly, we nevertheless believe that Mrs. Tingley is the fitted and true leader of the entire Theosophical movement, as Madame Blavatsky was in her day and Mr. Judge in his. A lady of means, she has for years been working quietly and unostentatiously in New York among the poor; starting missions and homes for the needy; and when, on the death of Mr. Judge, we waited on her with the papers left by him announcing her successorship, she only stepped out from retirement, and the philosophic life she led, to bear the brunt of all the attacks on the movement, because she felt called to do so. Madame Blavatsky asked Mr. Judge when they first met why he had not brought with him "the chela," whom he afterwards identified with Mrs. Tingley. She would have had her place in the movement long before had circumstances been such as to permit of it. Who and what she really is and her great work, all will learn in the coming years.
297We regret, in reply to the numerous requests we have had from almost every city of importance in India, that we cannot outstay our pre-arranged trip in the country, for we have to return to California in time for Mrs. Tingley to lay the foundation-stone of the "School for the Revival of the Lost Mysteries of Antiquity" before our great American Convention in April; but next year Mrs. Tingley hopes to return with a large number of students, and then our work will be carried on to better advantage. Finally, we attack neither persons, religions nor sects. We do not believe in religious interference of any kind. We work to create tolerance in the world among thinkers of every denomination, and this we hope to bring about by showing that all men have essentially the same ideals. We do not wish to injure Mrs. Besant or her followers in any way. We merely ask that they should recognize that the world, small as it is, is quite wide enough for all to work in.—Yours, etc.
- E. T. Hargrove, President, T. S. in A.
- Claude Falls Wright, President, New York T. S.
- H. T. Patterson, President, Brooklyn T. S.
- F. M. Pierce, Representative of School for the Revival of the Lost Mysteries of Antiquity.
- Leoline Wright, Lecturer, T. S. in A.
- W. Williams.
- Alice L. Cleather.
Every possible step had been taken, publicly and privately, to hinder the work of the Crusade, and Mrs. Annie Besant in a lecture in Bombay shortly before our arrival, had stated that Mrs. Tingley had "claimed to be the reincarnation of Madame Blavatsky," a pure fabrication. But such efforts were foredoomed to failure. They had in the first place evidently been due to fear, and flew back like boomerangs of destruction. The law of reaction is subtle in its operation and it is certain that sooner or later an attempt to do evil to an honest person must redound to the advantage of that person. That at least has been the experience in this case, for no better thing could have happened to the Crusade than the appearance of that unfortunate letter.
Leaving Bombay on the 3d, with many pleasant recollections of the work done and of the friendships made, the party reached Jeypore at 5 a. m. on the 5th.
Brothers H. T. Patterson and W. Williams had arrived the day before in order to make the necessary arrangements. Jeypore is an independent state in Rajputana. The city of Jeypore is very ancient. It is situated in a hilly district. On a hill on the outskirts of the town there is a large fort, garrisoned by Munas, aboriginal hill-men. No one is allowed to enter it on any pretext. Provisions are taken in once in two years only. The main streets of the city are crowded with Rajputs, and with Mohammedans, Jains and the four castes of Hindus. The Rajputs are a magnificent race, even in appearance; tall, powerful, dignified. The Maharajah is one of them, and is said to be most good to his people, generous, the supporter of several hospitals, schools, museums and similar institutions. He has already given the Crusaders the use of his elephants
298in case they wish to visit the neighbouring city of Amber. It would seem that some good work may be done, and possibly some useful experiences gained, in this old city of the Rajputs. But this remains to be told in the next "Screen of Time."
If it were needed it would be easy to draw one lesson at any rate from the experience of the Crusade, and that is the tremendous importance of preserving a free and open mind. In every country visited, where the people have been hide-bound by traditions and orthodoxies, Theosophy has had to engage in an up-hill fight. How can a man ever see the truth if he refers all that he hears to some book or accepted standard of respectability. Truth is one and is eternal, never changing; but the mind of man is the most movable thing in nature, only capable of catching stray glimpses of truth, which in combination may amount to much, though never to all. Methods must change, and ideas, beliefs, systems, as well as ability to use and power to receive the light. It were well if all men, while never anxious to change, could stand ready to alter their ideas and plans at any moment. Then they would see truth as it passed their way, and truth would not have to come and knock at the doors of their minds throughout the ages, to be refused admittance for lack of some special sign or button to show its pedigree. To seek truth fearlessly, without thought of either past or future; to shut one's mind to no channel, no matter in what repute that channel may be held by others: that is the first step in the attainment of divine wisdom. Until it is taken man remains little better than a fool. We might well imitate children in the matter, for children have no fear of truth, seeking it on all sides and loving what they find. Little children are very near to nature, but there is no reason why men and women should not be as near. Nature would quickly free them of time-worn preconceived conceptions and would show them things as they are, not as they ought to be.
E. T. H.
Jeypore, Rajputana, 8th November, 1896.
322
The Screen of Time.
The stay of the theosophical Crusaders in Jeypore, Rajputana, was in any case necessary as a break on the journey northwards from Bombay, and although no public propaganda was carried on there, a good deal of work was accomplished in a quiet way, and the foundation laid for much more work in the future. Delhi, once the Mohammedan capital of India, was the next stopping point. Some members of the party travelled there ahead of the others in order to make preliminary preparations for a meeting, which they did most successfully, enabling the others to speak at a public gathering in the Town Hall on the evening of their arrival, Monday, November 9th. A prominent lady member of the Adyar Society unexpectedly lectured in the same hall on the evenings of the 10th and 11th, so on the 12th the Crusaders held a farewell meeting, when the large hall was packed by an enthusiastic audience. Mr. H. T. Patterson, the chairman, adjourned the meeting, but the audience refused to separate. They sat motionless, profoundly impressed. Suddenly the Nawab Ahmed Said Khan, a Mohammedan prince, stepped up on to the platform, followed by the larger part of those present, and, amid much enthusiasm, presented Mrs. K. A. Tingley with a floral and a lace garland on behalf of the people of Delhi, as a token of their appreciation of her work and of their respect for her noble aims.
A society was formed there next day, with a very large membership, and that it is cosmopolitan in character is vouched for by the fact that its president is a Hindu, its Vice-President is a Mohammedan, its Treasurer a Jain, its Secretary a Rajput Kshattriya, and that on its Execu-323tive Committee are Brahmin Pundits with Hindus of other castes as well as Mohammedans. Only those who know India can truly appreciate the significance of this. It shows that the true spirit of brotherhood had touched the hearts of those people. They said so themselves and proved it by their acts. It is a very strong society.
It is interesting to note that just outside Delhi are the remains of one of the most ancient cities of India, called Indrapat or Purana Kila, rebuilt 2000 b.c. by Yudhisthira, first king of the Pandu dynasty of Indraprastha. Delhi itself is glorious with the buildings of Shah Jahan, the Mughal emperor, constructor of the marvelous Taj Mahal at Agra.
A special and urgent invitation had been received from Ludhiana, in the Punjaub, for the Crusaders to visit that city. But there was pressing work to be done elsewhere and all could not go. So Mr. C. F. Wright and Mr. H. T. Patterson journeyed northwards, rejoining the rest of the party at Lucknow, after forming a strong Society and holding a well-attended public meeting in Ludhiana. They received the warmest possible support from a very old member of the Society resident there, a friend of Madame Blavatsky's, who became the President of the new organization. The rest of the party left Delhi on the 14th. What might be described as an incessant meeting had been held from the memorable evening of the 12th until the moment of their departure for Lucknow. Business meetings of the new society, personal interviews with members and inquiries without end, obliged the Crusaders to take their meals in relief parties, one at a time!
The condition of things was different in Lucknow, reached on the 15th by way of Cawnpore. A great prejudice against Theosophy existed in the minds of its leading citizens on account of the disastrous way in which the subject had been presented there previously. It had been made to appear as yet another sect of Hinduism: so much time had to be devoted to removing this and other false impressions. A large hall was kindly loaned for a public meeting on the 18th. There was a representative assembly of the principal thinkers in the town, and a number of young men from the local colleges sat through the addresses in what was evidently full sympathy with all that was said. These young collegians took a leading part in the establishing of an Indo-American T. S. in Lucknow, which was done at the conclusion of a second public meeting held on the 19th, at the request of the first evening's audience. Then followed a business meeting on the morning of the 20th, immediately after which the party started for Benares, arriving there next day. Here also a strong prejudice was to be met with on account of the extreme and absurd views put forward as theosophical by some members of the Adyar Society who make Benares their headquarters. But this prejudice was overcome in the end, for a strong and large Society was 324formed there, after two meetings in the Town Hall, which were very well attended considering the bad weather. Another public meeting on the 23d, in the hotel, after which a business meeting was held, officers elected, and the name decided upon—The Indo-American T. S.—one of the most active and enterprising in India to-day.
On the 25th those members of the party who had not gone on to Calcutta ahead, started on their way there. They held a meeting on the night of their arrival, largely attended by Europeans; another on Sunday the 29th, conducted by those members of the party who did not go with Mrs. Tingley to Darjeeling—a small town not far from Kinchinjunga, one of the Himalayan peaks. A society was formed in Calcutta with quite a number in it who had been formerly members of the Adyar society but who had left it owing to their intense discontent with the methods and practices of its leaders.
On the afternoon of the 30th the Crusaders left Calcutta on board the British India S. S. "Golconda" for Madras, where they arrived after a moderately comfortable voyage on December 6th. Rain was coming down in torrents. It was found that cholera had broken out at Tuticorin, making it impossible to go by train from India to Ceylon without a quarantine of many days. No one was sorry, therefore, to pack up and return to the good ship "Golconda" without spending a wet night, in wet beds, on wet floors; wettest of all was the atmosphere itself. Getting back to the ship in a small boat, in the dark, with blinding rain, blowing and the sea fairly dancing, was an experience long to be remembered. The rest of the voyage to Colombo was a very hot one. Mrs. Tingley became seriously ill, so much so that it seemed at one time as though it would be impossible for her to live till the end of the voyage. But the turn came at the right time and the whole party landed safely at the Colombo Customs house on Wednesday, 9th December.
On reaching Colombo news was received of a plot against the theosophical movement which has been industriously hatching in New York for some time past. It may have come to an age of maturity by the time this letter appears in America. The object as usual is to destroy Theosophy by destroying the leading Theosophist. There must always be such targets for the edification of those who either do not understand Theosophy or who understand enough of it to fear it. Madame H. P. Blavatsky stood the brunt of the onslaught for many years; W. Q. Judge was the next target, and now it is Mrs. Katherine A. Tingley. Pity the leader of the Theosophical movement! But let that pity take the practical form of a bold defence in case of need, not that of sentimental and silent regret. The duty of earnest students is so very simple under such circumstances: to listen to no evil said of a fellow Theosophist without protest. As much 325harm is done in the world by evil listening as by evil speaking. That is but another way of saying that "inaction in a deed of mercy becomes an action in a deadly sin." Gossips and slanderers will only flourish so long as there are people to listen to them. This fact is frequently lost sight of, though it has been stated so often that one hesitates about committing it to type. One of the common-places of Occultism!
It may be well to inform those of our readers who are not members of the Society that neither Madame Blavatsky nor Mr. Judge were paid for their services to the movement; they never received one cent of salary. The same applies equally to Mrs. Tingley, who in fact made heavy sacrifices in accepting her present position. No officer receives any salary or any sort of payment from the Society, nor does the Outer Head of the Esoteric School receive salary or payment for services rendered to it.
Furthermore, in the case of Mrs. Tingley, and in answer to contrary suggestions, it should be known that she did not claim or seek recognition after Mr. Judge's death, but that she was sought out by several prominent members and asked to accept the position she now occupies; which she did at great personal sacrifice, as said.
The questions are sometimes asked: Why should not those who lead the movement be beyond suspicion? Why should the Society have to suffer on their account? In the first place it should be evident that the leaders of such a movement as this must be people of considerable force. People of force, such as Madame Blavatsky, W. Q. Judge and Mrs. Tingley, can do far more for the work than people without it. But while they make many staunch friends it stands to reason that they must make many bitter enemies. Those who work with the same object they work for are helped and encouraged in their efforts; but others who strive for different ends, often narrow and selfish, have to step out of their way or get trodden upon. This is a crude but practical way of explaining the undoubted fact that the leaders of this movement are certain to have secret as well as public opponents.
It would also be strange if the Theosophical leaders did not have a certain large generosity in their make-up, and history shows, particularly in the case of Madame Blavatsky, that their desire to help and protect others has been so strong that it has often got the better of their sense of self-preservation. The result has been injury to themselves in the eyes of people who could not appreciate either generosity or unselfishness. Madame Blavatsky in her youth and before founding the Theosophical Society and occupying a representative position as a Theosophist, was reckless of the world's opinion, looking to her own conscience for truth and guidance, indifferent to the artificial conscience erected by custom and prejudice. Naturally the world misjudged her, but it was these very qualities which made her so truly magnificent, so invaluable to 326the cause she served. A case was reported in the Welsh papers some time ago of two ladies in a row-boat refusing to save a drowning man because he was not dressed according to their fancy. Would they make great Theosophists?
It is not to be wondered at that the lives of our leaders have not run smoothly; that they have had many enemies; that their noblest actions have been misjudged by persons whom the world regards as virtuous. And the Society does not suffer from these criticisms and attacks. They serve to bring Theosophy to the notice of the public. Some of the best workers to-day heard of Theosophy through the publication of slanders against Madame Blavatsky and Mr. Judge. The Society would be practically unknown at the present time if it had not been for the opposition it has met with in the past. Not that such opposition and criticism is to be encouraged, for friendly support is what is wanted, and that is being offered by people of every class in all parts of the world. But a finer point enters into this question of damage to the movement: would it be right to accept an unlimited amount of hard work from some prominent member and to refuse to give support and encouragement in return? That would be ungrateful and ingratitude is a deadly sin. A man would not treat even his horse in that fashion, for if it had labored for him and had shown by honest work that it was strong and capable, he would not dispose of it because some officious critic merely questioned its appearance. Gratitude for work accomplished should far outweigh every criticism from outside sources.
Such thoughts naturally arise on hearing that attacks on the old familiar lines are being prepared. Well, it will not be the first time, nor by any means the last for such efforts to be made to upset the movement. One can afford to continue one's way in peace.
Certainly Ceylon is conducive to peace. Too much so, if anything, for the intense damp heat is enervating in the extreme. The Singalese are a delightful people, though not infrequently lacking in that useful quality, best described as American "push." They are mild, gentle and obliging. Buddhists in religion, they are truly devout and preserve with the most jealous care the traditions of their faith. But many of them carry it a little too far in having preserved the pre-Buddhistic demonolatry, which is more a system of exorcism than anything else. They exorcise for bad weather, sickness, anything and everything. In this they show their similarity to many of the northern Buddhists, who have preserved much of the more ancient Bhon religion in their Buddhism. But this only applies to the ignorant people in both cases, for those who understand the doctrines of Buddha are far above any such superstition; they are philosophers and metaphysicians as well as religionist. 327A public meeting was held on the afternoon of the 12th, attended by from five to six hundred people, according to reports received. Not all the members of the party could be present as there was so much work to be done in the way of correspondence and so forth before to-day's start for Australia. The audience was most deeply interested in the lectures, for at the conclusion of the meeting a Society was formed without further delay, and the members assembled this morning to elect their officers and arrange details of the work to be done. The next "Screen of Time" cannot record much activity, as it will have to be mailed as soon as the P. & O. "Oceana" touches at Albany. This will give a needed opportunity to review the work in India, past and present, and to consider the future of the work in that country.
E. T. H.
Colombo, December 13th, 1896.
353
The Screen of Time.
The Theosophical Crusaders left Colombo for Australia on the 14th of December on board the P. & O. mail steamer Oceana.
The heat in Ceylon had been excessive, which the heavy rains had by no means lessened, so the cool winds met with after the first two or three days out were most welcome. Up to the time of writing the voyage has been uneventful. The chief subject of conversation among the passengers has been Theosophy, as the result of a well-attended meeting held in the first-class saloon on the evening of the 21st. Several passengers formally requested lectures on Reincarnation and Karma, the captain's permission was gladly given, and the meeting was held accordingly. Every one pronounced it an immense success. Good questions were put, all in a friendly spirit.
To-morrow, Thursday, the 24th, the Oceana should reach Albany, and Adelaide on the following Sunday. The Crusaders will then visit Melbourne and Sydney, cross the sea once more to Auckland, and from there will probably start on their homeward journey to San Francisco by way of Samoa and Honolulu. China and Japan will in that case be reserved for future Crusades. Now there is not sufficient time in which to do the work in those countries justice, for the Convention of the Theosophical 354Society in America draws near, and before that takes place Mrs. Tingley has to lay the foundation stone of the School for the Revival of the Lost Mysteries of Antiquity. The party will thus reach California by the second week in February.
Passing from the activities of the future to the work already accomplished, the mind naturally reverts to India as the land last visited and as the scene of so many Theosophical campaigns in the past. Confining one's self to this century and to the work of the Theosophical Society, Madame H. P. Blavatsky undoubtedly occupies the most prominent position as a laborer in that field. She aroused the slumbering interest of the Indians in their ancient religions, philosophies and sciences, while working primarily for the cause of brotherhood. She did her utmost to broaden the minds of those natives of India who were inclined to narrowness on religious questions, and in order to show the universality of truth and the immense antiquity of "western"[3] religious systems, she wrote a series of learned articles in her magazine on prehistoric America under the title "A Land of Mystery."[4] So long as she resided in India and supervised the work, all went well; but as soon as she left the country, activity subsided and the movement slowly degenerated. In later years and after her death, interest in Theosophy was temporarily revived among the Hindu population, but on an unpractical and unhealthy basis. This sudden revival was swiftly followed by a reaction which brought Theosophy in India lower than it had ever been before, in fact to the point of extinction. For the revival had been caused by the erroneous identification of Theosophy with one of many Hindu sects; and by the propaganda of an astonishing egotism which momentarily impressed some people, until they paused to think. Theosophy, the wisdom of the ages and the doctrine of the heart, was converted under these auspices into a dry system of intellectual gymnastics which chiefly consisted of crowding man and the universe into diverse pill-boxes, carefully labelled, classified, stored. If a certain amount of emotionalism was evoked in the process, it was because some people have a faculty of shedding tears, or of otherwise perorating, over a bone of the extinct moa bird—or anything else on demand. And if in addition unlimited flattery was lavished upon anything and everything, from the fold of a turban to the conception of Mahadev, which would best please the audience of the evening, this again could be accounted for on very commonplace grounds. No wonder that interest in Theosophy languished, and that 355the more enlightened Hindu, who is not a fool in any case, came to the conclusion that he could not get assistance, much less instruction, from a source so transparently shallow, though noisy.
It was clear, even from a distance, that the theosophical movement in India sadly needed to be set once more upon the firm foundation established by Madame Blavatsky, and that another effort would have to be made to erect the superstructure of practical work which she had so longed to see a living reality. So the visit of the Crusade to India, under the leadership of Mrs. Tingley, was an absolute necessity, if the early efforts of Madame Blavatsky for India were not to be wasted. And the way in which Mrs. Tingley grasped the situation on her arrival there was an experience not to be forgotten. I well know how easy it would have been for her to have outdone any teacher known to the Indian people as an exponent of their ancient Gupta Vidya or secret wisdom; how triumphantly she could have passed from city to city as a sage possessing siddhis, spiritual powers, recognized as such by all who believed in the divine possibilities of the human soul. And how different was her work! No reference was made to powers or secret teachings; the very appearance of possessing unusual knowledge was avoided, and the whole force of this wonderful woman's mind was turned to the task of establishing the theosophical movement on a firm basis of practical brotherhood and of practical work for humanity. No attempt was made to proselytize: the Hindus were advised to remain Hindus and turn to their own priests for teaching on religious subjects; the Mohammedans were told the same thing, as were the Christians and the Jains; but all were urged to be tolerant of each other's beliefs and to sink differences of form in a common work undertaken for their country and the whole world. Much was done in this way to heal existing breaches between Mohammedans and Hindus and the small but powerful Christian community.
What wonder that the Crusade met with immense success, or that Mrs. Tingley has left behind her countless friends who stand ready to assist her at any time in whatever she may undertake for India! Because the people of India are not slow to appreciate sterling qualities. They are wonderfully intuitive as a rule; quick to sense weakness or recognize strength; with acute intellects capable of catching the point of an argument more swiftly perhaps than any other race. This is a generalization, just as it might be said generally that many Indians lack enterprise and originality though it should be remembered in their favor that the climate of their country almost prohibits continuous exertion. Now that a union has been established of these great qualities of the Indians and of the peculiar characteristics of the Americans, a force must be generated in time that will overcome everything in its path, theosophically speaking.
At all the meetings of the Crusade in India, both public and private, 356great stress was laid on the fact that its work had no political or religious bearing, and that brotherhood and a practical expression of brotherhood was its only aim. This avoidance of religious topics naturally led to criticism from those who would in any case have criticised. It was said that the teaching of the Crusaders was "materialistic." A feeble criticism, in truth, but worthy of a moment's examination because of its implications. In the first place, what is true spirituality? Is it made up of white clothes, colorless skin, adorations of a far-off "principle"; of expressions of devotion to man, or of appeals to other men to feel the same abstract and impalpable devotion? Dry intellectualism cannot be spiritual: then is it not possible that true spirituality is synonymous with true brotherhood—with all which that involves? Spirituality, to be worth anything, must express itself outwardly; must be made practically useful. It should be manifest in the most material and ordinary acts of life. Beginning on that plane—being firmly established there—it should then be taken up into all the realms of action. But what folly to seek to obtain or to give knowledge and power unless the first "portal"—as the Buddhist scriptures call it—the "key of charity and love immortal," has been passed. With love and compassion the universe is conquerable; without love a man were better dead. Such has been the teaching of every great Theosophist, Eastern as well as Western. But in the East, in the ordinary acceptation of that term, love has been too frequently allowed to remain a dreamy, metaphysical conception, as many Indians readily admit. That is one reason why they so cordially welcomed Mrs. Tingley's large-hearted efforts to inspire their countrymen with an appreciation of true philanthropy and tolerance, for they at least are aware of the futility as well as the danger of all talk of "occultism" until that broad, wise love is alive in the hearts of men which alone brings lasting knowledge, power, self-control, discretion, and finally illumination.
So must the work be carried on in India for many years to come. That it will be successful no one doubts who has seen what a brief effort accomplished. It is a work in which Mr. Judge was profoundly interested. He loved India as few have ever loved that country; but he well knew that in his day the time had not yet come to work there with large effect. He did what he could to keep up the connection between India and America, succeeding admirably in that, as this Crusade has testified. He worked for the future, and the future will show that his efforts have been more than justified already.
E. T. H.
S. S. Oceana, nearing Albany, December 23, 1896.
The work of the Crusade in Australasia was undoubtedly a brilliant success, due in large measure to the devotion and self-sacrifice of the members who prepared the way for its labors.
357On the 24th December the S. S. Oceana reached Albany, W. A. Brother Wilton Hack came on board there, having travelled from beyond Coolgardie—many hundreds of miles away—to do so. He was naturally most welcome and at once became a "Crusader" in his turn.
Adelaide, S. A., was reached on the 27th. That night was spent on shore and the rest of the journey to Melbourne was made by rail. The Oceana encountered a most severe storm on leaving Adelaide, which the Crusaders thus escaped. On the evening of the 31st a public meeting was held in Melbourne which was very well attended considering that the New Year holidays and a serious strike of engineers effectually engrossed the attention of the general public. Further meetings were held in the Menzies Hotel, the last being conducted by H. T. Patterson after the rest of the party had left for Sydney. At this meeting he formed a strong Centre, soon destined to blossom into a duly constituted Branch.
The Crusaders arrived in Sydney on January 5, 1897. They were greeted at the station by the members of the Sydney Branch with the utmost enthusiasm. It seemed as though they were shaking hands with life long friends. A members' meeting on the 6th was followed by a crowded public meeting in the Protestant Hall on the evening of the same day. Long interviews and reports appeared in the local press, in all cases couched in the friendliest terms. A reception was held in the Australia Hotel on 7th, for members and their friends. Then on the 9th another public meeting was held in the Protestant Hall, more crowded than the first. The audience continually showed their appreciation by prolonged applause, particularly after Mrs. K. A. Tingley's inspiring address. Next day there was a large meeting of the Esoteric School, and on the 11th a Brotherhood Supper was given to the poor of Sydney in the Temperance Hall. On Tuesday the 12th the annual Convention of the Theosophical Society in Australasia was held. The most perfect unanimity characterized its proceedings. Mrs. K. A. Tingley was elected Corresponding Secretary for life; C. F. Wright was elected Recording Secretary; E. A. Neresheimer, Vice President; and E. T. Hargrove, President.
On the 13th the Crusaders left Sydney for Auckland on the S. S. Rotomahana. It was with sincere regret that they bade farewell to their many friends and faithful associates in Sydney. It is best to avoid the mention of names in the record of this Crusade, but it is not possible to leave unrecorded the splendid work of T. W. Willans, President of the New South Wales Division of the T. S. in A.; nor the labors of Mrs. E. Minchen, the President of the Sydney Branch, nor of the energetic Secretary, Brother Smith. The movement in Australia is certainly in the best of hands.
On the morning of the 18th, the Crusaders arrived in Auckland. 358Kind friends welcomed them, as in Sydney. A reception that evening was followed by a public meeting on the 19th in the City Hall, which was crowded with an enthusiastic audience. On the evening of the 21st another big public meeting was held in the same hall. All Auckland was talking about Theosophy. The interest was intense.
The 22d was a busy day. A meeting of the Esoteric School in the afternoon; then a Brotherhood Supper; then a private meeting at the hotel, and the necessary arrangements for departure on the 23d for—home. On the 23d the party embarked on board the S. S. Alameda for San Francisco. But mere embarkation did not abolish public meetings, and on the evening of the 26th addresses on Theosophy were delivered to the first saloon passengers at their urgent request.
At Samoa, where the Alameda stopped six hours on the 27th, one of the leading native chiefs came on board and expressed himself as anxious to join the Society. He said that most of his followers would do so as soon as he explained to them the nature of the movement.
A meeting in the steerage on February 3d showed that almost more interest was felt among the passengers there than in the first saloon. This experience was by no means unique of its kind.
At Honolulu, on the 4th, an old comrade and friend was unexpectedly met with in the person of "G. Hijo," who had travelled all the way from New York to greet the Crusaders. It would be difficult to describe the welcome he received. He brought nothing but the best of news from America which direct experience has since then amply verified. Yet another meeting was held in the first saloon of the Alameda on the 9th, and then on the 11th we reached San Francisco, we reached home—or so it seemed, if a wide continent does still divide us from the Headquarters of the movement.
Being in San Francisco, every second counts as it does in few other places in the world. So these concluding remarks must be brief and very hastily penned. Needless to say that our welcome here was cordial; that we were glad to meet once more the workers who have given Theosophy on the West Coast the position it now occupies.
There remains to be said but a few words of special thanks. It is out of the question to name all those who have carried on the movement in America during the absence of the Crusade. Those who have done most would say that it has been the loyalty, the devotion and the energy of the large majority of members which has made their special services possible. One name at least will spring to the minds of all as a pillar of strength and steadfastness. But it is my special province as the editor of this magazine to state that but for the unceasing zeal and stability of J. H. Fussell it would have been most difficult to have continued issuing Theosophy during the past 359eight months. How well he has done his work every reader knows. I am sure that all will join with me in most cordially thanking him for his splendid services to the cause. Words of thanks are poor recompense at any time, but when heart-felt appreciation goes with them as in this case, they may perhaps live as a memento of good work well done.
E. T. Hargrove.
San Francisco, February 13, 1897.
1
The Screen of Time.
The Crusade of American Theosophists around the world will have reached the city of its origin by the time these pages are read. An account of its activities in America will be found in The Mirror of the Movement. The journey of the Crusaders across the continent from San Francisco and the wonderful success of their meetings in the many cities they have visited forms a fitting climax to the work of the past nine months. Mrs. Tingley's bold conception of this gigantic undertaking and still bolder execution of the plan, have met with the reward they merited. That part of us which clings to the outer life and loves the mere sound of a well-known voice and the gaze of familiar eyes will have been tempted to exclaim more than once—"If W. Q. J. could but see it all!" William Quan Judge, the man who made all this possible, the man whose nobility, strong steadfastness, self-sacrifice and devotion, built up Theosophy in America, and to a large extent in Europe, upon a foundation of rock! Death to such an one would bring but dearer vision and a wider field of service, so our wish that he, our friend, could see is not based on wisdom,—though it is a very human wish.
We are nearing the anniversary of his birth, the 13th of April. 2Arrangements have been made to celebrate the day by a special meeting of all the Lotus Circles, when it is hoped that members as well as children will come together to honor his memory and gain inspiration from his life. It would not be well if such a character were to be forgotten. Not many are known to us in this world who stand out as portents of man's future possibilities. And all of us have to become such as he was, each in his own way and on his own line, before we climb still higher. Those who knew him most intimately loved him best, but hundreds who never set eyes upon his eyes gained from him their life's impetus towards a better and more unselfish activity.
Blind hero-worship was never indulged in at his expense,—for he was the first to condemn it; but to recognize and revere all that is purest and loftiest in others is a recognition of the divine in man and all nature. We should not hesitate then to place on record our appreciation of his character and worth. Particularly does this become our duty when his unworthy enemies still fling their homemade mud at the monument of his everlasting deeds. Wife, sisters, friends—these are nothing in their eyes, even less than his admitted virtues, for they, the accusers, have to justify their own iniquity and excuse themselves for his untimely death. So a pamphlet goes out from one, an article from another, a carefully blackening sentence in some newspaper interview from yet a third, "grieving" over the great man's "frauds"—bah! give me a good, honest, open enemy but spare me a little longer a "grieving" self-appointed executioner!
For of course William Q. Judge had enemies, as Madame H. P. Blavatsky had before him and Mrs. K. A. Tingley has to-day—Judas Iscariot has reincarnated many times! Charges were brought against him, foolish, self-destructive, but with a blare of virtuous proclamation and with tears—tears which I among others had to see and suffer, tears which deceived some but not others. Judas undoubtedly wept when he took the pieces of silver; nothing but his sense of duty could have overcome his reluctance. And onlookers no doubt said then as they said a few years ago, "There can be no smoke without a fire; we will side with the accuser because we see the smoke." They forgot that such smoke may come from hell—no matter where situated.
No smoke without a fire, true; but where is the fire in a case of this sort? I take a case from my own experience, though I could take many other instances from the lives of those prominently connected with this work. In a city in America there is a branch of a small society which has no connection with the Theosophical Society 3in America. It is part of the accepted beliefs of the members of this otherwise harmless branch that I left a wife and three children when I joined the Theosophical movement. Please remember that this is not a rumor; it is given out gravely as a fact! Whether the wife and children are starving or not I do not know: I expect they are, and that kindly people have wept over the need of the little ones for bread! I cannot possibly prove that I never was married, that I am not the father of children. Should I then resign the position I hold in the movement? I think not. I can do what Mr. Judge did under similar circumstances: tell these good gossips to go ahead and establish one small fact in support of what they allege, and meanwhile deny in the most sweeping way possible the whole silly story. And then laugh.
Poor Judge: it was not the charges that stung him, they were too untrue to hurt. It was the fact that those who had once most loudly proclaimed themselves his debtors and his friends were among the first to turn against him. He had the heart of a little child and his tenderness was only equalled by his strength. Those who turned against him could not understand the simplicity of the man. They looked for mixed and complicated motives when his motive was invariably single and direct—the good of the work. They suspected him of plans and schemes of which he was utterly innocent, for he never made a plan, teaching and living the principle that "an occultist never makes any mortal plan," but tries to do his whole duty in each moment as it arrives, leaving the results to the universal law. If they had wronged him in any way or had failed in the work, they looked for evidences of his resentment and naturally found them, though he bore no resentment and was ever willing to take others on the strength of their present work without regard to the past. He never cared what people thought of him or of his work so long as they themselves would work for brotherhood. I have heard him accused of ambition, but in both instances it was due to the fact that his life outshone the lives of his accusers, and that he had failed to glorify them at the expense of the movement. His wife has said of him that she never knew him to tell a lie, and those most closely connected with him theosophically agree that he was the most truthful man they ever knew.
If we expect fools to praise him we shall expect more than nature makes possible. Years ago I was walking with one who called himself a fast friend of Mr. Judge's and who wrote to an acquaintance not long afterwards that anyone "daring to attack W. Q. J. would raise a wall of steel between himself and us." Big words, destined to be eaten alive by their author! As we walked and 4chatted this man said to me, "Judge is the only occultist we've got; the only teacher left us since H. P. B. passed away." Then he paused, and at last burst out with long pent-up irritation—"but I wish to heaven he knew more Sanscrit. He does not even know Greek decently and it does look so bad." When this man turned traitor years afterwards I told Mr. Judge of that conversation. His keen sense of humor took in the situation at a glance and he smiled that never-to-be-forgotten smile of his, saying, "It looks so bad, does it? Well, well,—— always did judge by appearances and he's doing it now, sure enough. Mistaken appearances, too."
So from one cause or another a few people became his bitter enemies, though for every enemy he had a thousand friends. These few enemies gathered around themselves a few followers, people who were and are more sinned against than sinning. Their efforts to blacken his fame and destroy his work will last yet a little while longer, for Time is more just than man and removing all traces of his Wanderers will leave his friends in undisturbed possession of his fair memory and life's achievements.
A few days ago the following paragraph in his own handwriting was found among his papers by Mrs. Tingley, who has given it to me for publication.
I think the way for all western Theosophists is through H. P. B. [Mme. H. P. Blavatsky]. I mean that as she is the T. S. incarnate, its mother and guardian, its creator, the Karmic laws would naturally provide that all who drew this life through her belonged to her, and if they denied her, they need not hope to reach * * *: for how can they deny her who gave this doctrine to the western world? They share her Karma to little purpose, if they think they can get round this identification and benefit, and * * * want no better proof that a man does not comprehend their philosophy.
This would, of course, bar him from * * * by natural laws (of growth). I do not mean that in the ordinary business sense she must forward their applications or their merits; I mean that they who do not understand the basic mutual relation, who undervalue her gift and her creation, have not imbibed the teaching and cannot assimilate its benefits.
She must be understood as being what she is to the T. S., or Karma [the law of compensation or of cause and effect] is not understood, or the first laws of occultism. People ought to think of this: we are too much given to supposing that events are chances, or have no connection with ourselves: each event is an effect of the Law.
5 The above was especially intended for members of the Esoteric School, as will be seen, for so long as members of the Theosophical Society work for Brotherhood, their beliefs regarding other matters concern themselves alone. But I cite it here as a profound truth is contained in those few sentences, and furthermore on account of its direct application to Mr. Judge himself. Madame Blavatsky was the "mother and creator" of this movement; W. Q. Judge was its father, and without him it could not have lived. A mother takes care of her child in its infancy, but the time comes sooner or later when she resigns its charge to the father. Still later its care devolves upon some "guardian." And this is what has taken place in the theosophical movement of this century. W. Q. Judge appointed Mrs. Tingley guardian of the movement in a very real sense. Such a position is an unenviable one, for it involves untold suffering and persecution. As I have previously stated, if a specially created angel were imported from heaven for the purpose, the enemies of the movement would still ventilate at his or her expense their blind animosity. Foul tongues would wag and inventive brains would concoct "charges." But such a person will also at all times find loyal and devoted friends, ready to defend and support her in the work, and it is for each one of us to do our duty in this respect so far as we are able to see it. Human nature is dual, in the mass as in the individual, and may unfailingly be relied upon to repeat its peculiarities of yesterday or a thousand years ago in the near or distant future. Give it time and the old story will unfold itself for the edification of all beholders. Our course is simple enough: to do our whole duty, to watch over ourselves, and leave the future to take care of itself. At least that is what W. Q. Judge would have said and that is the way he lived.
* * * * * *
Meanwhile the world is travelling a different course. The air is tense with thoughts of war. Armies are on the march and wave after wave of hatred surges backward and forward between contending nations. At the time of writing a mock peace still prevails. But what a peace! One is tempted to cry, as Madame Blavatsky is said to have done—Let it out. This exclamation of hers was evidently based upon her own teaching, the teaching of common-sense: that an explosion now and again relieves the atmosphere and clears the air. In the case of an individual it is better for him to express his anger and have done with it than to keep the fires of revenge and hate smouldering within him. There will probably come reaction after the explosion, and he will have a chance to review his conduct and to ask himself if after all he had 6not been foolish to feel anger in the first place. For it is the thought that does the damage, with nations and individuals. War is an effect, not a cause; it is the effect of national jealousy, vanity, ambition, all to be summed up in one word—selfishness, which is in its turn due to ignorance. Under certain conditions war may therefore be preferable to peace, if that peace be a mere cloak to a seething mass of corruption, the least effect of which is the maintenance of vast standing armies composed of the flower of a nation's life and manhood. It all points once more to the duty of the Theosophist to call attention to the causes underlying all phenomena and to the urgent necessity of teaching Brotherhood in such a way that people will come to see that selfishness is not only wrong but is self-destructive.
* * * * * *
Brotherhood! again and again we must preach it, proclaim it, prove it as a fact in nature, do our best to live it. We must be lovers of justice, defenders of the persecuted, upholders of all that is best and nearest to the divine. It is this that the people need. They care little for science or for metaphysics; they want to understand their own lives, their own thoughts, and they want encouragement for their own half-recognized aspirations. They already understand many of the laws governing their physical health; they are prepared to obey the laws of mental and spiritual health, once they are taught them. Years ago one of the greatest living Theosophists wrote that what the Western world most needed was a knowledge of the doctrines of Reincarnation and of compensation, for these teachings directly illustrate and explain brotherhood, while they show man's responsibility for his thoughts and actions as nothing else will. These teachings can be given out in a thousand different ways; they never grow stale and unprofitable, seeing that they apply to the smallest of daily duties.
Fancy and more or less imaginary details concerning the human aura, with stereopticon views at fifty cents a show; startling revelations concerning unprovable and utterly immaterial and generally incorrect facts in occultism; details as to the exact present whereabouts of prominent persons long since dead—these things will evoke the curiosity of fools and the pardonable derision of the worldly, but they will not help people to become Theosophists. Charlatanism gone crazy is a poor substitute for brotherly love and common sense and we have to see to it that the good name of Theosophy in America is maintained by our constant and untiring efforts to spread a positive knowledge of its true principles. We do not wish to mention names, though many could be given; among others 7that of a person who travels from town to town, claiming to be able to read the thoughts of others, calling herself a Theosophist and announcing herself as "The White Mahatma of the Himalayas," admission fifty cents to all meetings! Beware of money-making "Theosophists," particularly when they claim to be able to read your thoughts.
* * * * * *
We live at a period in the world's history of intense activity which is manifest in every possible direction. In the works of philosophy, science and art this is particularly noticeable, perhaps nowhere more so than in a comparatively new field of research, the world of the "ether," new only in relation to our modern civilization. New discoveries are being made almost daily in this department of science, all of which give support to many of Madame Blavatsky's new-old teachings. An article in McClure's Magazine for last March should be read by every student. It is entitled "Telegraphing Without Wires," and those who apply what is there said of electricity to thought should learn a good deal as to a condition of the mind which makes of it a "receiver" to vibrations either high or low in the scale of thought. The article is full of valuable illustrations of theosophical truths from a scientific standpoint.
Indianapolis, Indiana, March 20th.
33
The Screen of Time.
The third annual Convention of the Theosophical Society in America will take place on the 25th and 26th of April in New York City. A very large number of representative members will attend the Convention from all sections of the country and many European Theosophists will also be present. At no time in the history of the movement has the Society been more united than at present; its members are one in purpose and are agreed as to the best means to be employed to carry out that purpose. Brotherhood has been our watchword for the past twelve months and the approaching Convention should once more prove to the world that a real nucleus of universal Brotherhood has been formed by the Theosophical Societies, and only needs time in which to grow in order to ultimately embrace all humanity.
The Convention of 1895 was one of reorganization; that of 1896 was one of development. This year the Convention promises to be one of consolidation. An immense number of new members have recently joined our ranks. They need to come into contact with those who are older in the work of the Society than themselves, though possibly not older in work for Brotherhood. The older members can gain much in their turn from these newer and fresher forces. For it must always be a source of strength for those engaged in a common undertaking to meet together. Close friendships 34will be made; plans of work will be talked over; experiences exchanged. Cooperation will be the order of the day and everyone taking part in the proceedings should leave them with a brighter hope and with a broader outlook. It can hardly be necessary to extend a cordial welcome to all visiting delegates and members. Are they not comrades and fellow-workers? That in itself should imply all and more than words of welcome.
* * * * * *
Stagnation means death. No one has ever accused the theosophical movement of being stagnant; everyone admits that it is very much alive. But life involves growth and change, and changes must at all times take place in every branch of this movement when such changes are a natural outcome of preceding effort and seem likely to bring about a greater opportunity for useful work in the future.
With the June issue of this magazine the number of its pages will be doubled. Its circulation must also be doubled if this change is to be justified. There would not be the least difficulty in bringing about this most desirable result if its readers were to realize that to double and quadruple its circulation would do more to spread a knowledge of Theosophy than several lecturing tours throughout the country. For where this magazine goes, there goes our literature, and it is the reading of books that brings people into the movement. Lecturing draws public attention to the subject, but the books do the rest.
It is pretty well known by this time that no one on the staff of Theosophy receives any remuneration for services rendered. Any profits arising from its publication will always go directly towards further propaganda. Whatever its readers do to promote its circulation will therefore be work done for the movement; not for its publishers or editor. At the forthcoming Convention, by means of a printed circular, certain practical suggestions will be made to all who are interested in the matter, which if followed will be of enormous assistance in bringing these pages to the notice of hundreds of thousands of readers in the course of this year.
Certain changes will be introduced in the general character of its make-up. As the movement itself broadens, this magazine must open its pages to the discussion of many subjects which have not so far been sufficiently dealt with in theosophical literature. Many of the world's greatest thinkers will be invited to contribute their thoughts on the social, religious and philosophical problems of the day—men and women who though perhaps not familiar with the theosophical philosophy are nevertheless working on the same broad lines as are all Theosophists. Proper attention will be given to any 35important investigations in the domain of modern science; the experiences of students throughout the world will be recorded in such a way that others may really gain instruction thereby. Special attention will be given to the ancient religions of the world. In short Theosophy will be so conducted as to appeal to every class of actively thinking mind.
This is a good occasion to appeal to all readers, and particularly to those who are not avowedly Theosophists nor members of the Theosophical Societies—to express themselves as either favorably or unfavorably impressed by each month's issue. If they were to write to the editor, saying what particularly pleased them and also what they would like to read which has not been provided, it would assist him materially in his labors. Suggestions and criticisms are urgently needed. It is indeed strange that criticisms are not more frequently volunteered, for the world is usually generous with unsolicited criticism. Perhaps even in this case it is poured forth abundantly enough, but without sufficient care in addressing! However that may be, the request is hereby most earnestly made that every reader who believes it would be possible to add to the interest of our pages or who knows of other means for increasing our circulation, do forthwith write out his (or her) suggestions and mail them to the editor. They will be gratefully received.
* * * * * *
It is not only the theosophical movement that is growing and that changes as it grows. The whole world to-day is in a state of ferment. The orthodoxy of 1897 would have been regarded as rank heresy twenty-five years ago. The new Archbishop of Canterbury, Dr. Temple, head of the Church of England, called forth a storm of bitterest condemnation, even from his more liberal confreres, when he pronounced himself some thirty years since a follower of Darwin on general evolutionary lines, in the then famous Essays and Reviews. He has now been chosen Archbishop although no one has the slightest reason to suppose he has changed his opinions.
All the stoking by all the bigots in modern Christendom has not been sufficient to keep the fires of hell alive. Various theological exits have been discovered by means of which the more enlightened could escape from the fire and brimstone battery with orthodox colors still flying. Here is Dr. Lyman Abbott's latest definition of hell—and as the successor of Dr. Henry Ward Beecher as well as on account of his fearless interpretation of the Bible, his words have weight among many: "My conception, then, of hell is this; first, that sin carries with it terrible punishment in this life and in the life to come. That the punishment is redemptive, the end of it 36being the reformation of the offender, and if neither by punishment in this life nor by punishment in the life to come the offender is redeemed and brought back to God, then the end of that one is death—that is, extinction of being."
This definition is not original, but it is certainly a considerable improvement upon Tertullian and augurs a reaction in favor of the teachings of Jesus and of all other great Theosophists. It would appear that Dr. Abbott might still study the writings of Paul the apostle to advantage, for he would not then be obliged to postulate such an absurdity as an "extinction of being." He would distinguish between the spirit or pneuma and the psuche, or lower personal self. He would furthermore realize that "extinction" is something unknown in nature, for death is not extinction; it is transformation or change. Ice can be transformed into water and water into invisible vapor, but it is impossible to annihilate the substances of which all three things are composed. So even in the case of the animal or lower nature, extinction is impossible; it can either be so purified and raised that it comes to partake of the divine nature, or on the other hand it can be resolved back into its original constituents, only to be again carried forward towards perfection, in the grand sweep of universal progress. But the spirit of man, or higher soul must be essentially immortal because essentially divine, and no sin of the personality can affect its nature. It is the crucified Christos, unsullied by either repentant or unrepentant "thief"—symbolizing two qualities or aspects of the lower nature of man.
Dr. Abbott very nearly reaches the old theosophical conception that we make our own heaven and our own hell, both here and hereafter. He seems to be steadily moving out towards the primitive teachings of Christianity, though it is doubtful if he will find them fully without the light that Theosophy throws upon that and all the other religions of the world. He is at least doing much to broaden and strengthen the Church to which he belongs, for he obliges his congregation to think—and that is the first step toward salvation. In so far as he does that, if for no other reason, he is working with and for the theosophical movement; for Theosophy above all things inspires people to think for themselves, proving that they can find truth within themselves, and that not sin but wisdom and love and joy are man's heritage. Man's greatest crime is lack of faith in man. Let him search the depths of his own nature faithfully and he will find that heritage and will see that he shares it in common with all his fellows.
E. T. H.
New York City.
65
The Screen of Time.
Theosophy, as promised in our last issue, is this month, and will be henceforth, exactly twice its former size and without any increase in its cost. It will now take its place in the front rank of popular monthly magazines, and the dream of its great founder, W. Q. Judge, will have been realized at last. The Screen of Time has recorded few changes more significant than this. It is one of the surest signs that the thought of the world is broadening.
* * * * * * *
The most important event in the history of the Theosophical Society in America during the past month has been the annual Convention of the Society, which took place in New York City on April 25th and 26th. Delegates from all quarters of America, and an unusual number from Europe, took part in the proceedings, which from first to last were characterized by an unsurpassed unanimity and general good feeling. This was particularly evident when the resolution of confidence in Mrs. Katherine A. Tingley as leader of the theosophical movement throughout the world was proposed, the entire audience rising as one man and cheering her to the echo. This resolution will be found in a brief report of the Convention proceedings under "The Mirror of the Movement."
66While Theosophists assembled from all parts of the world to promote the cause of universal Brotherhood, the whole of Europe trembled on the verge of unthinkable disaster; war seemed inevitable, not merely between two of the second-rate powers, but between the combined armies of the continent. As yet, this greater conflict has been averted, but the two minor powers still continue at strife. This has aroused the most wide-spread interest in America, as well as in Europe, and has called forth many appeals in aid of the wounded. One such appeal, made by good and charitable people, laid itself open to most serious objection on account of its undisguised attempt to arouse Christian prejudice against everything Mohammedan. The Turks were referred to as people whose religion teaches them that it is an act pleasing in the sight of God to kill and torture Christians. Mohammedanism teaches no such thing. If there are Turks who act on such principles, opposed as they are to Mohammed's teachings, have there not been so-called Christians who have been equally false to their Saviour's divine injunctions? And in any case, can any good thing come out of an appeal to one of man's lowest characteristics—religious bigotry and intolerance? We think not. Let us help the wounded by all means, but let us help them because they suffer, not because we hate their enemies.
A war of a very different sort is being waged on this continent. It is a campaign in favor of high-class journalism as opposed to degrading sensationalism. It is a newspaper war, and as it occasionally waxes furious, one is not infrequently reminded of the "ungracious" reformer who shows
. . . the steep and thorny way to heaven,
Whilst, like a puff'd and reckless libertine,
Himself the primrose path of dalliance treads
And recks not his own rede.
Who is to blame if a newspaper indulges in "gutter-journalism"? The editor? Not nearly so much as the people who demand what he supplies. If we are to reform the press we must reform the people first, for it is the business of a newspaper editor to so keep in touch with the requirements of the public that he is able to provide whatever will most please his readers. He forms a low estimate of their taste, and if without high principles himself, he naturally caters to their depravity so far as the law will permit. It is the old story; it seems impossible for the nineteenth century reformer to do more than rush headlong at an effect, regardless of its cause. He does not see that if you change the hearts and minds of the 67people, abuses of every description will be possible no longer. He tinkers here and there at the surface of things, and leaves the hidden cancer to work inevitable destruction. Do away with selfishness and its cause—which is ignorance—and misery, immorality, intolerance and all other evils would vanish of their own accord. But then a good many reformers would be in dreadful need of occupation!
* * * * * * *
Immense strides continue to be made in the field of biblical research. Chaldea is at present the chief centre of interest for those who make a specialty of this work, for recent investigations in the neighborhood of Babylon have thrown new and valuable light upon what are called "Christian origins," though they actually concern Judaism more than Christianity proper. It is strange with what timidity these discoveries of cuneiform tablets and other records are regarded by many orthodox people; they admit with evident reluctance that the story of the Garden of Eden must be thrown back several thousand years—and there they stop, afraid of their own boldness. Foolish scepticism on the one hand, thinking it can destroy Christianity by proving the story of Jonah and the whale a fable, common to all the great mythological systems—forgetting that a fable may be a myth and that every mythos has its logos or reason; foolish orthodoxy on the other hand, clinging to dead-letter interpretation and verbal inspiration, and hopelessly ignorant of universal symbolism which alone can protect religious forms from materialistic and destructive criticism. But when the right time arrives and the right man steps forward to do the work, both in Assyriology and Egyptology, there will be a revolution in human thought and both scepticism and crass orthodoxy will be forced to change their attitude for the better in the face of overpowering facts.
During a recent trial which attracted considerable attention the following statement was made by the defendant in the course of cross-examination: "I sat down to say my prayers, because if I knelt down I always went to sleep and stayed there on my knees till morning." There is something delightfully naive about this admission. It implies so much more than appears at first sight, for it represents the condition of what generally passes for religion at the present time. This same individual found it easy enough to keep awake when dealing with worldly affairs, but when it came to praying, to religion, he had to fortify himself against sleep. Re68ligion has lost its reality for most people; its ministers have to galvanize it into artificial activity by every trick and device of the showman and politician. Even then they can hardly keep either it or its devotees awake. And this state of things will continue so long as religion is divorced from philosophy and science, and is chiefly applied to a part of man's nature, which labelled "the soul" and classified as "supernatural," must always be regarded as separate from man himself.
Sleeping, dreaming of its past, and sometimes shouting in its sleep, religion can never occupy its true position in the lives of men until it claims its chief home as being within their own hearts. Pointing to the sky as the seat of Deity, to the unseen future as the time for compensation, to undiscoverable "supernature" as an explanation of all mysteries, it can only dream itself into oblivion. But as it passes out, true religion must take its place, and Theosophy as the synthesis of religion, science and philosophy will be one of the chief factors in bringing this about. Its doctrines are already being preached from thousands of pulpits; its message is reaching millions who may never have heard its name. The name is of little consequence compared to the importance of theosophical ideas, and these, in many strange disguises, are met with everywhere. The world is being reminded of long-forgotten truths and religion may yet be reborn to exercise its true function in human affairs.
Explain the universe as natural and yet essentially divine; turn men's minds to the Christ within and the light within even more than to powers beyond and above them; show that they have made themselves what they are and may make themselves what they would be; make them feel that life is the science they should master, and that life's first lesson is to love their fellow-men—and whether they call themselves Christians, Mohammedans or Jews, Hindus or Buddhists, they cannot help but be good Theosophists.
E. T. H.
179 The improvements made last month in the get-up of Theosophy met with quick, recognition from the reading public and the press. The circulation of the magazine has already more than doubled. Articles of real interest and permanent value will appear in each issue. The series of "Notes on the Crusade," by Mrs. K. A. Tingley, the leader of the Theosophical movement throughout the world, who steered the recent Crusade round the globe through many difficulties to a safe haven, have a rare fascination and should attract thousands of new readers. So, while the present shows an unqualified success, the future of Theosophy promises to be a veritable triumph.
* * * * * * *
One of the strangest manias of unthinking man is his desire to kill his fellows upon what he considers adequate provocation. The folly of inflicting capital punishment legally was admirably demonstrated in our last issue by Dr. Rexford. But if there be a worse form of murder than the legal destruction of life, it is to be found in the lynching of people already condemned by the law. Cases of lynching are appallingly frequent in some parts of America. Only one thing can stop this, and that is the united voice of the community—never to be raised, however, until people in general realize that their desire to wreak vengeance upon the offender springs from the same ferocious brutality that instigates the crimes for which the penalty of death is most often enforced. Every man has something of the "lion and the ape" in his composition, as Ruskin said, and the recital of some outrage tends to evoke the ape-qualities in him by reaction. Blood cries aloud for blood, and if this cry be heeded another crime soon darkens the State's record. Punishment, in any case, should be inflicted as a duty, not in a spirit of revenge. Its object should be remedial and should be carefully suited to the character of the crime committed. In short, our criminals should not be treated like brutes to be kicked, but like brothers to be helped, and this would be perfectly compatible with the utmost severity whenever that attitude might be deemed necessary. In no case can mob-law promote the cause of justice, for a mob is notori180ously governed by its transient passions and emotions, and once these are let loose in the cause of destruction they will very soon turn into other channels, in time imperilling the existence of nations.
* * * * * * *
Considerations like the above give rise to questions concerning fundamental principles of right government, and in a Republican government such as prevails in America, help to remind us that each citizen shares to some extent the responsibility for every miscarriage of justice. Republicanism differs from autocracy inasmuch as it supposes that all voters are qualified to assist in governing their country. Such a system must fail if individuals consider their own interests first, then the interests of their city or State, and, lastly, the interests of their country as a whole. Self-sacrifice and self-control are necessary, even in politics, if people would see their country wisely governed; and at some future date, when man's vision broadens and he comes to see that the interests of humanity as a whole are inseparable, self-sacrifice on the part of nations will be looked upon as neither Quixotic nor absurd, but as right and proper and perfectly consistent with the main object of all government—the greatest good to the greatest number, with due regard to the welfare of the few.
* * * * * * *
Man is responsible for the right performance of his worldly duties, whether they be to his family, to his business associates, to the land of his birth or adoption. It was not by chance that he was born into any given environment; it was due to causes originated by himself in the past, and he should see to it that, on dying, he leaves behind him no unsettled debts, for he can at best postpone their payment—at compound interest.
"No such thing as chance": it is a statement so evidently true that superficial reasoners are apt to conclude they have no free-will; that they can only be what they are, and become what they are doomed to become. They perhaps appreciate the truth of the theosophical teaching that man is the result of his own past thoughts and acts, having made himself what he is, and daily and hourly making himself what he will be. And they ask, wherein is man free? He is free in the use he makes of the present moment; for he may use a disaster and by his inner attitude in its midst may convert it into at least a moral victory. Whatever limitations may encompass a man they are absolutely his own creations. Within these he is free—just as a bird in a cage can fly freely within the limits of the cage, though unable to pass its bars. But man has made his own cage; 181he is responsible for its existence and responsible for all he does or fails to do within his confines.
It would seem as though the apparatus for telegraphing without wires had been finally perfected by Nikola Tesla, the famous electrician. He claims to have succeeded in utilizing the "electric fluids of the earth" for this purpose, and to have constructed an instrument for registering the disturbances he produces in these "fluids." This would practically revolutionize the whole of our modern civilization. Possession of an instrument would enable ships at sea to communicate with land from any distance, while the theatrical explorer of "darkest Africa" could rejoice in daily columns of his own reports, issued simultaneously on four continents. But if his instrument were accidentally destroyed! And here is the weak spot in all these inventions: they force man to depend more and more upon mechanical contrivances which in no way assist him to develop his own latent powers. It does not occur to the modern scientist, dealing as he does almost exclusively with phenomena, to try to find in his own brain a receiver and transmitter, which would never leave him so long as his body endures. Physiology admits that it cannot account for the existence of certain atrophied centres in the brain and for various cavities in the bony structure of the skull—the frontal sinus for instance. Such centres will remain atrophied until used, and their use will never be determined until scientists, taking it for granted that "man is the mirror of the universe," deliberately search for agencies within themselves by means of which they can produce the same results as they can now attain by external means only. Man's body is the most marvelous instrument known to us. It would be well for him if he used it a little more intelligently. Sooner or later he has got to become a wise cooperator with nature. The first step in this direction will be the conscious performance of acts which he now does without understanding or even thought. "Man, know thyself!"
E. T. H.
241 The most important feature of the month's record has been the active manifestation of the International Brotherhood League, founded by Mrs. K. A. Tingley, leader of the world-wide theosophical movement. It began its work with the opening of the Lotus Home, of which a report will be found in "The Mirror of the Movement." This is more particularly part of the work for children, but the League itself has a much wider aim, being intended not only "to educate children of all nations on the broadest lines of Universal Brotherhood, and to prepare destitute and homeless children to become workers for humanity"; but also "to ameliorate the condition of unfortunate women and assist them to a higher life; to assist those who are or have been in prisons to establish themselves in honorable positions in life; to help workingmen to realize the nobility of their calling, and their true position in life; to bring about a better understanding between so-called savage and civilized races by promoting a closer and more sympathetic relationship between them; to relieve human suffering resulting from flood, famine, war, and other calamities; and generally, to extend aid, help, and comfort to suffering humanity throughout the world." A particular effort is also to be made to obtain the abolition of capital punishment.
It is a magnificent enterprise and will doubtless be made as great a success by Mrs. Tingley as she made of the Crusade around the globe not long ago. The League will not be finally organized until toward the end of the year, as the Lotus Home for children is a special undertaking; but whenever its other activities commence it will undoubtedly find glad cooperators in the Theosophists of Europe, India and Australasia, as well as of America. Mrs. Tingley speaks of organizing before long, some practical means of raising funds for the Theosophical Society in America and for the International Brotherhood League, jointly.
In addition to these far-reaching undertakings, much quiet work is being done by Mrs. Tingley in connection with the School for the Revival of the Lost Mysteries of Antiquity at Point Loma, Calif. The school has some near surprises in store for us, by which the in242terest of the general public should be aroused to a degree exceeding the expectations of the most sanguine. Point Loma is a strange place, with a wonderful future; perhaps with a wonderful past.
So this great movement continues to cover the world with its wings, at once overshadowing it and leading it in many of its noblest purposes. No class as a rule appreciates the importance and influence of Theosophy better than the newspaper editor and representative. He looks back to the small but pregnant beginning of things made by Madame H. P. Blavatsky in New York City; he probably had some personal experience of William Q. Judge's heroic and highly successful efforts to consolidate and perfect Madame Blavatsky's achievements; he now witnesses Mrs. Tingley's brilliant successes, and not only in America, for the cable brought him news of similar successes on three other continents. And as the newspaper man has learned to respect success, wherever he may meet with it, he now treats the subject of Theosophy with seriousness and dignity, honoring its good deeds without prejudice. Theosophy triumphs and Theosophists rejoice.
* * * * * * *
Outside the ranks of any theosophical organization an immense amount of purely theosophical work is being done, as "The Literary World" and "The World of Science" constantly testify. Students of what is sometimes called the "hidden side of nature" cannot fail to find an endless record of facts and theories in current literature, the careful perusal of which would occupy their entire time. One of the latest investigators in this realm has unbosomed himself to a representative of the Chicago Times-Herald, summarizing his researches by saying that "the science of creation is simply the science of vibration." Claiming to base his philosophy upon the physical sciences, he has nevertheless arrived at some exceedingly metaphysical conclusions. He admits that his is "the old philosophy of the Buddhists" and that it was the "theory of Pythagoras." According to his view of things "all material manifestations are embodied sounds." He shows the intimate relationship which exists between sound, heat, color and light. He traces the origin of life and matter from the atom of revolving ether in its primal state to cosmos, then to nebula, to the sun, to the world, to man and to his very immortality"—though in this last respect he is evidently misinterpreted, for he is careful to explain further on that in his opinion "there is no death, but only a transition into higher states and conditions": and that "the spiritual force or energy is preexistent: that it was an entity before it was environed by the body, and hence will exist as such, with the added impress 243of experience, after the spirit is excarnate." He deals largely with the question of the human aura and with the earth's auric sphere—at least more intelligently than some exponents of the subject. Speaking of sex he stated his conviction that the "feminine principle is a centripetal condition, while that of the masculine is centrifugal"—a deeply significant conclusion and one that should be applied to the psycho-physiological processes generally. The existence of "seven spheres" of man and of the earth is also taught. There is a suspicion of The Secret Doctrine pervading the statement of his theories, but even if indebted to that book, it may be said on his behalf that he makes better use of it than most of those who borrow but do not acknowledge their indebtedness.
* * * * * * *
This is a season of many changes. In international affairs we all know of the great unrest which prevails. In the politics of this and, in fact, of most countries, men are abandoning their old platforms—considered "sound" till now—and are groping for some new scheme of national life which at least promises improvement. Dissatisfied with the past, uncertain as to the future, they are still in the transition stage, afraid to advance, unable to retreat, finding it difficult to stand still. It is at such times as these that the oratorical reformer, promising much and performing not at all, except in words, finds his great opportunity to gather around himself a multitude of people who find rest and satisfaction in his certainty, so utterly foreign to themselves. They reflect convictions as muddy water may reflect a rush-light, and being very shallow, evaporate about as quickly as the rush-light burns away. Even those whose thought is clear and deep on matters of importance to themselves are sometimes the quickest to succumb before the speciousness of men who are bubbling with one-sided arguments, unauthenticated "facts" and attractive illustrations; for few have time to devote to profound consideration of political and social questions, and, simply aware that the prevailing order of things does not please them, jump at any proffered solution of problems which in no case have they clearly stated to themselves. Once a problem is clearly and correctly stated, it is practically solved. And in this case the statement of the problem will involve consideration of the causes of human misery, which undeniably arise and reside in the minds of rich and poor alike—selfishness, and its cause, which is ignorance. Remove the ignorance and you remove the selfishness; remove that, and you remove the sorrow.
At no other time is it so necessary to move slowly as during a period of transition. Hasty conclusions are fatal. That is why 244the wise man waits till he is certain and when in doubt, stands still. Even though standing still, he can and should still cling to eternal principles, and hence the doubting politician can profitably pass his months or years of uncertainty in proclaiming universal brotherhood to be a law of nature, and in demonstrating that without a recognition of that law as its basis, legislation must prove abortive.
E. T. H.
300 As seen from the deck of an ocean steamship, the view presented differs but little from that to be seen from any other point of vantage. Life is eternally the same. Incidents and persons vary somewhat in appearance, but behind all persons is the same great Soul and behind all incidents lies concealed the same great lesson. Yet life on board-ship is a curious epitome of the life of the world as a whole: there are the workers and the drones, and the drones are not the happier as a rule, particularly if the weather chances to be rough! People generally relax at sea, and to some extent throw aside their business and social cares; but they remain the same men and women. They play cards, and you can almost tell a man's normal occupation by the way in which he holds the playthings in his hands, furtively hiding them from the possible observation of his neighbors, with many a defensive side-glance, not to mention an occasional attempt to take advantage of the carelessness of others. He is a business man, a financier, but not an habitual card-player, for the latter, though far more careful in fact, preserves an appearance of large indifference which shows the expert as it deceives the unwary. The game consists in trying to get the better of all the other players: not unlike the ordinary game of life! Then they resort to music, and this gives free scope for extravagant little jealousies, criticisms, heart-burnings, just as in the big world around us whenever people meet together for either work or pleasure. It has been said that a funeral gives wider opportunity for displaying these peculiarities than any other form of human entertainment, but a concert at sea easily comes second.
One hardly expects to find evidence of spirituality in any but one in ten thousand faces. To expect more would involve grievous disappointment. Not that all faces are not now and again illumined with some rare flash of the inner light "which lighteth every man that cometh into the world," but this transient awakening leaves no permanent impress on the features. Without expecting, however, to meet with any outer and visible sign of spiritual aspiration and endeavor, one might imagine that traces of decision and certainty of aim would be frequent. This is not so. Indecision
301 is clearly shown in nearly every face, and, paradoxical as it may seem, in this fact lies the hope of the future. Once in a long while one meets a man whose every feature and movement proves that he knows exactly what he wants, is determined to get it and that he has concentrated the whole force of his nature on its attainment. He is absolutely one-pointed in his aspiration, and therefore he must triumph in the end. As in the vast majority of cases such a man's aim is low and "of the world, worldly," he throws love, affection, conscience, duty to the winds and makes straight for his point. He is a strong man, and no ordinary man, who wavers between conscience and desire, can compete with him. If the whole race were resolute in its striving after material things, its damnation would be assured; it is because men doubt the solidity of the ground on which they now stand that they sometimes turn their eyes heavenward and long for a security and a peace which this world does not afford. In the course of ages, as they learn to look with more persistence, they will find their peace. Even those who keep their eyes turned earthwards, look in a dozen different directions instead of one—with the exception of the man with one desire. They strive for wealth, and what they call "love" intervenes to divert their aim; they strive for what they believe to be love's realization, and expediency divides their interest; they strive for place and power, and the fear of public opinion stays them at the crucial moment. They are the world's weaklings. Saddest of all is the plight of the strong man who with one-pointed endeavor at last attains the object of his heart's desire. As it is a material thing it cannot be permanent, and furthermore he must tire of it in time, for, as Emerson said, the soul was born to embrace the whole and not a pail. This thing for which he has so wonderfully striven will become more bitter than death to him, and he will suffer as few can suffer, because few are strong. If, with the same power and simplicity of purpose, he had aspired towards the permanent and the eternal, how great would have been his reward! But doubtless he had first to learn his lesson.
The multitude of man's desires! And all of them efforts to attain the unrecognized ideal—the true Self and the hidden Deity. Man seeks it in woman and woman in man (not that they may not often help each other to find the unknown God within themselves); both seek it in Power and in the praise of their fellow men, in music, in painting, in the mere unintelligent "doing of good," in the favoritism of some man-like God, in forgetfulness. For aeons they have been paying homage to these and many other idols, all-unconsciously worshipping the one ideal, the Soul of things, the
302 World's Desire, as they bowed before them. They have tried to find the ideal in the material, and they have failed and always will fail to do so. Sooner or later they will feel some dim appealing consciousness stirring within their hearts, like the voice of one crying in the wilderness, and they will wake to lend ear to it and to find their ideal as it really is, instead of as they imagine it to be.
It has been reported that, in one of the States of the Union, the Police Department have set women prisoners to breaking stones, the Police Commissioners arguing that "women prisoners kept in idleness were not sufficiently punished." We live in a refined and gentle age, forsooth; we look back with horror and contempt upon the barbarities of ancient Rome; we wax tumultuously indignant over the Sultan's alleged cruelties—and we set our unfortunate women-folk to breaking stones as a punishment for their sins! The men who have done it are doubtless God-fearing citizens, full of virtuous condemnation for such offences as these poor women have committed; they possibly have not committed the same offences themselves, at least they have never been found out, and so from their narrow point of view they are perfectly justified in "punishing" these women as severely as possible. In doing so they simply reflect the hopeless ignorance of the people who elected them to office, who would thoroughly endorse the Mosaic principle of "an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth," regardless of Christ's teaching of compassion and forgiveness. But even in reflecting the stupidity of the majority of their fellow citizens, they might have used discrimination, one would suppose. They need not have chosen the most degrading occupation it would be possible to inflict on a woman. They might have taken into some account the effect of stone-breaking upon the minds and moral natures of their prisoners. By a supreme effort they might possibly have discovered some form of "punishment" which would have kept the women employed and which would have taught them at the same time how to gain an honest living after their discharge. There are surely many feminine occupations which are by no means light work, but which are useful and productive and honorable in the eyes of the world. But these Police Commissioners are mere instruments, and it is their employers'—the people—who are the most to blame. We may at least hope that before too long the great mass of people will appreciate the importance of using their prisons as centres of education—the hospitals of the morally diseased.
E. T. H.
* * * * * * *
303 All through the world to-day is sounding with a persistency that is alarming, a dull heavy note of unrest, unrest. With scarcely an exception, the scenes that flit across the Screen of Time portray the same unrest, the same anxious looking for some change. In one place—Famine, in another revolution and a fight for freedom, here strikes, there disputes, a rush for the new gold fields at Klondyke, speculations in stocks, luxury and sensuous enjoyments for the few, a life-long struggle for a bare subsistence for the many. But back of all these outer and visible signs there is an universal unrest of the souls of men—the spirit of Humanity travailing, with the pangs of childbirth already begun. What will be this child, the Future, so soon to become the present? Is its fate already written in the stars, the irrevocable outcome of the deeds of the past, or is there still time to awaken a new influence which shall run like a golden thread throughout the new era? We do still have this opportunity, a few short months still remain ere the cycle closes in February, 1898. It was recently said by Mrs. Tingley that if we would send forth a note of radiant hope into the next cycle we must concentrate all our efforts upon the work now. We cannot too fully realize how much needs to be done, and the importance of our efforts during the next six months. Let us make every effort to instil into our work the spirit of unity and harmony; let us look to principles and not to personalities; let us put aside personal ambitions and work for humanity; let us seek ever to get into closer touch with the spirit of the; for the more the spirit of harmony prevails, the more the Movement advances and grows and the more humanity is helped.
* * * * * * *
Yesterday, August 8th, another awful picture was flashed across the Screen of Time—"The Assassination of Antonio Canovas del Castillo, Premier of Spain." What does this mean for Spain, and for Cuba? But there is a more important question and one which touches not Spaniards and Cubans only but every human being, for those conditions which resulted in this awful tragedy are to be found in other countries besides Spain—this question:—how can we bring about such a state of things that such an act will be no longer possible, not from forcible restraint but because men's hearts shall be changed, for as says an ancient scripture:—"All creatures act according to their own natures." But let us look at another picture that shone and gleamed on the Screen on that same yesterday. It is a picture that has been growing and gleaming for some time past. It began just as a mighty forest tree begins—as a small seed—but when it is grown the birds of the air lodge in its branches
304 and it becomes a place of shelter where all may seek and find refuge.
It is to this picture that we can turn with hope, a hope that will not fail us, and here we can find that which shall still the unrest of humanity's heart, once more bringing peace and harmony to tired earth. The International Brotherhood League began as a tiny seed, as a single thought, born of the love which Katherine A. Tingley bears for the whole human race. Already the seed has grown and become a strong and vigorous plant as was so clearly shown at the meeting of the League at Lotus Home, August 8th. It is impossible to give detailed accounts of this work in this magazine but we would refer our readers to the Theosophical News. Among those present at the Home yesterday were Mrs. Tingley, E. A. Neresheimer, Mrs. Neresheimer, F. M. Pierce, A. H. Spencer, H. T. Patterson, H. Harney. Mr. Neresheimer, in particular, spoke of splendid work that had already been done.
He said that it was impossible to fully realize the magnitude of the work and that he was only beginning to dimly understand the possibilities that lay before the League but which he was absolutely confident would be carried out. The work of the League was but a continuation of work of the Crusade and under the same guiding hand cannot fail of its accomplishment. The International Brotherhood League is for the binding together of all the nations upon earth and, through it, help will come both to the East and the West, for the East and particularly India, needs our help. India, the seat of so much of the spiritual wisdom of the past but now wasted by famine and plague, despairing, almost hopeless, still has vast stores of knowledge hidden away which can only be brought to light when the misery which now weighs so heavily upon that ancient land, shall be lightened,
* * * * * * *
One of the saddest pictures upon the Screen is India. What a contrast we have had presented to us this year. The Queen's Jubilee with its gorgeous pageantry and India where—for how long?—a fire has been smouldering, and now here and there breaks out and we hear rumors of rebellion and uprisings. And the people all the while growing weaker and weaker, fighting that awful foe—Famine. There is suffering in America, thousands out of work, not knowing where to look for the next meal but all the suffering in this land of ours, if multiplied a thousand-fold would not compare with the awful, indescribable suffering and misery of that ancient land, once beloved, yea still beloved, by the gods, and still in the years to
305 come to lift her head once more and bring back the cycle of her former greatness and wisdom.
One department of the International Brotherhood League is the Bureau of India Relief and Famine Fund and we are glad to be able to print in this issue a letter showing what work has been done by the members of the Indo-American Theosophical Society at Benares, as a result of the Crusade work in India. Twenty-four hundred and fifty-five persons have been relieved by a small band of workers in this city alone and similar work has been done by the members of the League at other of the large cities of India. A little money in India goes a long way, and shall we not, will not you, readers of Theosophy, give some help to relieve this awful suffering.
* * * * * * *
Other work of the League being done in New York and soon to be inaugurated in all the large cities of America, is among the unfortunate classes, men and women. Dr. Robt. A. Gunn, a prominent New York physician, is giving his services free to this work. A centre has been opened in East 14th Street, the centre of one of the most thickly populated tenement house districts in this city, and here treatment is given to those enslaved by the alcohol habit. Dr. Gunn treats this as a disease and has effected some remarkable and complete cures. There has also been organized a band of ladies to work among the unfortunate women of the city. Is not the true way to help these our unfortunate sisters, to first recognize the indissoluble link that binds all, rich and poor, strong and weak, pure and impure, into one Universal Brotherhood? To do this, to help as far as in each one lies, to practice Brotherhood, is the work of the International Brotherhood League. Every one can help in this work and there is work for every one to do. Mrs. Tingley informs me that not later than September 15th, full particulars in regard to the work of the International Brotherhood League will be sent to all members and that possibly a lecturer will be sent to visit all Branches.
J. H. F.
375 On the death of Mr. E. B. Rambo every Theosophist has lost a comrade, though the world has not lost its friend; for his heart was so full of gentle tenderness that the influence of his life on earth was at all times but the shadow of his influence in the world of the real, where the soul lives and works in the midst of "life" as in the midst of "death."
Workers for Theosophy and Brotherhood may be divided into two great classes; those who talk or write and think in order to talk or write; those who in any case think and feel and do or do not talk or write, as duty demands. The work of the former class is transient, does not arise from the soul and never reaches its; the work of the latter is not touched by death, because it springs from and deals with that which death can never touch.
E. B. Rambo belonged to the latter class, and therefore in no real sense is he lost to the work, though as friends we must inevi- 376tably mourn his loss. To recite his virtues would be useless. Those who knew him know what they were, and those who knew him not would hardly understand the steadfast, cheerful devotion and unfailing common-sense of this Quaker-Theosophist, who never said an evil thing of any man, and who refused to impute evil motives to his worst enemies.
A brief account of the Convention of the Theosophical Society in Europe, which took place on the 8th and 9th of August, at Stockholm, will be found in the "Mirror of the Movement." As a Convention it was a great success, though everyone deeply regretted Mrs. Tingley's unavoidable absence. The members there are in hopes that she may be able to visit them later on in the year.
Stockholm proved itself an ideal place for a Convention. Its people are some of the most hospitable in the world; its means of transport and communication have been brought to a rare point of perfection, and the national exhibition had naturally attracted a very large number of tourists from all parts of Europe, who helped to swell our audiences and to add an international character to the Convention proceedings.
The members of the Society in Sweden—of which Dr. G. Zander is the President—have done marvels under somewhat disadvantageous circumstances. They loyally supported the late W. Q. Judge at a time when he was being most bitterly and recklessly persecuted. They were not personally acquainted with him; they certainly had the advantage of acquaintance with his enemies, which may have slightly biassed their judgment in his favor, but fundamentally they acted on the broad principles of brotherhood, refusing to judge or condemn a fellow-worker, remaining indifferent to one-sided testimony, and taking their stand upon the impregnable rock of brotherly love and attention to duty. They of course met with their reward, in a great increase of energy and unity among them and in other and less evident ways. But they still have to encounter an unnecessary and regrettable opposition at the hands of those who, either lacking their loyalty or misinformed as to the facts, joined the ranks of Mr. Judge's antagonists and took part in the common outcry against him.
In spite of this they have rapidly gained in strength, both numerically and in their influence upon the public; so that it would be difficult to find, at the present time, a more devoted, energetic and united body of people within the entire movement than that formed by the members of the T. S. in Europe (Sweden). The King of Sweden showed his appreciation of their work by sending 377a most cordial telegram of congratulation and good wishes in reply to a message of greeting addressed to him by the Convention.
* * * * * * *
There was once a member of the Theosophical Society who worked hard for its success for some time. About the best work he ever did was contained in a series of articles which appeared in this magazine, giving ridiculous extracts from letters addressed to the office. In them he made our readers laugh, and it is said that laughter is very good for the soul, as well as for the digestion. So for that work he has always had our cordial thanks. He related the troubles of an editor, which are in all cases many, but which are apt to become amusing when the periodical edited deals with the subject of Theosophy. Much is expected of the occupant of the editorial chair, as the following communication shows. It was written in ungrammatical Russian, and mailed at some outlandish place, five hundred miles from anywhere. Needless to say that this correspondent is not known to any member of the staff.
Supremely Dear Friend.—I ask you to hand over to me the central governing of the Theosophical Society for all who speak Russian and all Slavonic languages and French and modern Greek. I love you and understand you; I defend Blavatsky, understanding her in myself and in all, and myself in her and in all, controlling myself in a purely spiritual way in all spheres of life and knowing that Love of Unity is the Truth of all Truths. Rejoice yourself.
The following correspondence speaks for itself, and is inserted here in explanation of a change in the editorship of this magazine which is about to take place:
144 Madison Avenue, New York City.
August 29th, 1897.
To the Members of the Theosophical Society in America:
Fellow Workers:—On account of serious financial events in America which concern me intimately, I shall be obliged to enter the business world and devote my energies to business occupations for some time to come. It will therefore become necessary for me to resign the office I now have the honor to hold as President of the Theosophical Society in America. My resignation as President will be formally submitted at the next annual Convention of the Society. You will then be called upon to elect my successor to the office, and on that account I now give you early notice of my intention. Similar notice is being sent to the members of the Theosophical Societies in Europe and Australasia.
378It will always be my most earnest desire to resume an active share in the work of theosophical propaganda, to which, as many know, my heart must ever be devoted; and I shall of course continue to devote all the time, money and thought at my disposal to the work of the theosophical movement.
Wonders have been achieved in the past twenty-two years in the cause of brotherhood, of freedom, of justice, and towards bringing humanity to a realization of its own perfectibility, by and through the Theosophical Society, as a part of that theosophical movement throughout the world, which has existed in all ages. We have to thank the great leaders of this movement, Madame H. P. Blavatsky, William Q. Judge and now Mrs. Katherine A. Tingley—for this magnificent record. What they have done for us and our work we cannot sufficiently estimate. The unfailing devotion and self-sacrifice of members could not have achieved these results unaided. Wise leadership and the power and guidance necessary to lead was required, and they gave and still give all this and more, absolutely assuring the success of the work in the future. I have written much in the past concerning these leaders of the movement, and in this, probably my last official communication to the members of the Theosophical Society in America, I desire to endorse and to emphasize once more all that I have ever written or said concerning them. I also wish to take this early opportunity to thank you, the members of the Society, for the kindly, considerate and loyal assistance you have rendered me as your officer in carrying out my duties as President. That you will extend the same fraternal help to whomsoever you may elect to succeed me I do not doubt.
I now ask you to believe me,
As ever fraternally yours,
(Signed) E. T. Hargrove,
President of the Theosophical Society in America.
144 Madison Avenue, New York.
September 1st, 1897.
To the Vice-President and members of the Executive Committee of the Theosophical Society in America:
Dear Sirs and Brothers:—The enclosed communication [given above] was recently sent by me to a few friends in the Society—yourselves among the number—for their personal information, as "what will probably be sent to all members in the course of a few months." It speaks for itself and shows the necessity for my resignation as President of the T. S. in America. It requires modification in one respect.
379I had intended to defer my resignation until April in order to create as little inconvenience as possible; but thanks to the kindness and self-sacrifice of my friend and comrade, Mr. E. A. Neresheimer, the Vice-President of the Society, and to his ever-ready willingness to take yet more burdens upon his shoulders, I am enabled to resign almost immediately and so (under By-Law 14) leave the current business of the Society in the faithful hands of the Vice-President, to whom I particularly desire to express my thanks for this favor.
My resignation will take effect on the 13th September. With the most cordial expression of good will and affection to you all, believe me as ever,
Fraternally yours,
(Signed) E. T. Hargrove,
President of the Theosophical Society in America.
September 9, 1897.
Mr. E. T. Hargrove, President of the Theosophical Society in America:
Dear Sir and Brother:—We are in receipt of your communication of Sept. 1, 1897, tendering your resignation as President of the T. S. in A., to take effect on the 13th inst.
It is with great regret that we notify you of the acceptance of same, particularly because you are obliged to take this step on account of personal duties.
It is yet fresh in our minds that at the time of your entering into the office of President, our leader, Mrs. Katherine A. Tingley, held that you were the only one to fill the office to its full and requisite extent, and she and the Executive Committee had hoped that your official activity might have lasted until the end of the term, April, 1899.
As comrades and co-workers we express to you herewith our appreciation of and gratitude for the services which you have rendered the T. S. in A., and take this opportunity to tender our best wishes for your future success.
Sincerely and fraternally,
(Signed) E. Aug. Neresheimer,
For the Executive Committee.
For the same reason as given in the first of the above communications, it has become necessary for me to resign the editorship of Theosophy; but I do not think that anything but good can arise from this as Mrs. K. A. Tingley and Mr. E. A. Neresheimer have kindly consented to act as co-editors, beginning with the November issue. The proprietors are particularly indebted to 380Mrs. Tingley for accepting their urgent invitation to look after the interests of the magazine, for the responsibilities of the post can only add yet another toilsome duty to her already extraordinary load of work.
Under the able management of Mrs. Tingley and Mr. Neresheimer Theosophy will undoubtedly gain in popularity and in usefulness. Its progress will always be a matter of the most profound interest to me. My pen, as heretofore, will invariably be at the free disposal of its editors. I beg to most earnestly and sincerely thank our many readers for the splendid support they have given the magazine since the time of its enlargement last June, which I trust they will give even more freely in the future. In this way Theosophy will become a power for good among all English-speaking people and a messenger of hope to many thousands in all parts of the world who long for truth, light and liberation.
E. T. Hargrove.
10th September, 1897.
Footnotes
- ↑ Letters that have helped me, p. 29.
- ↑ For a report of this Convention see The Mirror of the Movement.
- ↑ In the early days of the Theosophical Society its members were regularly initiated, receiving passwords, etc. Those who know those passwords should note that to India, America is the "East."
- ↑ Theosophist, Vol. I, pp. 159, 170, 224, 277.